- Context
- Churchill spoke in the House of Commons Committee in London on February 27, 1935, in the debate on Clause 6 of the Government of India Bill, arguing that the Princes' accession was not to their advantage.
- Main themes
- Accession of the Indian Princes under Clause 6, All-India Federation, Government of India Bill, Instrument of Accession and its 45 topics, labour and social conditions of India's masses, Secretary of State for India, hostility of the Princes to the Bill, debate of States' internal affairs in the Federal Assembly, change in Indian political situation since 1930, statements of the Maharajas of Bhopal and Bikaner
- Duration
- ~18 min
- Words
- 2,175
- Sentences
- 97
- Readability
- 67
- Grade
- 9.1
- Syntax
- 2.83
- Vocabulary
- 2.14
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other97 sentences in 21 paragraphs
We have now reached the conclusion of this Debate on the Question, "That Clause 6 stand part," and I venture to think that there is hardly any other question more momentous than the one with which we have to deal now. Here is the crux of the Debate. We have considered many Amendments, and we have now reached the point where the main issues are clearly before the Committee, and we are entitled to review them, seeing that the, Committee have to take a decision of such consequence. This Clause deals with, as the Chairman has pointed out on several occasions, the accession of the Princes. Without the accession of the Princes there can be no All-India Federation, and without an All-India Federation we are assured, though I do not myself adopt that view, that there can be no hope for the present Government of India Bill. Therefore we are absolutely at the cardinal point of our discussion. The Government attitude throughout has been that it would be of the very greatest advantage to the Princes if they accede to the Federation.
The right hon. Member for West Birmingham (Sir A. Chamberlain), and others who have been enlisted in the Government scheme of very effective orators, through their association with the Joint Select Committee, has expressed on his high authority the view that it would be greatly to the advantage of the Princes if they were to sign the Instrument of Accession. That is the position of the Government. The Princes are, by association with an All-India Federation, to gain great facilities and great improvements in their customs arrangements and so forth, and in joining in general matters of interest for the great sub-Continent of India. 'hat is the position of the Government, their official and public position, but when one has a Debate such as we have had to-day one sees how very thin and threadbare that kind of argument is, what a bold bluff it is, what a sinking there is, what a hollow feeling there is behind all the confident asseverations of the advantage to the Princes, the great demand of the Princes, the surging of these princely figures towards the portals of All-India Federation.
In spite of this tremendous tendency to federation, this irresistible demand
1246
for federation, on the part of the Princes, the Secretary of State, with his liberal and humanitarian sentiments, has not dared to speak a word for the poor millions of India; he has not dared to say one word on their behalf. So near, so narrow, is the margin that he has not dared to say to any of these Princes, not even to the most enlightened of them whose labour conditions are better than those which prevail in British India, "Surely, in your Instrument of Accession you will agree to uniform laws for labour and social and health conditions." He would not dare to do it. The sense of advantages which the Princes have is not strong enough to bear the weight of that demand, and the Secretary of State, intent upon the political aspects of the great design which he has carried so far and fought for so valiantly and bodly, which he has lost himself in, absorbed himself in, has brushed aside all considerations affecting the well-being of the masses of India, who are regarded as pawns in this great game of empire unbuilding. His Majesty's Government do not dare to ask that any steps shall be taken in the Federation to secure decent conditions for the masses of the Indian people. That is an important point. One of the lines of the attack we make on this Bill, not only now but which we shall make as long as it is in any way presented as an issue in our public life, is that the interests of the masses of the people of India have been totally ignored.
The hon. Member for Bodmin (Mr. Isaac Foot) made a speech which I am bound to say did more credit to his fidelity to the engagements and associations into which he has entered than to the interests of working democracy. It was the sort of speech of a very old Liberal school. As long as they could preach liberty they cared little what were the conditions of the poorer people. But I must not allow myself to be drawn outside the scope of the discussion, and I think I rather caught your eye, Mr. Chairman, as though you were, shall I say, on the pounce. Therefore, I will not press my advantage against the hon. Member for Bodmin any further at the moment. I say clearly that the Government do not believe that this will be to the advantage of the Princes, or that the Princes have that idea, because they dare not ask us to insert the provisions.
1247
Indeed, the position of the Princes will be most poignant. I said so in the Debate on the Second Reading, and to-day we have had full confirmation of the fact. I did not know at the time of the Second Reading Debate that the Instrument of Accession would be interpreted to cover the very wide series of subjects, 45 topics, of which the great majority are obligatory. Then there is the expectancy that the voluntary list shall also be acceded to by the Princes.
I did not know, I was surprised like the hon. and learned Member for East Bristol (Sir S. Cripps), that all matters of the internal government of the States would be debatable on every occasion, on almost every pretext upon which you can hang a Parliamentary Debate. As hon. Members know a discussion may be raised on one point and at almost any distance from that point; but little did I realise that this would be possible by direct debate. I thought that by a side wind they would be able to call the Princes over the coals in regard to questions about internal administration, but only by a side wind. To-day the Secretary of State, speaking with great clearness, explained that in all matters of labour legislation and so on the Ministers will be advising the Viceroy and the Assembly will be influencing Ministers, although there is no direct surrender on the part of the States. It is clear that the whole of the affairs of these independent States will be debatable from day to day on the floor of the Indian Assembly. If we tried to debate the affairs of the Irish Free State in this House, I think we should be pulled up. I thought it would be only a limited debate which would prevail in the Federal Legislature as against the States. Not at all. It is -clear that all these matters can be debated. It illustrates the poignant position, the terrible position, of the Indian Princes.
What are they expected to do when they sign the Act of Accession? That is the core of our discussion. They are expected to be the stabilising influence in the Assembly. They are expected to be the conservative and loyal influence. If they move in that direction, and in so far as they do move, they will excite the animosity of those who hate our rule and who hate law and order in every
1248
form. They will be attacked first of all in their States, where disorders will be raised by agitators. They will be attacked in the Central Assembly, where the Secretary of State assures us there will be limitless opportunities for calling in question and debating every one of their actions. In the third place, these matters undoubtedly will have their repercussions over here. When a Prince has stood out for the Imperial -connection and gained unpopularity in India, has been attacked in his own State where agitation has been fomented against him, he may easily find people who will criticise him again over here. A horrible position for the Princes to be placed in. Is it to their advantage? I do not wonder that the Government dare not put another straw on the camel's back and. ask them to agree to decent conditions for the labouring people. The ice is far too thin for that.
But what is their actual view? What has astonished me more than anything else in the course of these discussions, through which we shall arrive at a true conviction of the issues in this enormous Bill, is that the Secretary of State, whose ability is so obvious, whose industry is so praiseworthy, who is so saturated with his subject and whose courage and qualities as administrator and parliamentarian are nowhere more readily admitted than by those who are fighting him in this matter, has not been able, as well as many of those who are acting with him, to understand the simple dynamics of the Indian situation. Why is it that the Princes are now boggling at the Act of Accession? Why are they now rising in such hostility and wrath against it, when you thought you had them all so tame and friendly? Why is it? The right hon. Gentleman said he was surprised. I am not surprised at all, and my friends are not surprised, not because of special information which reached us, but because it is quite clear to anyone who has followed this thing what are the dynamics and the articulations of the Indian situation.
You have a different situation from that of 1930. You are four years removed from then; this is 1935. In 1930 the Indian Princes had an invitation from the advanced political forces of British India to join them in a Federation, which it was believed, in the bad days of the
1249
Irwin-Benn regime of 1930, would have speedily led on to their practically taking over the goodwill of the whole business of British Government in India, lock, stock and barrel. But things have changed since then. They have changed from another cause. They have changed because of the right hon. Gentleman's firm administration and the much improved administration of Lord Willingdon compared with the previous regime, and also because some other people have put up a fight all the time to keep a strong resisting force operative; and now the Princes are not so willing to adopt this instrument of Accession. Why? Whereas they were invited by the political forces in British India in 1930 and 1931, there is no invitation to-day. The invitation is withdrawn; the political forces are not saying to the Princes, "Come on and share this Government of Federal India." They say, "No. Stand out of this. Do not you associate yourselves with this scheme, which we have repudiated. If you do, it will not be comradeship we shall give you. On the contrary we shall pay you out by all the means which this Bill will give us the power to pay you."
That is the explanation of the Princes' change. What is the good of pretending to be surprised at it? It is the working of remorseless laws, and I am astounded that the Government have not seen that that would be the reaction which would occur as a result. of these four years, and of the continued process of change which has governed their own course during that time. What is the present view of the Princes? My right hon. Friend the Secretary of State read this afternoon a telegram which he had received from Reuter's Agency in Bombay. I must say that if it had been an official telegram I should have given it equal credence—yes, equal credence. But we have now in our possession statements made by the leading personages upon this very question of Clause 6 and the act of accession. What. is so remarkable is that it is the very men on whom the right hon. Gentleman has been relying who are now most vehement against the Bill—the Maharaja of Bhopal, the Maharaja of Bikaner, Sir Akbar Hydari and Sir C. P. Ramaswami Ayyar. These are the Ministers and Princes who are most concerned in this matter, who are most in touch with the intelligentsia in British India, the Indian intel
1250
ligentsia. They are the very ones who have most denounced this Measure. That is a great fact. You may vote them down: you may vote us down; you may call your 200 gentlemen from the Lobbies and the smoking-rooms and Library and vote us down, good and plenty. Yes, that is what happens. You may do that, but nothing can alter the facts or the march of events. There is the point. The Maharaja of Bhopal said:
The present scheme as put forward before us in the shape of the Government of India Bill and the draft Instrument of Accession, falls far short of many of our vital demands, and in regard to certain matters ignores agreements reached with His Majesty's government in London.
And then Sir Akbar Hydari, the able Minister, said two days ago:
