CLAUSE 5.—(Proclamation of Federation of India.)

United Kingdom Winston Churchill · Member of Parliament

20 February 1935 · House of Commons debate on the Government of India Bill (Committee stage) · House of Commons, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill spoke in the House of Commons, London, on February 20, 1935, in Committee debate on Clause 5 of the India Bill, urging acceptance of an amendment requiring three-quarters of the Indian States to accede before federation.
Main themes
50 per cent threshold for Indian States joining federation, amendment to raise threshold to three-quarters, Indian princes' offer of federation, alleged pressure on princes, retrocession of territories, forgiveness of tributes, financial concessions to the princes, Secretary of State for India's policy, Conservative party consent to the measure, proclamation of Indian federation
Duration
~6 min
20th percentile
Words
706
20th percentile
Sentences
34
21st percentile
Readability
74
99th percentile
Grade
7.0
2nd percentile
Syntax
2.85
28th percentile
Vocabulary
2.11
30th percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 44%41%
  • Institutional 41%38%
  • Economic 16%15%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Ceremonial 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

34 sentences in 7 paragraphs

We know that India is progressing at an enormous rate. We are told that it is progressing at such a rate that any man who came home before the Secretary of State took office has no opinion about it worth considering, so no doubt his own views will change from time to time. But let me put before the Committee the brutal fact that whereas the sort of general idea was that it was to be the offer of the Indian States, that they all wanted to come forward, now it has been cut down to 50 per cent., and those 50 per cent. can be pretty well made up out of the States which we allege, and will increasingly assert and endeavour to prove,

489

have been in one way or another got at, approached, developed, by the right hon. Gentleman through all the sources that are open to him. What is the use of telling me that there is this talk about pressure and bribery? Let us withdraw all invidious expressions. The facts are quite good enough. Here are these territories which are to be retroceded. Here are these tributes which are to be forgiven. Here are these alterations in the financial arrangements with the Government of India. We heard representatives of the princes appealing that these concessions should be made to them, and they were only to be made if there were Federation. All this only operates on the basis of 50 per cent.

One could have understood if, with all these adventitious aids, the right hon. Gentleman had worked it up to 75 per cent., but 50 per cent. is all he is able to get. With all the pressure of the Government, and all the power and might, majesty and dominion at the disposal of a National Government in the full plenitude of power, they can get only 50 per cent. This is the crux of the whole matter. Here is the basis on which the Conservative party were induced to consent to this measure; they were told that here was this offer of the princes. I must say we thought it was a stream, but it is a pump, and the pump only works to the extent of 50 per cent. The right hon. Gentleman would be well advised to accept the Amendment; there is no reason why he should not. Why should he not accept three-quarters? He says that the odd balance of States would blackmail him. On the 50 per cent. he thinks he has got them pretty well fixed up now. The Committee can judge between those two propositions. If the Government are going to give a foundation to your Indian policy, if the great States of India are to come into a federal system, and if they desire to come in so long as it is democratic, have not the Government the courage to put their convictions to the test of 75 per cent.?

The right hon. Gentleman is here on the weakest point of his case. I should say the weakest point of his case up to the present time. I can only speak as a political friend of the right hon. Gentleman, and even that would be subject to some discount, but if he would accept the Amendment, on which we intend to divide, and take three-quarters as a

490

broad test of the willingness of the States to come in and as a broad guarantee and vindication of the statement of the Lord President of the Council as to the offer being the thing that moved him—this offer which is petering out and shrinking down, and all the available pressure only working it up to 50 per cent.—if he would take this on the basis of three-quarters, even if they do not all come in, even if the decision were adverse to it, would he be so much the worse off? Would the Government be so much the worse off? Would India be so much the worse off? Who would be the sufferers by it? The right hon. Gentleman would be well advised to accept this further definition. If he 'has faith in his policy, cannot he trust it beyond an even-money chance?