CLAUSE 5.—(Proclamation of Federation of India.)

United Kingdom Winston Churchill · Member of Parliament for Epping

20 February 1935 · House of Commons debate on the Government of India Bill, Committee stage · House of Commons, Palace of Westminster, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on February 20, 1935, during the Committee debate on Clause 5 of the Government of India Bill, challenging the Government's case for bringing in an Indian federation immediately.
Main themes
Proclamation of Indian federation, Government of India Bill Clause 5, Secretary of State's exposition, Princes' offer to join a federal system, provincial home rule and centrifugal tendency, Statutory Commission report, provinces as political entities, difficulty of combining devolution with integration, Joint Select Committee, uncertainty over the Princes' decision
Duration
~8 min
27th percentile
Words
921
27th percentile
Sentences
41
26th percentile
Readability
53
71st percentile
Grade
11.1
34th percentile
Syntax
2.90
34th percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
18th percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 82%76%
  • Geopolitical 8%7%
  • Ceremonial 8%7%
  • Social 3%2%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

41 sentences in 12 paragraphs

The Committee will feel indebted to the Secretary of State for the clear and full exposition he has given of the views and position of His Majesty's Government on this serious issue. If I found it necessary to apply a blister in order to procure from the right hon. Gentleman this highly agreeable exertion, I can only feel that it has been attended with success, and, if he is satisfied with his efforts, we are entirely grateful to have received from the Government some guidance as to their views on this subject. The Secretary of State has reaffirmed the Government's case without

403

attempting in any way—naturally he could hardly do so in so short a time—to deal with the arguments which have been advanced. He has restated the Government's main position. The Princes made their offer to come into a federal system; the Princes said that if they came into a federal system they must be responsible and, therefore, it is necessary for the Government to set up this federal system now. That, in short, is the main position of the Government. The right hon. Gentleman also said that if we were to proceed only with provincial home rule, a centrifugal tendency would be developed in the povinces, and the united focus and harmonious action of India would be destroyed. That is a clear statement of the position taken up by the Government, and also by the Joint Select Committee.

When it is given out, as it has been to-night, with an air of expert authority which the Government quite rightly are entitled to assume, one is entitled to be allowed to point to the fact that other expert bodies, who have given great consideration to this matter, have taken an entirely different view of the philosophical and fundamental basis on which this issue turns. My hon. and gallant Friend, in asking his question was really leading up to a quotation I am about to make from the report of the Statutory Commission. I do not know why hon. Members opposite should laugh; I am surprised at such irreverence. This was a body which contained eminent Liberals, the most pre-eminent Liberal was at its head, and hon. Members laugh because I venture to quote him. I have always noticed that the hon. Member for Bodmin (Mr. Isaac Foot) mocks at every authority which does not suit his argument at the moment, but I will admit that he is not the only man in the House who does that. This is what the Statutory Commission said:

Even if we were to ignore the Indian States and were to rest content with the provinces as at present constituted, the necessary conditions for bringing a full federal constitution into being are not yet present. The provinces must first become political entities.

I should have thought there was some importance in that. Before we can become political entities, before we can join ourselves together in political parties,

404

we must first be born into this world of sin and woe. The commission go on:

Even when our proposals for the constitution of the Governors provinces have been embodied in a Statute, the process is not completed. The provincial constitution only begins to exist as a living thing when the forces which operate it are at work and provincial opinion gives it inspiration and direction. Every federal union means the coming together of constituent elements which, while preserving their identities, look to the Centre to deal with matters common to all. Thus the nature of the constituents themselves has a great influence on the form which the federation takes. It is a difficult task.

These are not my words; they are not the words of Tory diehards. This is the Statutory Commission, with the Foreign Secretary at its head, surrounded by Liberals and Labour representatives.

It is a difficult task to combine the process of devolution with that of integration on a new basis.

These are solid propositions and arguments provided for us in the House of Commons and Lords by our own Statutory Commission, which was sent out and worked in India for two years. They gave us these solid bases of argument and, therefore, I am not so hopelessly divested of authority when I am confronted with the statements of the Secretary of State, which are absolutely contradictory to these main basic propositions. It is by no means the only time that we shall raise this federal issue in its different aspects, but it is the prime occasion. Having listened to many able speeches made by the supporters of the Government from time to time—there are some of them, certainly, who are very able in their statement of their views—I must say that I remain bewildered as to the initial motive power and impulse which lead the Government to insist on bringing a federal system into operation now, and forces us to take this position on the Bill. I have searched to find some adequate and satisfactory reason for it. Nobody wants it in India. With great difficulty the Princes are being brought up to scratch or not, as the case may be. We do not know. The Government have a great advantage over us in this respect, because the Debate is taking place without our knowing the decision of the Princes. With the greatest difficulty the Secretary of State set himself out to have three-quarters of the Princes as the test, but very quickly he had to write it down to one-half—