- Context
- Churchill addressed the House of Commons in London on February 20, 1935, during the debate on Clause 5 of the Government of India Bill, arguing for a 75 per cent threshold of Indian States joining the federation.
- Main themes
- Indian States' offer to join the federation, proportion of States required for federation, 75 per cent amendment, Secretary of State's 'all' Indian States remark, Government of India Bill Clause 5, princes and democratic basis, alleged blackmail by outstanding States, composition of the Joint Select Committee, opposition to the Bill, Indian federation as megalomaniac palace
- Duration
- ~8 min
- Words
- 926
- Sentences
- 48
- Readability
- 75
- Grade
- 7.0
- Syntax
- 2.89
- Vocabulary
- 1.79
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other48 sentences in 10 paragraphs
This matter is really crucial. The essence of the Government's scheme has been based upon the offer of the princes. That was the statement made by the Lord President of the Council—whom I do not see in his place to-night—at the critical
486
meeting of his own party. We were told the princes had come forward with their offer and the suggestion was made "How can you reject these good gifts which are so freely proffered to your hand?" Now we are right down to the bones of the offer. There was the speech of the Secretary of State in which he said that the Indian States would come in. By a misprint in the OFFICIAL REPORT, such as often occurs to us, he was reported to have said that "all" the Indian States would come in. My right hon. Friend the Secretary of State says he did not say "all" and, whether he said it or not that he did not mean to say it, which is quite the same thing. No one is going to hold a Minister in high office and in a great critical position, responsible for the exact terms of the phrases which fall from his lips, but at any rate it was said that the Indian States would come in.
That is a very important point. The whole essence of the matter as presented to us was, "They want to come in." We were told that they had come forward with their offer and that all they said was, "Do let us be responsible. Do let us have democracy. Do let us have the will of the people prevailing." But they were to come in. Here was this great offer, enabling us to build up this vast megalomaniac palace of Indian Federation. This thing was presented to us because of the Indian States. All was put upon their offer. Now we are told it is only to be half. I am not going to argue with my right hon. Friend. He says he did not say "all" or did not mean to say "all" and that-is the end of it. But between "all" and 50 per cent. there is a pretty wide margin. He brushed that aside, but the Government are basing their case on the offer of the States. We are told that we ought to give up our views because of this great ugly rush of the Princes of India to get into the Federation—on a. purely democratic basis, of course. That is understood all the time. But between "all" and 50 per cent. cannot we come to an agreement with the right hon. Gentleman? Cannot we split the difference and accept this Amendment of 75 per tent—three-quarters instead of half?
What is all this talk about the blackmail which is to be exerted by the outstanding of a few States or whatever it
487
may be—that if you ask too many to come in the last lot might make conditions, and that you have to ask a very few to come in so that you can square that lot—and you have got them very well sized up I must say? Add up the big States of India and see the ones that have been dealt with—Travancore, and Bangalore, and so forth. But when you come to the focus of this matter you find that this point diminishes under the criticism of the Committee. Personally I think this is the weakest point in the Government's case. I think they make a great mistake to force it so much. If the great mass of the Indian States were really so sincere in their desire to participate in the newly created Federation of All-India, with responsible government, with the full surge of democratic processes operative at the centre, you would not have had this awful comedown to 50 per cent. and that 50 per cent. just about what can be managed and manipulated.
The right hon. Gentleman will tell me, no doubt, that the Joint Select Committee have considered all this, and settled it all, and examined it all so nicely. My right hon. Friend made a great mistake in not having a better committee of inquiry, people who would really make a searching examination of these problems. Because the composition of it was so unfair—about four to one, between three and four to one. Let us be quite frank about it. An hon. Member looks at me in a questioning manner. We are fighting this policy, fighting this Bill, and we have to judge whether we shall fight it, on the committee or outside the committee, entirely from the point of view of whether we can make a better fight; but if the committee had been a fair one, if it had been one which gave a fair representation—and we are not fighting it with such ill-effects as you suppose or as your majorities in this House may lead you to imagine—if the committee had been a fair one, it would have been quite possible to go on it. The right hon. Gentleman, however, so managed this committee that, instead of being a committee to inquire into these matters, it was a sort of recruiting agency for supporters of the Bill. But I am not
488
going to discuss the committee. On the contrary, all I say is that if this matter had been properly thrashed out in the committee, the right, hon. Gentleman would not be in the position in which he finds himself at the present moment.
