Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the regulation of globalized capitalism, in Davos on January 27, 2010.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

27 January 2010 · Davos Forum 40th session opening speech · Davos, Switzerland

Context
Sarkozy addressed the 40th World Economic Forum in Davos on January 27, 2010, calling for fundamental reform of globalized capitalism following the financial crisis.
Main themes
Regulation of globalized capitalism, financial crisis lessons, globalization imbalances, financial deregulation critique, short-termism in finance, market-value accounting flaws, capital vs. labor inequality, speculation vs. productive investment, global economic governance reform, role of the state in crisis intervention
Duration
~37 min
88th percentile
Words
4,380
88th percentile
Sentences
246
93rd percentile
Readability
55
76th percentile
Grade
10.0
20th percentile
Syntax
2.87
30th percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
42nd percentile

World Economic Forum · Davos Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 63%59%
  • Institutional 17%16%
  • Social 10%9%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Environmental 3%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

246 sentences in 88 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

Of course, allow me to thank Professor Schwab and all the organizers of the Davos Forum for inviting me to deliver the opening speech of this 40th session.

Let me be clear: I did not come here as a political leader to lecture anyone, but to tell you that together we must learn the lessons of the crisis. Why must we learn the lessons together? Because we are all responsible. And because, above all, we are responsible for the world we will leave to our children.

Ladies and Gentlemen, without the intervention of states, everything would have collapsed. This is not a question of liberalism, statism, socialism, left or right; it is a reality. And failing to draw from the events we experienced a year ago the conclusion that we need to change profoundly, then if we do not change, we would be irresponsible.

This crisis is not just a global crisis.

This crisis is not a crisis in globalization.

This crisis is a crisis of globalization.

It is our worldview that, at a certain point, failed.

It is our worldview that we must therefore correct.

There is no prosperity without an effective financial system, without the free movement of people and goods, without competition that challenges vested interests.

But finance, free trade, and competition are means; they are not ends in themselves. Let us not confuse the means of doing with the objective we must set for ourselves.

Globalization went off the rails the moment it was accepted that the market was always right without condition, without reservation, and that no other reason could be opposed to it.

Let us try to trace back to the source: it is the imbalances in the global economy that have fueled the development of global finance. We deregulated finance to more easily finance the deficits of those who consumed too much with the surpluses of those who consumed too little. The perpetuation and accumulation of imbalances have been both the engine and the consequence of financial globalization.

Globalization was first the globalization of savings. I want to be very clear that the globalization of savings has created a world where everything was given to financial capital, everything, and almost nothing to labor, where the entrepreneur came after the speculator, where the rentier took precedence over the worker, where leverage - the term "leverage," everyone was talking about it - reached unreasonable proportions, and all this led to a capitalism in which it became normal to play with money, preferably other people's money, to earn easily, extremely quickly, without effort and often without any creation of wealth or jobs, vast amounts of money absolutely considerable.

One of the most striking characteristics in my eyes of this capitalism that we have allowed to emerge is that the present was everything and the future no longer mattered. Everything for the present immediately, nothing for the future. We read, I want to point out, Professor Schwab, this devaluation of the future in the absolutely exorbitant demands for returns. This return boosted by speculation and leverage was the discount rate of future income: the higher they rose, the less the future mattered. Everything, right now.

We read this devaluation of the future in accounting. Fantastic! We have come, Ladies and Gentlemen, to evaluate a company's assets at market price, forgetting that the market changes constantly based, for example, on stock market frenzies. When euphoria took hold of the markets, balance sheets were revalued, and the revaluation of balance sheets in turn boosted stock prices. When distrust prevailed, balance sheets were depressed, and the depreciation of balance sheets in turn caused stock prices to fall.

We felt the harmful effects of this accounting during the financial crisis when the collapse of the markets melted the capital of banks, and the credit crisis was aggravated. And we were told: "But be careful, the banks are worth nothing anymore; they can no longer lend anything." So, companies could no longer seek credit since they were not being lent to. They were not lending because the value of the banks had disappeared. The value of the banks had disappeared because it was itself discounted based on the stock price of the day, what am I saying, of the afternoon, of the morning, of the hour, of the minute.

It was our entire system of representations that was distorted. May I assert, while apologizing to you for this overly simple idea, that the economic value of a company does not change from second to second, from minute to minute, from hour to hour... To measure how absurd this accounting can be, it is enough to know that with the market value system, a struggling company can record an accounting profit simply because the degradation of its credit rating decreases the market value of its debt! One had to think of that.

It was our entire system of statistical measurement that was biased.

In the statistics, we saw incomes rising.

But in life, people saw inequalities widening.

In life, we saw this, and in the statistics, the standard of living was rising, but the number of those who increasingly felt the harshness of life continued to grow.

Let us reread the report of the Commission chaired by Joseph Stiglitz, and let us question our way of measuring our economy and its results. It is fundamentally about questioning our purposes. What do we want to do with capitalism?

I say this reflection cannot be the sole domain of experts, of statisticians. We must move beyond the civilization of experts who only discuss among themselves, each in their specialty.

We must reflect together; these are not just technical problems. And we must do this because if we do not, we are taking unsustainable risks with the future. If we do not change banking regulations, if we do not change prudential rules, if we do not change accounting rules - but this is not just a matter of techniques, it is not just a matter of experts - where do we want to lead the capitalism that is ours? What do we want to make of it? What are the purposes we pursue?

We will not defeat hunger in the world if we do not manage to stabilize the prices of raw materials that fluctuate erratically. This is not a matter for experts.

We will not preserve the future of the planet if we do not pay the true price of scarcity. This is not a matter for experts. It is our concern for all.

We will not reconcile citizens with globalization, with capitalism, if we are not able to bring counterweights, even corrections, to the market.

Ultimately, by offloading all our responsibilities onto the market, we have created an economy that has ended up functioning against the values to which it referred.

For example, we excessively mutualized risk, thus diluting responsibility. If risks are shared infinitely, there is no longer any responsible party. If there is no longer any responsible party, we are no longer in a market economy.

By placing the freedom of trade above all, we have weakened Democracy, because citizens expect Democracy to protect them.

By prioritizing short-term logic, we have exhausted non-renewable resources and damaged the environment. There can be no sustainable development when immediate profit and shareholder value are the only criteria. I do not say that these are illegitimate criteria; I say that they cannot be the only criteria.

By excessively deregulating, what happened? We had dumping, and competition that was no longer fair but unfair. We allowed a globalization based on external growth to take hold, where everyone seeks to develop by taking companies, jobs, and market shares from others, rather than by working harder, investing more, increasing productivity, and enhancing innovation capacity.

The globalization we dreamed of was one where, instead of taking from others through monetary, social, fiscal, and ecological dumping, everyone would support their development on social progress, on increasing purchasing power, on improving quality of life.

Look: at the ILO, at the IMF, at the World Bank, at the FAO, at the G20, ultimately, Ladies and Gentlemen, we are discussing the same thing from different aspects: the great question of the 21st century: how to put the economy back at the service of man? This is the question posed to all leaders. How to ensure that the economy no longer appears as an end in itself but as a means? How to move towards a globalization where everyone, in developing, will contribute to the development of others? How to build a globalization that must be more cooperative because it is too conflictual today?

Let us be clear, and I want to be understood here: it is not a matter of asking ourselves what we will replace capitalism with but of knowing: "What capitalism do we want?"

The crisis we are going through is not a crisis of capitalism. It is a crisis of the denaturation of capitalism.

Capitalism has always been inseparable from a system of values, from a project of civilization, from a certain idea of man.

Purely financial capitalism is a drift that flouts the values of capitalism. But anti-capitalism is an even worse dead end. There is no solution in anti-capitalism. There is no system other than the market economy.

But we will save capitalism and the market economy by refounding it, dare I say the word, by moralizing it. I know that this term can raise many questions.

But what do we fundamentally need, if not rules, principles, governance that reflect shared values? And if we were to establish a common morality?

We cannot govern the world of the 21st century with the rules of the 20th.

We cannot govern globalization while keeping half of humanity at bay.

We cannot make decisions about globalization without India, without Africa, or without Latin America. It is madness.

We cannot look at the world after the crisis as we did before the crisis.

The world of tomorrow will not be that of yesterday.

We must take our responsibilities. There are indecent behaviors that will no longer be tolerated by public opinion, my dear friends, in any country in the world, even the largest.

There are excessive profits that will no longer be accepted because they will be out of proportion to the ability to create wealth and jobs.

Let us go a little further. There are compensations that will no longer be tolerated because they will be unrelated to merit. But for those who create jobs, for those who create wealth to earn a lot of money, that is normal; there is nothing shocking about it. And we must educate on this. What is profoundly abnormal is that someone who earns a lot of money when things are going well considers it natural to continue earning a lot of money when things are going badly. No one can accept that. Big compensation, big responsibilities. Someone who contributes to destroying jobs and wealth without facing any consequences from the situation is morally unacceptable.

I thank the two people who applaud this. You know, there was the great president of a major French bank whose resignation I called for because one of his bank's employees alone was able to commit a fraud that cost the bank several billion euros. It is not normal that with such dysfunction, this person remains in place, or else we are no longer in a system of responsibilities. At the same time, I defended a French industrialist who heads one of the major French companies, with a more comfortable salary, because he is a man of recognized competence.

In the same way, bonuses. When we make a list of bonuses for all those who helped make a company profitable, that is perfect. But when the company loses, one should not come and explain to me that we were able to make the list of bonuses and that we are unable to make the list of penalties. When one wins every time, we are not in a market economy. We deceive people, and morally, we are indefensible. Those who act like this, Ladies and Gentlemen, destroy the values of the market economy that we all defend together. It is the caricature of what we defend, and a small minority can distort, in the eyes of international public opinion, a system that has proven itself.

In the future, there will be a much greater demand that incomes be proportionate to social utility, to merit; a greater demand for justice; a greater demand for protection.

So I believe, Professor Schwab, that we have no choice. Either we will change ourselves, or changes will be imposed on us. By what? By whom? By economic crises, by political crises, and by social crises. Let us choose immobility, and the system will be swept away, and it will have deserved it!

Either we will be able, through cooperation, regulation, and governance, to respond to the demand for protection, justice, and loyalty, or we will have protectionism, closure, and each for themselves. I am in favor of free trade, the freedom of exchange, but is there anyone who can assert that public opinion will accept that certain countries exempt themselves from all rules to flood the markets of others that respect rules? Protectionism, which should not be wished for under any circumstances, will come from these dysfunctions.

The G20 foreshadows the planetary governance of the 21st century. Without the G20, each for themselves would have prevailed; without the G20, it would not have been possible to regulate bonuses, to tackle tax havens, or to change accounting rules.

But from Davos, I want to say one thing: it is all well and good to make decisions, but those decisions must be implemented. I want to take this opportunity to affirm that if the signs of recovery that seem to mark the end of the global recession are here, this should not lead us to be less bold but even more so. More so to reform our social protection systems, to clean up our public finances, to be more rigorous in the fight against tax fraud, to invest in the future. If we do not do this, the recovery will only be a respite.

So, the commitments made must be kept.

I will take examples. If the absolutely crucial debate on accounting standards gets bogged down, if private bodies to which we have delegated regulatory power deliberately violate a mandate given by heads of state and government and we let them do so, there will be nothing left of the credibility of the G20. And if there is nothing left of the credibility of the G20, we will lose the beginning of a global economic government, and that will be a catastrophe.

If competition is distorted by prudential rules that remain different from one country to another, from one continent to another, while we have decided otherwise. For example, we must agree on a common definition of capital, and if we do not agree on that, then so many actors will find it normal to return to their habits from before the crisis. I will not be satisfied with a symbolic and political decision; I will demand that it be put into practice.

How, for example, in a competitive world, can we require European banks to hold three times more capital to cover the risks of their market activities and not require the same from American or Asian banks? Who could understand that? It would be a scandal, and we cannot accept it.

How can we accept that the obligation for banks to retain a portion of the loans they have securitized may not be included in the regulations of G20 member countries when this principle has been the subject of unanimous agreement? We cannot accept it! Only, the difference is that, for example, France will not say, "Oh, I will wait for others to do it before I do!" We will do it; we will scrupulously respect the rules. But we will take the global public opinion as a witness, and those who do not apply the rules we have defined together and adopted unanimously will have to explain themselves to their public opinions.

If we create standards that do not learn from the crisis and lead long-term investors to reduce their equity portfolios—which is unbelievable—then we should not be surprised that prices are even more unstable and that a large number of companies find themselves more subjected to speculative pressure. If the consequence we draw from the crisis is to ask investors to invest less in equities, it means we have not understood well what happened a year ago.

Not doing what we have decided would be an economic fault, a political fault, a moral fault.

At heart, we know well what we have to do together.

To end a system without rules that drags everyone down and replace it with rules that lift everyone up. So, I know that, as a Frenchman, I am suspected in this regard, but please, can we try to promote this reasonable idea? That if too many rules kill dynamism, the absence of rules kills capitalism! This is not a difficult idea to understand on all continents, is it?

So, it is not a matter of having the same labor law everywhere; that is obvious.

But at the same time, here in Davos, I would like to pose this question. How can we accept that about fifty member states of the ILO—members of the ILO!—have not even ratified the eight standards that define fundamental labor rights? I completely understand that a country that is not a member of the International Labour Organization does not adopt the standards, but when one is a member of an organization, adopts rules, and does not ratify the standards! But who can believe your word? What kind of system is this? This is not regulated globalization; it is the jungle.

In Copenhagen, quantified commitments on climate were made by 192 countries. How can we enforce these commitments without a World Environment Organization that France is calling for? How can we not see that the possibility of establishing a carbon tax at the borders against environmental dumping is a strong invitation for each country to respect the common rule?

The decisive advance in my eyes would be to place environmental law, labor law, and health law on an equal footing with trade law. This is a revolution in global regulation, and it implies that specialized institutions can intervene in international disputes, particularly commercial ones, through preliminary questions. The international community cannot continue to be schizophrenic; yes, we are schizophrenic! We deny at the WTO or the IMF what we decide at the WHO or the ILO. But they are the same! They are the same countries, they are the same leaders; we cannot hold two completely different discourses in the same year depending on whether we are in a different forum; that is not how we restore trust and rise to our responsibilities.

Of course, we will need to help poor countries.

Of course, the question of innovative financing is central, given all the money we have committed with our budgets to avoid catastrophe. We will not escape the debate on taxing speculation. Wanting to curb the frenzy of financial markets to finance development aid is rather good news, and I want to express how much I support the initiatives of England and Gordon Brown.

To conclude, there is another question that we can no longer evade. I know I am addressing a highly qualified audience, but still, this question must be asked. What role should banks play in the economy? It is not a dirty word. What is the job of a banker? Let us return to fundamentals; the job of a banker is not to speculate; it is to analyze credit risk, to measure borrowers' ability to repay, and to finance the development of the economy. If financial capitalism has experienced such a drift, it is because banks were no longer doing their job. Why take the risk of lending to entrepreneurs when it is so easy to make as much money playing with stock market levels? Why lend only to those who can repay when it is so easy to take risks off your balance sheet? The very notion of off-balance-sheet is something I find hard to understand, and when I understood it, hard to accept. Why make rules if a whole part of your activity is outside the rules, off-balance-sheet?

I agree with President Obama when he deems it necessary to dissuade banks from speculating for themselves or financing hedge funds.

Ladies and gentlemen, if we perpetuate the imbalances that are at the root of the problem, we will not succeed. Surplus countries must consume more. Deficit countries must consume less and repay their debts.

So, another sensitive topic. Money, do we have the right to talk about money? But I say it is a duty; I do not understand why talking about money is considered a problem in itself. Is it always a problem when we do not talk about things? And when we refuse to think about them? Money is at the heart of these imbalances. There will be no reordering of finance and the economy if we allow the disorder of currencies to persist. Exchange rate instability, the undervaluation of certain currencies prevents trade from being fair, prevents competition from being fair. Saying this is common sense. It is employment and purchasing power that serve as the adjustment variable to what I will call, excuse the expression, monetary manipulation. The prosperity of the post-war period owes much to Bretton Woods, to its rules and its institutions.

Well? We need a new Bretton Woods. We cannot have, on one side, a multipolar world and, on the other, a single reference currency on a global scale. We cannot advocate free trade on one side and accept monetary dumping on the other. France, which will preside over the G8 and G20 in 2011, will therefore place the reform of the international monetary system on the agenda, which is a fascinating and absolutely decisive subject for all countries in the world. I hope that in Davos, this will be a great topic, for example, for the 41st edition.

Until then, and I will conclude, we will need to carefully manage the exit from support measures for activity and the withdrawal of the excess liquidity injected during the crisis. My conviction is that a too abrupt tightening risks causing everything to collapse again.

We will have to bring forth a new model of growth, to invent the state, the business, and the city of the 21st century.

My dear friends, a few years ago, the end of nations was predicted, and intellectuals spoke of the advent of nomadism. But in the crisis, I want to pay tribute to companies, the most globalized companies, the most global banks that rediscovered with disconcerting ease that they had a nationality. None went to the wrong counter! The thread was not broken; everyone knew well where they were from. And the discourse: "we are large companies that span continents and we have no nationality," at the first headwind, the discourse disappeared.

But a few years ago, the decline of organizations, the end of companies was announced. They wanted to apply the principles of portfolio management to them. We are rediscovering today, fortunately, that companies are human communities, living organisms, that need a leader, a chief, a boss, an entrepreneur, and that depend on the know-how of their employees. A company lives. It is a community. It breathes. It creates wealth. It must have a purpose that is not simply a stock price, even if the stock price is important.

A few years ago, it was predicted that the city would disperse, unravel, and with it social ties, human relationships, and local connections. We are rediscovering today the need for conviviality, for urbanity.

At heart, it was citizenship that seemed destined to dissolve in the global market. Citizenship has been revitalized in the trial of the crisis. And the great lesson is that tomorrow we will once again have to reckon with citizens in all our countries.

Citizen is not a separate category; it is each one of us. The business leader, the shareholder, the employee, the unionist, the associative activist, the political leader, is a citizen who has responsibilities towards others, towards his country, towards future generations, towards the planet.

The world of tomorrow will have to reckon with citizens, with the moral demand, with the demand for responsibility, with the demand for dignity of citizens. I propose to you, ladies and gentlemen, to view this not as one more problem but as part of the solution, to see the emergence of this new global citizen not as an additional difficulty but as something healthy, good news, something virtuous. And do you know why? Because, perhaps, the emergence of this more lucid, more realistic, more aware, more demanding citizen will lead us to feel happier about who we are, and above all, happier about what we accomplish.

Thank you.

I apologize; I would like everyone to understand one thing: in the world that is ours—I will not start again!—the differences between Anglo-Saxons and continental Europeans are completely fading. It strikes me a lot that in the face of a great problem, we found ourselves on equal footing. There you go.

I would also ask you, Professor Schwab, not to forget the Global Fund, the Millennium Development Goals, and to ensure that we, the States, will be there, but that the generous donors can make sure - I know that Mélina GATES is coming tomorrow - but let us not forget that in Davos, there is a human purpose to all of this, that we are not just technicians thinking about the creation of wealth, but you are legitimate in asking the question of the distribution of wealth. Never let yourselves be trapped in a caricature. The opponents of the market economy would be all too happy about that; it would be too serious if that were the case.

Thank you. Now, I really have to go.