- Context
- Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on February 20, 1935, during debate on Clause 5 of the India federation legislation, arguing that the Princes would not be a stabilising element in a federal Assembly.
- Main themes
- Representation of the Indian Princes in the federal Assembly, Princes' demand for responsible government at the Centre, alleged deal between some Princes and Congress, Wedgwood Benn's tenure as Secretary of State for India, Princes as a conservative one-third bloc, Chancellor of the Duchy's argument for a stabilising block of votes, Congress pressure on loyalist Princes, agitation and disorder in princely states, withdrawal of British power from India, Amendment on three-quarters of the Princes
- Duration
- ~5 min
- Words
- 624
- Sentences
- 27
- Readability
- 54
- Grade
- 11.0
- Syntax
- 2.99
- Vocabulary
- 2.21
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other27 sentences in 4 paragraphs
I do not doubt my right hon. Friend's honesty and good faith in the matter, and I hope that such things are not going to be suggested. In this controversy many things have happened during the last four years and I certainly was under the impression, just as honestly or almost as honestly as the right hon. Gentleman, that a higher number of Princes was chosen in the first instance, and, in fact when we put down our Amendment about the three-quarters we understood that we were basing ourselves on the original view. However, the Princes are to be represented, they made this offer and demanded responsible government at the Centre. It reminds me of a saying of the Duke of Wellington to a man who accosted him with, "I believe you are Mr. Smith?" The Duke said, "If you believe that you will believe anything." Why these autocratic Princes should demand responsible government at the Centre I cannot conceive. What happened, as far as we have heard—names have been mentioned, but I will not repeat them—was that some of the Princes, believing that under the Secretary of Stateship of Mr. Wedgwood Benn England was really determined to move out, lock, stock and barrel, met representatives of Congress and did what in ordinary English language is called a deal. The Princes were to be left to run their territories as despotic and hereditary rulers and to help Congress to get responsible government at the Centre. That was the situation which preceeded the so-called offer of the Princes, and that is the explanation, and the only explanation, of their enthusiasm for responsible government.
What will be the plight of the Princes in this new Assembly? Anything more lamentable can hardly be conceived. They will be expected to uphold stability, the Conservative point of view, to sustain
406
the Imperial authority, and be as it were behind the Viceroy. The Chancellor of the Duchy made a most interesting and revealing speech a few days ago, in which he spoke of the advantages of having the Princes in. He made a confession of faith on the matter, very characteristic, very natural and very sincere, in one who has been a party manager. He said: "Here is this large block of votes, one-third of the Assembly, they will put things straight and counteract the evil of democratic and revolutionary tendencies which are manifested in the Congress of India." That is the position. The Secretary of State has shown how much hope he is putting upon this. What is to be the position of the Princes under this ordeal? Congress are not going to be idle in the new Assembly, and any Prince who makes himself prominent in defending Imperial interests and in acting in accordance with his sentiments of loyal allegiance, will be a marked man. He will be the subject of a double attack. Agitation will be raised in his dominions behind him, disorders will occur, comments and criticisms will be made, and there will be pressure at the centre, to show how he is a reactionary, is neglecting his State and how much happier they are in the States of those Princes who have conformed to the views of Congress. I say they will be in a dreadful position. If you imagine that they are going to be an element of stability, I believe that you make a profound mistake. There will be no element of stability there. Once the British power has definitely disinterested itself in this aspect of our affairs in India the Princes of India have no choice whatever but to throw in their lot with their own fellow-countrymen, and that is what they will do under the remorseless pressure of political events.
