CFK at the G-20 Summit in Cannes

Argentina Cristina Fernández de Kirchner · President of Argentina

3 November 2011 · G-20 Summit Business Sector Forum · Cannes, France

Context
Fernández de Kirchner addressed the Business Sector Forum of the G-20 Summit in Cannes, France on November 3, 2011, presenting Argentina's agricultural and food security strategies.
Main themes
Food security, agricultural productivity and technology, industrialization of rurality, biotechnology innovation, urbanization and rural depopulation, value-added agri-food production, Argentina's agri-food capacity, gender equity, global food supply, workforce and competitiveness
Duration
~29 min
81st percentile
Words
3,498
81st percentile
Sentences
107
66th percentile
Readability
39
35th percentile
Grade
15.5
80th percentile
Syntax
3.38
88th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
20th percentile

G7 / G20 Summit Communiqués Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 67%64%
  • Social 14%13%
  • Ceremonial 8%7%
  • Institutional 6%6%
  • Environmental 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

107 sentences in 41 paragraphs

Business Sector Forum of the G-20 Summit. November 3, 2011. Cannes, France.

I have heard talk of development, growth, but I cannot help but first reclaim a little bit of gender, in light of Mr. Polman's expression that wants to take us to work in the fields; we women are willing to collaborate with work in the fields. It reminds me a bit of when they wanted to take us only to the kitchen or from the kitchen to the fields now.

But I believe he touches on a central issue, which is also linked to another topic that was addressed, which is the growing urbanization and depopulation of the countryside, which is also linked, at least in the experience of Argentina. Today we have between 90 and 92 percent of the population living in urban areas, being for example the eighth largest country in area and also one of the leading countries in agri-food production and essentially also leaders in technological innovation and productivity.

Today Argentina has, in the world—I dare say—the best level of productivity per hectare planted, precisely due to the introduction, innovation, technology, and biotechnology that have been essential and will continue to be essential to produce more and better.

But this at the same time creates a contradiction, as happens with all technological innovations, which is that the greater the degree of technological innovation, the greater the degree of productive efficiency, the fewer jobs per hectare, which leads us to the contradiction that every time we advance in productivity and technology, there is a reduction in the workforce and therefore people move to the big cities because they lack opportunities.

What have we formulated as a response to this growing problem that, in addition to depopulating the countryside and excessively urbanizing the cities, brings problems of insecurity, brings problems in urban infrastructure, brings problems of misery, ultimately a contradiction of what can be a great agricultural production?

We have presented in the National Agriculture Plan, in the National Agri-Food Plan 20-20 the slogan: the industrialization of rurality. That is why, at this table, I am accompanied not only by the Minister of Agriculture, Livestock, and Fisheries, Julián Domínguez, but also by the Minister of Industry, Débora Giorgi.

We believe that one of the keys, linked to technology and greater productivity, is to achieve value addition to each of those products, to the different links in the production chain, at the place of production. This is not only about having our families situated in their places of origin, but it will also be a matter of competitiveness, because one of the issues of competitiveness will also be given by logistics.

If I obviously also have to transport my raw materials certain kilometers to be able to industrialize them, this will evidently reduce my competitiveness in terms of industrialization and added value, so the issue of industrializing rurality, which means adding value at the place of origin where the raw material is produced with a high degree of productivity and efficiency, is one of the objectives, not only social but also economic. We have defined it as something central; this is a topic that is not only about women, but also for example about our young people who are trained in university centers, who are also trained in those sectors to return to their places of origin and add more value, innovation, and technology.

You know that Argentina is also one of the leading countries in the world in biotechnology. We have the highest proportion of biotechnology companies per capita in Latin America. We have developed this in relation to the productivity we have achieved, with direct seeding and with things that I will not explain because you all know perfectly well.

But I want to address the points of Food Security. This President has had the task of being a defender of Food Security in the Republic of Argentina, often with some criticism from the private sector, because there is a saying in my country that goes: "quality well understood starts at home," and if I cannot ensure the food security of my people, I will be even less able to contribute to global food security.

But in fact, Argentina, in this food security, is a major producer of food with just 40 million inhabitants and with the capacity to produce food for 400 or 500 million while maintaining this food security, because we have sufficient surpluses, which is not the case for other countries that have productivity, that feed but due to their large population do not manage to have large surpluses, places Argentina in a privileged position as an agri-food producer and as a contributor to food security. In fact, we have gone from 67 million tons of grains to 102 million tons of grains in this last harvest. And the conservative gap, I believe, of Minister of Agriculture, I think we will be more, is to produce 160 million grains by the year 2020.

I personally believe that with the current development of Argentina, with the level of investment that the producer also has in the Republic of Argentina, the private sector, plus the level—which I also want to touch on here—of infrastructure that the State has built, I want to tell you that from 2003 to date, infrastructure plans have grown exponentially, to the point that they have come to constitute between 4 and 5 points of GDP in the last exercise, for example, through programs like PROSAC financed by the Inter-American Development Bank, of which it was also discussed here how multilateral organizations finance, we have achieved the irrigation of more than 2 million hectares.

What problem do I see in the future? It could be climate-related, evidently unmanageable for anyone. In fact, Argentina had a significant drought period during 2008 and 2009, which is why I have entrusted the Minister of Agriculture and the entire Infrastructure sector, and I have also discussed it with producers and the business sector, that the task of irrigation is fundamental to prevent drought, in a country where we also have a very important aquifer.

You know that South America has about 25 or 30 percent of the world's fresh water reserves, so we can, with a strong investment plan, guarantee at least not having to look at the sky to see if it rains. This is one of the keys also in port infrastructure. We have a complex, the oilseed complex, that is, the most important granary is in the port of Rosario, and we have developed an infrastructure that is the Hidrovía, which allows us—you know—maritime transport. It is, in terms of costs, an important equation, and we are also redeveloping, after many decades, rail transport.

We all know that transport by truck, beyond 100, 150 kilometers, makes production uncompetitive, so it is necessary to have transport through railways and fundamentally maritime transport, to be able, for example in our case, to reach in 2014-2015 directly with very deep-draft ships to Asunción, which would mean being able to export production via maritime routes from all of southern Brazil, from all of Paraguay, from part of Bolivia, from all of Argentina, and obviously from Uruguay that is there. Thus, we also conceive infrastructure as something fundamental in this matter.

Another thing that Mr. Polman addressed is also the term of investment; investment has also grown exponentially in the Republic of Argentina in agri-food production, and now it has also been incorporated through promotional laws of the State, the issue of investment. I know that in terms of food security, there is a very debatable issue, which is the issue of bioethanol and biodiesel, but the issue of fuels and the competitiveness of the use of fuels in the agricultural sector is also relevant. We are objectively aiming for the producer to negotiate, obtain their own fuel, so as not to be subject to the variable of an international commodity, such as oil, which can negatively impact production.

If the Argentine producer could definitively become independent of the energy variable for production, we would achieve even greater competitiveness because we would be eliminating an international variable.

The issue of transparency, I believe, was also discussed regarding research and technology; I want to inform you that we are currently analyzing more than 200 technological events. Just a few days ago, more than a month ago, between INTA, which is a state agency that also includes the private sector, we achieved the first cloned transgenic cow that produces maternal milk. We are really conducting very important research in this sector; we are also working with seeds, as has already been indicated, with deeper roots, so that in the event of a drought, they can obtain water, and also do it sustainably so that this does not mean affecting and touching the environment, so the issues that have been addressed here are truly the reason for this Plan 20-20, and they are also a reality in the Republic of Argentina.

We also talked about producing better, and I wanted to touch on the issue of family agriculture, which was a topic that was also addressed here, and I want to tell you that practically 70 percent of food in the Republic of Argentina is supported by family agriculture. We have a great development of family agriculture, in horticulture, in everything that constitutes the family table.

The responsibility of the business sector and social enterprise was also discussed; I believe someone spoke of social enterprise here. In Argentina, there is a great development in terms of cooperatives, which is the most social way we can approach in a capitalist economy—this is what we are talking about—and Argentina has had great development. In fact, 20 percent of grain production is marketed through cooperatives, and some are competing with the large grain companies, the large exporters, to participate even more in that marketing. One of our leading dairy companies, SANCOR, is precisely formed in the dairy basin of the Republic of Argentina, in the form of a cooperative. The cooperative is a successful experience in Argentina in terms of production, technological investment, and productive investment.

I wanted to speak especially about market transparency, which is ultimately the issue that the three who preceded me in speaking addressed, Mr. Polman among others, but fundamentally the Minister of Agriculture of the Republic of France regarding market regulation.

I believe that the problem does not lie in the issue of grains; I believe that the problem lies in the financial system. I think that focusing solely on the issue of market regulation as a food security issue only concerning commodities seems to me to be an absolutely biased view, I say this honestly. Because in such a way, we could also say that we should regulate the market for medicinal patents. For example, it is very important to eat because otherwise one dies. Now, if one does not have technology and remedies, one also dies. So if we talk about food security, if we talk about life security, because ultimately we are talking about life security, we should also, for example, talk about regulating the market for royalties and medicinal patents, because I believe that in Africa, people not only die of hunger but also die for lack of medicines, for lack of healthcare; however, so far I have not heard any word about regulating the markets, for example, of health technology, which are key, and moreover, it is as humiliating to die of hunger as it is to die for lack of an aspirin or a vaccine.

It seems to me that when we talk about regulation to protect life, we must talk about all aspects, but fundamentally about employment, about the possibility of decent work that also needs to be introduced into this issue. No one can have food security, life security if they do not have a job that provides them with the means, and that is why I believe that employment will be a topic of this G20, which provides the possibilities; employment that also has to do with returning to a true capitalism. Because I believe that we are today—sincerely, I will raise this later with my colleagues—in a kind of anarchic capitalism or anarcho-financial capitalism, if you will. Financial markets today are in commodities and are profitable in commodities; tomorrow or the day after they will be in oil depending on how oil goes, and they may tomorrow dedicate themselves to candy markets if they really have the opportunity to earn a peso more without working, without producing, and without investing to perfectly speculate.

That is why we are maintaining that the real problem is the lack of regulation of financial markets in the world.

Ladies and gentlemen: the large grain companies, the large enterprises, no matter how big they are, can only make speculative moves evidently within what constitutes the financial system. There are no possibilities for speculation, there are no possibilities to obtain higher or lower interest rates, if the financial market is not also regulated in terms of how much it will invest, whom it will finance, how we will finance, under what conditions. Who are we going to finance? Are we going to continue financing brokers who only deal in financial derivatives, or are we going to finance those who produce food, goods, and services? This is the key; I believe that focusing on the regulation of the commodities or food market is an absolutely biased view.

I am a fan of Realpolitik and I know where things are decided and where decisions are made. If those who lead the world, because they have also wanted to lead it, do not provide clear and concrete solutions regarding the financial regulation system, if they only continue to aim at controlling how each country spends its money but do not control what each investment bank does, what each rating agency does, what each stock market movement does, tell me, they are all businessmen or at least linked to business: what do you think happens when one day Mrs. Merkel wakes up and says something that seems to have fallen badly and the stock markets crash and lose 4 or 5 points? The next day Mr. Sarkozy wakes up and says something important that seems to calm everything down and they rise again by another 10 points, the next day Mr. Papandreou decides on a popular consultation and we all go back down again.

Do you think there are not people who make thousands of fortunes with those movements without doing absolutely anything, just sitting at a desk and managing a computer? This, the world leaders have not managed to solve, and three years have passed. And of course, when three years have passed and they do not provide a solution, it gets worse and worse. If they treat it with aspirin, if a doctor treats it, in this case the International Monetary Fund, if the G20 treats it, if they are giving it medicine, they have injected billions of dollars and euros into the financial system.

I stated at the London meeting on April 2 that it was necessary to force the financial sectors to channel those resources into the real economy, because if there is no consumption, gentlemen, there is no capitalism, there are no possibilities for economic growth.

If we make adjustment plans, if people cannot spend money, if people are indebted beyond a hundred percent of their possibilities, I want someone to tell me, from Adam Smith, from David Ricardo, from Keynes, if they do not like it for some more leftist thinkers like Karl Marx, how are we going to make the economy grow again if there is no consumption, if capitalism does that, that people consume and that you, the entrepreneurs, produce and sell more and more. This is the issue; this is what is failing.

Who would have thought I would be here from my university days now! What I am proposing is to return to serious capitalism, because what we are living, gentlemen, is not capitalism. This is total financial anarcho-capitalism, where no one controls anyone.

So, the proposal is that we regulate those whom we really need to regulate. It turns out that we are going to regulate countries and see how they can adjust. Moreover, leaderships are falling, and also, allow me from politics, no longer from business, the foundations of democracy will begin to be questioned. Because when people see that democracy does not provide them with opportunities for work, progress, housing, or health, they begin to question the functioning of the political system.

You think not in terms of 2 or 3 years, think in terms of the historical evolution of humanity, what has happened every time the people have not been able to eat. And I say this here in France, the cradle of the French Revolution; systems change. I am not announcing the end of any system, please. I am simply looking at it with a historical perspective and seeing that it is necessary to make a serious change, because also what some believe is happening in other countries, someone just spoke about what is happening in Africa when people cannot eat or in the Maghreb when what happened happened, but let us not fall into the trap of the famous Arab revolution that only has to do with food. It also has to do with people who have political systems different from ours and who do not want to live with Western democratic forms. Let us not see it only as an economic problem. Those who believe that the Arab Spring is a matter of wanting to live like us Westerners, with the separation of powers and so on, do not seem to me to be reading it correctly. And if not, look at the photos of the people celebrating the fall of governments and we will see people dressed as Muslims, absolute Islamists, and moreover, in the first election held in Tunisia, it was shared by a moderate Islamist but an Islamist - and I have nothing against Islam, not at all - I simply say: let us have a real understanding of the world we are in. Let us not be mistaken and know that if this deepens, democracies and current political forms will begin to be questioned.

Europe also has a history in this, of how totalitarian governments arise in the midst of unsolvable economic crises that cannot be resolved.

I believe we are still on time; I do not want to be dramatic, nor alarmist, nor sow panic because it is not my mission as President of the Republic and also because I do not believe it. I believe we are still in time and form to establish solutions, but solutions that have to do with the regulation of those who have caused the problem.

But also, and to conclude, if one has already tried certain medicines for 3 years with certain doctors and the patient is getting worse and worse, should we not change the doctor and the medicine and try another treatment?

This is a matter of pure logic; trying to solve problems in the same way they were created, Einstein said, is the act of not very sane people.

With this, I wanted to conclude; excuse me, I am a bit... when I speak... everyone is looking at me as if I have... but it is a bit those who know me... I am passionate about the issues, I am interested in the issues, nothing is indifferent to me. I am absolutely convinced that we need to change a lot of things, and if I have proposed myself again as President of the Republic of Argentina, it has precisely been to collaborate with my country, but also to know that collaborating with my country is collaborating with the rest of the world to solve things, because Argentina is not an island, nor does it want to be. On the contrary, it is absolutely integrated into the world perhaps like never before.

We have grown in our foreign trade since the 1990s exponentially as well; we have doubled our integration into the world in terms of trade. So, let me say that this vehemence is a bit of passion and the desire to solve problems. Many times it is necessary to affect interests, that is true.

This is the other great definition, and with this I want to finish: it is true that many times to solve certain problems, it is necessary to affect interests, and interests that are very powerful. But I dare to say that it is better to confront those minority but powerful interests than to face the fury of society later. I tell you this from the experience of an Argentina that lived through a chaotic 2001 that practically collapsed our institutional system and divided society.

Thank you very much.