- Context
- Churchill spoke in the House of Commons Committee in London on February 26, 1935, on Clause 6 of the Government of India Bill, questioning the amendments on the Indian Princes' Instruments of Accession.
- Main themes
- Instruments of Accession of the Indian Princes, Government amendments to Clause 6, Secretary of State's dealings with individual Princes, minimum test for an acceptable accession, varying values of accessions, 50 per cent. threshold by population and territory, reciprocal federal voting rights, federal pool contributions, Solicitor-General's exposition, Government of India Bill, role of the Whips
- Duration
- ~10 min
- Words
- 1,159
- Sentences
- 50
- Readability
- 63
- Grade
- 9.3
- Syntax
- 2.91
- Vocabulary
- 2.06
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other50 sentences in 11 paragraphs
We are all indebted to the learned Solicitor-General for the cogency and the compression of his statement on this series of Amendments; which play an important part in the Government's alterations to the Bill. I feel,
1088
after what my hon. and learned Friend has said, that the Committee is now in full possession of all the points at issue. As we are anxious to get on as rapidly, as possible, I shall not find it necessary to delay the Committee by exploring this matter further, but there are one or two questions I wanted to ask. As far as I am able to throw myself into the full stream of the right hon. and learned Gentleman's discourse, I gather that this series of Amendments is designed to placate the Princes, a very legitimate and a very necessary task, designed to placate them upon the varying and complicated type of their Instruments of Accession. The rather vulgar commonplace word "declaration" has been put into a suitable background, and the expression "Instrument of Accession" is given due prominence. That is the specific Amendment, and it inaugurates a series of Amendments all designed, as I take it, to enable the Secretary of State to go round to these Princes one by one. Perhaps the right hon. Gentleman will give me his attention. Perhaps he was telling the learned Solicitor-General of something which the latter had forgotten to say. They are all designed to enable my right hon. Friend to go round to these Princes one by one—not having them in a great bunch of 100, as we saw the other day in Bombay—but one by one and take from each according to what he can give—from each according to his power, to each according to his need. It will be a case of an indefinite succession of individual dealings. After all, some will contribute a good deal to the Federation, others may only be able to give very little, but he needs them all, and this Amendment gives him the power to arrange anything that he likes with any Prince in order to gather his force together.
I take it that is the object of the extremely powerful technical exposition from the Solicitor-General. We can quite understand the purpose; although some of us, not having a legal training, may not be able to follow every one of those refinements, yet, nevertheless, the purpose is nakedly clear. It is to enable the right hon. Gentleman to gather his party together among the Princes. But there are one or two questions I must really ask. There must be some limit, some minimum test, before he can say he has got a
1089
Prince. Of course, the larger the party the more generous are the conditions of association, but this is rather a small party, on the narrow verge between the 50 per cent. who we thought were associated with the whole party and the 75 per cent. where a lot of vulgar blackmailing considerations might intrude upon the course of the Imperial Government. Therefore, the right hon. Gentleman must have a more or less precise test. I hope he will tell us what is the least concession of individual State rights which he will accept as suitable for the Crown to concur with. I gather we shall have all kinds of Instruments of Accession. Some will come in for a lot, and some for less, and some for hardly anything—some will hardly pay the green fees. At any rate, however they are in there must be some test, and I hope the Secretary of State will tell us quite shortly what it is. I would not wish him to go over all the legal points again. We have got them. Quite shortly, what exactly is the least that will qualify a Prince to he told, on the authority of the Crown, that he has executed an acceptable Instrument of A ecession—I think I have got that right?
Another question which arises is a little more complex, hut I think I can put it without any legal complication. All these Instruments of Accession will be of varying types and varying values. Some will be whole-timers, some half-timers, others will only just chip in for a bit and go away again. All these Instruments of Accession are of varying values. There may be four, five or six different types, or many more. How do those varying values affect the principle of 50 per cent. of the Princes coming in in order to constitute the basis of the federal system? It is obvious that these react upon one another. You cannot count the half-timers as whole-timers. For the purpose of 50 per cent. you cannot count a man who only comes in for one thing or another, and who says, "I come into Federation on this limited liability principle; I quite agree with it as far as that is concerned." You cannot count him as a 100 per cent. factor of the 50 per cent. necessary quota.
These react upon each other, and we are getting into an extremely complicated notation in this matter. I hope the right
1090
hon. Gentleman will tell us quite plainly whether, when he says there must be a 50 per cent. minimum of the Princes by population and territory, as set out in the Bill, he means 50 per cent. bona fide Instruments of Accession and not merely a number of Princes who may have paid a certain lip-service to the principle, although they may have a certain population and territory. Are these obligations to be reciprocal? Is everyone—including those who come in for a very little—also to be excluded from voting in the Debates of the Federal Assembly in respect of matters which they have not, as it were, put into the pool? If you are to carry out this immensely complicated scheme, the like of which was never seen on earth, in Heaven or in the waters under the earth, and will never be seen again after we have finished with it, at least you should lay down the broad principle that no one shall take out of the federal pool more than he puts in, and that no Prince shall take out of the federal pool more than he puts in. I hope I shall be able to have an assurance that that is definitely embodied in the law.
I am sure my right hon. Friend will clear up these points of difficulty which remain over; he really owes it to us to do so. He said earlier in the day that the House had instructed him to produce this Bill, but I think responsibility does not rest entirely upon the House. He forgot to mention that before the House instructed the Government to produce this Bill, the Government instructed the Whips to instruct the House to instruct him to produce exactly the Bill that he requires.
