Press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, notably on the reform of global governance, the fight against the proliferation of nuclear weapons, the reduction of budget deficits, and the regulation of financial markets, in Muskoka on June 27, 2010.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

27 June 2010 · Press conference at the G8 summit · Muskoka

Context
Sarkozy addressed a press conference at the G8 summit in Muskoka, Canada on June 27, 2010, outlining key outcomes on governance, development, and security.
Main themes
Global governance reform, G20 and G8 coordination, UN Security Council reform, nuclear non-proliferation and Iran sanctions, budget deficit reduction, financial market regulation, development aid and Millennium Development Goals, maternal and child health, drug trafficking and organized crime, Africa development, food security, HIV transmission prevention
Duration
~30 min
82nd percentile
Words
3,558
82nd percentile
Sentences
157
82nd percentile
Readability
51
66th percentile
Grade
11.6
39th percentile
Syntax
3.17
69th percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
46th percentile

G7 / G20 Summit Communiqués Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

157 sentences in 47 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT -- Hello to everyone here and also to everyone in Toronto.

This is the first time that the G8 has met in its refocused version, now that the G20 has taken over economic and financial issues. We were thus able to exchange very freely on all the topics that the G8 intends to prioritize from now on.

The reform of global governance, which was a topic that was not discussed, an extremely sensitive topic, was the subject of a very long and in-depth discussion last night. You know my conviction, the reform of global governance is not an option, it is a necessity, it is an urgency. This reform, we have initiated in the economic field with the creation of the G20, which France proposed. It has allowed for the reform of international financial institutions: the World Bank, we have just completed the process that has allowed for a significant transfer of voting rights to emerging and developing countries; the reform of the IMF which must be completed at the G20 in Seoul next November.

We must go further and we can no longer wait to launch the reform of the United Nations system. This primarily concerns the Security Council, whose reform has been absolutely blocked for twenty years. It also concerns the specialized agencies or institutions of the UN galaxy.

Regarding the Security Council, France and the United Kingdom have proposed an interim reform. This is the best way - probably the only way -- to break the current deadlock. Chancellor MERKEL supports this interim reform procedure. We have made it a priority for the French presidencies of the G8 and G20 in 2011, and Stephen HARPER, by the end of his presidency, will try to bring viewpoints closer on the issue of interim reform of the Security Council. Things have really progressed, at least within the G8.

Furthermore, during the discussion with our African partners and with representatives from Latin America, I proposed that the interior ministers meet to concretize an alliance to combat drug trafficking, organized crime, and terrorism. Cocaine is produced in Latin America, mainly Colombia, Bolivia, and Peru. This drug transits either through the Caribbean platform or, unfortunately, now through West Africa. We will hold a Summit of the concerned Interior Ministers to combat crime mafias.

We also extensively discussed with our African partners the issue of development. A detailed report on the respect of commitments made since the Gleneagles summit in 2005 has been submitted, which is an effort of transparency that I commend. I have requested - and Prime Minister Meles ZENAWI will be the author - that there be a second report for the French G20, but this time not from the donor countries but from the recipient countries of this aid so that it can be reported back to our public opinions.

I would like to take this opportunity to remind you that France has increased its official development assistance since 2007. In three years, we have gone from 0.38% of GDP to 0.5% of GDP in 2010. 12 billion dollars in aid, we are now the second contributor of the G8 in volume as well as in percentage of GDP. More than half of this aid, precisely 52%, goes to Africa, which is a priority for us.

We are implementing the commitment made last year in L'Aquila to dedicate one and a half billion euros over three years to food security. We have already spent 500 million euros.

But our effort in development goes well beyond these figures; it is the initiative I announced in Cape Town in February 2008 to dedicate 2.5 billion euros over five years to the development of the private sector in Africa.

And it is in this spirit that France has given its full support to the Muskoka initiative on maternal and child health. France will contribute 100 million euros per year for five years, which represents 15% of the total G8 effort. This initiative is absolutely essential to combat maternal and child mortality. Every year, 9 million children in the world die before reaching the age of five. For 4 cases of mother-to-child transmission of HIV in France in 2009 - there are in total only 4 cases of mother-to-child transmission of HIV - the same year, the 4 cases in France represent 400,000 cases in Africa, even though we know how to prevent such transmission. This leads me to reaffirm France's commitment to achieving the Millennium Development Goals, and I will, of course, participate at the end of September in New York at the UN summit on this subject.

Finally, we had exchanges on several major issues. Regarding Iran, I recalled how attached we are to the United Nations resolution that was voted for the strengthening of sanctions, but at the same time, how much France is committed to continuing the dialogue. The sanctions are not there to punish a population that is not responsible, but to compel the Iranian leaders to conduct a serious dialogue. France is ready to engage without delay in negotiations with Iran in Vienna at the IAEA based on the Brazilian and Turkish efforts and the comments made by France, Russia, and, of course, the United States.

We were unanimous in condemning North Korea for its irresponsible behavior that led to the death of South Korean sailors.

We also discussed the situation in the Middle East; we spoke with President OBAMA about the initiatives that will need to be taken in the fall.

And finally, France has indicated that the next G8 summit, since it will have the honor of hosting it, will be held in Nice, on a date likely around spring, which we are currently seeking in consensus with our partners.

Ladies and gentlemen, I am at your disposal to answer your questions.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, Barack OBAMA and Angela MERKEL have dominated this G8 by opposing each other on the question of what should be the economic priority. Is it the reduction of deficits that should be the priority as Ms. MERKEL has repeated several times, or is it the return and consolidation of growth as Barack OBAMA advocates? And Barack OBAMA has shown how concerned he is about the deficit reduction policy being pursued in Europe, particularly the German policy. Do you share the American president's concern that the policy being pursued in Europe, particularly by the Germans, could hinder any return to growth?

THE PRESIDENT -- I did not experience the G8 that I participated in since yesterday, at all the meetings, as you describe. I even heard President OBAMA say how necessary it was to conduct a sustainable policy, including for the United States of America. He clearly indicated the risk posed by deficits and debt. Moreover, I find that from this point of view, the report that was made public yesterday or the day before by the IMF is excellent in every respect. What does it say? It says, look, in 2009, we all decided on stimulus plans to face the crisis. That was the Washington summit. In 2010, at the London summit, we all decided to continue these stimulus plans, even in a more moderate way, because growth had not yet returned. Here, we say that we must, in a coordinated manner, prepare the exit scenarios from the crisis.

There is not a single interlocutor around the G8 table who has contested the necessity of reducing debt and deficits. And, at the same time, to do so in a pragmatic way, taking into account the specific situation of each country. I did not hear, for example, Barack OBAMA complain about the financial recovery plan of Greece or Spain. And in the same way, Ms. MERKEL indicated how important it was for Europe to have more growth.

So there you go, we decided to implement a coordinated exit policy from the crisis; everyone agrees that the most indebted and deficit-ridden countries should reduce their deficits. David CAMERON explained his plan to us; they have an 11% deficit, and it would not occur to anyone to reproach the United Kingdom, based on this deficit, for taking corrective measures. I know that all the pre-papers on the G8 were betting on a confrontation. I tell you without any euphemism, that confrontation did not take place. So I will see for the G20, which has not yet started.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, prosecutor COURROYE claims to have transmitted to the tax authorities elements in early 2009 that could constitute tax fraud by Ms. BETTENCOURT. So, to your knowledge, has there been an investigation by the tax authorities on Ms. BETTENCOURT? Was Mr. WOERTH aware? And was he in a conflict of interest knowing that his wife was managing Ms. BETTENCOURT's fortune? And do you still have confidence in Mr. WOERTH? And, second question, you said in London: "Tax havens are over." Is it really over?

THE PRESIDENT -- I see how passionate you are about the G8 discussions. Regarding tax havens, the action that was taken in London is an action that continues. Sanctions are planned for financial centers that do not respect the commitments we have indicated. Regarding France, since we have been constantly at the forefront on this issue, all French banks have taken the responsibility to close all the offices they had in tax havens. And I intend, during the G20, to demand accountability on the application of the various rules, particularly regarding tax havens that thought they could escape by signing, as you know, the twelve agreements on information exchange. Some have done so very seriously and have exited the blacklist and the gray list. Others have done so in a somewhat more suspect manner. I will demand accountability, and those who have not conducted operations seriously will find themselves on the blacklist. We remain perfectly aligned with what we had decided and what I had obtained after a famous battle, you certainly remember, in London. There is not the slightest weakness, and to be clear, including for French-speaking financial centers. No one will escape international control on the subject.

Regarding the controversy over the AFP dispatch, you know that this dispatch was truncated, and you know it even better since it led to a correction from AFP and a clarification from prosecutor COURROYE. So, why are you asking me about an alleged statement from prosecutor COURROYE that has been denied by the same prosecutor COURROYE and about an AFP dispatch that has been corrected by AFP?

QUESTION -- So there is no conflict of interest for Mr. WOERTH and with Ms. WOERTH, and you maintain your confidence in Mr. WOERTH?

THE PRESIDENT -- I was going to answer the question, but it seemed to me that you, who appreciate precision, it seemed important to say things, so I base myself on the latest AFP dispatch and the latest statements from prosecutor COURROYE. Do I maintain my confidence in Eric WOERTH? Yes, totally and completely. There you go. And if you ask me the question again tomorrow morning, I will give you the same answer... And I find that he is conducting the reform of our pensions with a lot of professionalism and calm, and that is precious.

QUESTION -- What was the content of the discussions within the G8 regarding the issue of the bank tax and particularly regarding European positions?

THE PRESIDENT -- Sorry, but we reserved this debate for the G20, and you will understand very simply, because we did not want to give the impression to the G20 members that the G8 was anticipating a discussion that concerns them. So you see that if we had put the question of the bank tax on the table at the G8, the twelve other members -- actually a bit more since there are 25 guests -- the twelve other members of the G20 would have been entitled to say to us: "Well, what does this mean, you are meeting before we can discuss it?"

For the rest, Mr. CAMERON, Ms. MERKEL, and I are determined to obtain a framework that allows for the taxation of banking activities, and whatever decision our partners make, we will implement it. It is perfectly normal that institutions, organizations that have led to the risks we know today can be financially solicited to ensure the funding of insurance funds.

QUESTION -- You just spoke of a desire to establish a framework, but does that mean that during this summit, there is a chance for the bank tax to be adopted? And, on the other hand, since this G20 summit exists only because the Canadians wanted it, is it really useful to hold this summit knowing that there is the more important one in Seoul coming up?

THE PRESIDENT -- The bank tax, you understand well that it is not a question of imposing a tax on a country that does not want to tax its banks. We are not in a world government that could impose a tax on a country. But we want a framework; that is an objective we have, and we will fight to achieve it.

So, this G20, the Canadians wanted it, and I want to pay tribute to them; they organized it very well -- at least the G8, and I am sure the G20 will be organized in the same way - and it is certain that this is a G20, how shall I put it, a milestone between the G20 in London and the G20 in Korea. Why? Because there is a whole process of evaluating what was decided in London and the implementation of which will only take place at the end of the year for the G20 in Korea. But that does not mean that it was useless to meet.

QUESTION -- Regarding North Korea, was there a discussion about the severity and the language in the communiqué, and did France wish it to be harsher? Secondly, did you discuss the new financial legislation in the United States passed by Congress, and does it go as far as France would have liked?

THE PRESIDENT -- On North Korea, there was no disagreement; quite the opposite. The will of all G8 members is to convince our Chinese friends to be as tough as we are towards North Korea and as supportive as we are towards South Korea. I also want to pay tribute to President Lee, who reacted as a statesman while about forty South Korean sailors had died in this tragedy. So there is really a consensus among everyone to condemn the irresponsible actions of North Korea.

Regarding the financial legislation in the United States, you know how much I have appreciated from the beginning President Obama’s willingness to regulate a number of financial and banking activities in the United States, but that will be more the subject of the discussion we will have starting this evening at the G20; it is less a G8 topic.

I remind you that the G8 discusses all issues, and the G20 is a body we have set up to talk about economic issues in the broad sense, which also includes sustainable growth, the environment, currency, and of course energy.

QUESTION -- Concerning Iran, did you talk with your partners about the possibility of going further than the sanctions recently imposed by the United Nations Security Council to really make the Iranian regime bend, which does not seem willing to do so, or will we have to come to terms with the idea of having an Iranian nuclear power?

THE PRESIDENT -- Yes, we discussed it in detail, firstly, to ask all G8 members to ensure that their companies no longer operate in Iran, and we know that the problem still exists. The sanctions were voted by the Security Council; they must be implemented. France, moreover, wishes these sanctions to be stricter regarding banking transactions and that we consider the possibility of reducing our purchases of Iranian crude oil. Europe will adopt stricter sanctions against Iran. President Obama has said how closely he will monitor the concrete and operational implementation of these sanctions, and at the same time, France is leading the call for enhanced sanctions on the Iranian regime, and we maintain that we must continue to dialogue to avoid the tragedy that would be opposition or Iran obtaining nuclear weapons.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, without prejudging the conclusion of the G20, which is only starting shortly, you seemed in your remarks to explain that the aspect of budget consolidation or deficit reduction had slightly taken precedence over the other dimension of the debate, which is to preserve the recovery. All of this is very subtle, and I understand the concern of not letting it appear that there are winners and losers in the debate; that is my first question. And the second: could you help us clarify the distribution of roles between the G8 and the G20 today, but also next year in France, and what are your wishes in this area?

THE PRESIDENT -- You know, the question is not so much whether there are winners or losers; that would be somewhat vain. The question is whether we are conducting good economic policy. It is true that in Washington, the theme was only the recovery plan. It is true that in London, the theme, I myself was, you see, criticized for the French growth support plan being insufficient. Today, there is no one; remember, there were even calls to reduce VAT by two points in France, in light of what the British government under Mr. Gordon Brown had done. So, I completely agree with you, but that is not what we discussed. The question today is no longer about reducing deficits and reducing debt, which no one contests. No one contests the necessity of it. The question is rather: to what extent, to what depth, and of what importance?

And if you look at the text released by the IMF, it is exactly the economic policy being followed in France. What does the IMF say? We must be concerned about the sustainability of our budgets and our debt. We must make deficit reductions not through tax increases but through spending cuts. And we must continue the reform movement, says the IMF, especially pension reform, since pension reform reduces deficits and potential debt without weighing on growth. So we are exactly in line with the IMF's recommendations, and I believe that there is really a consensus among us.

So, the G8 is a bit like a family, the family of eight great democracies that discuss all subjects, political, economic, diplomatic, together, informally, heads of state, heads of government alone. The G20 is an organization that represents the world in its diversity today and whose competencies are essentially economic, financial, monetary, energy-related, including issues of sustainable growth. And the United Nations Security Council is meant to discuss more about peace, borders, politics, and stability in the world.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, I understand that we are in a milestone G20 this time, but you, who are the originator of this G20 format aimed at refounding the global economy, do you not regret that the original momentum has somewhat faded since we are no longer on the brink of the precipice?

THE PRESIDENT -- Frankly, I cannot regret it, to tell the truth. I will speak very frankly; the G20 would never have come into being if there had not been a crisis and if the world had not been on the brink of the precipice. We were able to move forward very strongly, very quickly because there was the risk of a systemic crisis. I am not saying that this risk is completely behind us, but as times are relatively calmer, it is normal that we enter G20s with less dramatic connotations. Nevertheless, France is determined to see through the process of reforming global governance and establishing necessary regulation. We cannot continue to have global markets and only national regulations. The whole objective is to have international regulation that corresponds to international markets. That is what we are in the process of establishing, and the French delegation will also distribute a very well-prepared document that will update you on all the advances in regulation.

Thank you, if there is one last question...

QUESTION -- Mr. President, given the results of the G8 that you have just described, and what you expect from the G20, do you think it was useful, necessary to spend nearly 800 billion euros to organize such a summit, and should the French expect a bill of the same magnitude when the G20 is organized under the French Presidency?

THE PRESIDENT -- That is a very positive question, aimed at bringing me closer to my Canadian friends; I thank you for your contribution in this regard. I will not engage in domestic politics; I do not know how they organized it, what it cost. In any case, I can tell you that we are in a hotel with extremely sufficient, extremely reasonable comfort, and as far as I can see, I have not seen anything lavish or sumptuous. So, regarding the French G8-G20, even if I cannot confirm the figures you mention about the cost of the G20 in Canada, they will be ten times lower, exactly.

Thank you.