CLAUSE 6.—(Accession, of Indian States.)

United Kingdom Winston Churchill

27 February 1935 · House of Commons debate on the Government of India Bill, Committee stage · House of Commons, Palace of Westminster, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill spoke in the House of Commons Committee debate in London on February 27, 1935, opposing Clause 6 of the India Bill on the accession of Indian States and urging the Committee not to pass it.
Main themes
Clause 6 of the Government of India Bill, accession of the Indian Princes, objections of Sir C. P. Ramaswami Ayyar, Committee of Ministers of the Princes, federation and the Indian States, majority voting and parliamentary procedure, Joseph Chamberlain's successor Neville Chamberlain's dismissal of Indian opinion, Conservative party resistance to the Bill, Attorney-General's 'game' taunt, request to withdraw the Clause
Duration
~9 min
30th percentile
Words
1,042
30th percentile
Sentences
56
37th percentile
Readability
68
97th percentile
Grade
8.4
7th percentile
Syntax
2.83
26th percentile
Vocabulary
2.01
11th percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 70%66%
  • Ceremonial 28%27%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

56 sentences in 15 paragraphs

Yes, but there is no reason why the House of Commons should not hear the facts. He said:

These are matters to which we attach vital importance, and I really, for one, cannot understand why Section 6 (1, a) has been allowed to be provided in all its brutal absoluteness.

I do not say whether that is right or wrong. I am not associating myself with the statement. But this is not our man. He is the Government's own man, and he is surprised that the Government have inserted Clause 6 in the Bill "in all its brutal absoluteness." It does not sound very much like mere trouble about drafting Amendments, a little difference here or there or some small matter of adjustment. It is most extraordinary. The quotation goes on:

We cannot accept the entire Act as it has been enacted by Parliament. We have always protested against any acceptance of that kind. We have always held that we will be parties to a federation with regard to specific things and specific provisions. Here we are first asked to accept the entire Act, and then we are allowed to make reservations, not with regard to sections of it, but with regard to one particular Schedule of it, and in regard to all other matters we are asked to accept the Act. I think we have all unanimously agreed that this is a position which under no circumstances whatever we shall be prepared to accept.

Then Sir C. P. Ramaswami Ayyar said:

I appeal with all the force at my command that this Clause 6 is a dangerous innovation"—

1251

What a comment on the brutal ease of a majority to violate the decent sequence of Parliamentary procedure when here at this moment you are going to vote on this Clause and carry it, no doubt with the usual 200 gentlemen. I hope they will long be. Here you are, and at this moment you do not know what are the opinions of the people on whose agreement you depend for the existence of your Bill. The right hon. Member for West Birmingham took a very strong line the other day and said: "We will take our path as the British Parliament and not pay any attention to these opinions." What nonsense, when you have said that the accession of the Princes is vital to your. scheme. How can you stride off and say that you care nothing for all this? But if you are doing your duty and they do not agree, the result is that all that is done will be ploughing the sands, a wasting of the time of Parliament. Sir P. Ramaswami Ayyar said:

I appeal with all the force at my command that Clause 6 is a dangerous innovation. It marks the culmination of a process which began in 1930. From then down to 1934 it has been a progressive inclined plane and we are now at the bottom of the plane. This Clause is full of dangers, and I ask Your Highnesses with all the force at my command not only to disclaim Clause 6, but the spirit underlying this Clause.

Ought we not to know that before we vote upon the Clause? Are we not right to tell this to the House? Is it not relevant to the Debate and to the decision that we have to take? The quotation continues:

It is fraught with the utmost mischief. I am deliberately and firmly of the opinion that those features to which the Committee of Ministers has drawn attention are fundamental and vital, and unless there is a change in the spirit with which the Act is going to be dealt with hereafter, it would be a thousand pities if your Highnesses should join in a compact of which you know not the end.

There are many more opinions of that kind. We are a small minority here, even though, on questions affecting the well-being of the masses of the Indian people, we have associates to whom in other matters we are bitterly opposed. But we are a small minority. You can mock at us because in the Division Lobby we can only produce 50 or 60 Members against hundreds brought up by the Whip and waiting to fall in when the moment comes. We know that. But this

1252

is not going to be fought out by numbers. From the very beginning I have been sure that it is not going to be fought out by numbers. It is going to be fought out by the force of events, and by the decisions which are taken in the minds of men outside this House and by the effect which is produced upon the spirit and determination of the Conservative party. There is what we rely upon in our resistance, and never did I feel more hopeful than I do to-night.

The Attorney-General mocked me—mocked us—the other day. He said: "We see your game." Our game! I suppose for Members of Parliament to devote years of time to this subject and to sacrifice many friendships and, in the case of some of the younger men, their political careers, in order to fight for this issue—that we are told is a game. But for the Attorney-General to take any brief which is offered to him—that is professional business. We have done the best in our power, and it seems to me that we are entitled to-night to ask the Committee not to pass this Clause in view of the vital decisions which depend upon it, and in view of the fact that we do not know any of the essential points upon which our decision ought to rest. The right hon. Gentleman has conducted his case so far with the very greatest skill and the very greatest courage. I am bound to say that I admire his performance in everything except its direction—its objective. But I think he would add greatly to his reputation if he said that in view of the facts placed before him now he did not think that it would be fair to ask the Committee to-night to come to the decision of placing this Clause among the approved Clauses of the Bill.