Press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, notably on the situation in Libya and in Arab countries, the crisis within the eurozone, the succession of Dominique Strauss-Kahn at the IMF, and the sale of military ships to Russia, in Deauville on May 27, 2011.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

27 May 2011 · G8 summit press conference · Deauville, France

Context
Sarkozy held a press conference at the G8 Summit in Deauville on May 27, 2011, addressing Libya, Arab transitions, Syria, the IMF, and Middle East peace.
Main themes
Libya and Gaddafi's removal, Arab Spring financial support, eurozone crisis, IMF leadership succession, Syria condemnation, Israeli-Palestinian peace process, G8 summit outcomes, Gulf country contributions, multilateral development banks, Russian relations, African solidarity
Duration
~45 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,432
93rd percentile
Sentences
246
93rd percentile
Readability
58
83rd percentile
Grade
10.2
23rd percentile
Syntax
2.98
44th percentile
Vocabulary
2.07
22nd percentile

G7 / G20 Summit Communiqués Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

246 sentences in 70 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT -- Ladies and gentlemen, good morning. You have the text of the final communiqué from the summit, and so, if you agree, it might be best if I respond directly to the questions you may have for me, which will avoid paraphrasing the text of the communiqué.

QUESTION -- Good morning, Mr. President. In the communiqué, you say, the G8 says: "KADHAFI must go." But KADHAFI refuses to leave. What should be done?

THE PRESIDENT -- Intensification of military intervention to protect the populations under the framework of Resolution 1973. There is a strong consensus on this objective. The terms used regarding Mr. KADHAFI are particularly clear and very harsh, and they have been accepted by all G8 member countries, including Russia. Furthermore, all our African partners show great solidarity regarding the decisions on Libya. So Mr. KADHAFI holds his personal situation in his hands: he leaves and avoids much suffering for the Libyan people; he stubbornly stays, and he will pay the consequences himself.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, the final communiqué mentions 20 billion. However, the Tunisian Prime Minister says that you mentioned the figure of 40 billion.

THE PRESIDENT -- Yes, I can provide you with the details. It is 20 billion dollars for multilateral banks, in which I do not include the IMF. We thought it was more honest not to involve the IMF in this count since, in any case, the IMF engages loans and has already engaged these loans for Egypt and Tunisia, so we did not include it in the multilateral banks. In addition, there are about ten billion dollars in bilateral commitments that we did not mention in the statement. For France, it will be one billion euros for Egypt and Tunisia. Finally, there are 10 billion dollars in contributions from Gulf countries, Saudi Arabia, Qatar, Kuwait, which we will include in a financial fund specifically dedicated to this purpose. The total thus amounts to 40 billion over the period: multilateral banks, bilateral commitments, commitments from Gulf countries.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, after your discussions with President MEDVEDEV and President OBAMA, do you think the project at the Security Council for Syria, the European project, French as well, will pass? And what do you think is happening today, as there are still protesters being killed in Syria? Excuse me, Mr. President, a second question if you allow, regarding the conference you want to hold at the end of June: after your discussions with President OBAMA, do you feel that President OBAMA has accepted the principle of a conference where you want to relaunch, as you say, the peace process regarding Palestine and Israel?

THE PRESIDENT -- Regarding Syria, I told you yesterday, the situation is perfectly unacceptable and the attitude of the government is shocking. The terms used in the G8 declaration are unambiguous in condemning the actions of the government in Syria against peaceful protesters. And this text was further hardened in the negotiations last night, and our Russian friends accepted and validated this text. Who can imagine that what was possible to say and write at the G8 in Deauville would lead to or could lead to a different position at the United Nations?

Regarding the peace process, we discussed it at length this morning with Mr. JUPPÉ and President OBAMA. We believe that Palestinian reconciliation is good news. We think there is an opportunity to unlock the situation and that, above all, there is urgency because the Arab revolutions, democracy in certain Arab countries provide an opportunity for peace; because democracies, and this is even their characteristic, do not go to war with each other. And we want to convince our Israeli friends that they should not worry about this evolution; on the contrary, it will allow for a release of negative energy that was mobilized against dictatorships, into positive energy for growth and peace. And several times, with our American friends, we have agreed that there is urgency. So the urgency is precisely between now and the United Nations General Assembly. There may be differences of opinion on whether the urgency is June or whether the urgency is July.

And as you know, Mr. JUPPÉ, Minister of State, will be going to the Middle East next Thursday. And we will be able to provide a more precise update at that time, and he will himself be in Washington at the beginning of June; and we have agreed with our American friends to work together. We cannot resign ourselves, France cannot resign itself to the perpetuation of this conflict whose parameters for peace are perfectly known, and they have indeed been recalled with great courage, lucidity, and intelligence by President OBAMA.

So after that, there needs to be a minimum of goodwill from all partners to make peace. In any case, France's willingness to take initiatives and try to advance the process is clearly on the table, and it has indeed been reiterated in the G8 communiqué.

QUESTION -- Africa is increasingly present, sub-Saharan Africa, in international summits, but is its voice really heard, both politically and economically? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT -- In any case, it is clear that we wanted not only the G8 to hear the voice of Africa, but it is a shared voice since I believe this is the first time there has been a joint Africa-G8 declaration on absolutely significant issues.

We have the preparation for Durban, which is a huge challenge, and France, very clearly, wishes to prepare for the post-Kyoto era but without it resulting in a reduction of commitments, to maintain commitments to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and obligations for the protection of our planet, so there will need to be a great discussion.

There is the issue of the Doha cycle and the World Trade Organization, where regardless of the prospects for success or failure for Doha, we do not wish for the poorest countries to be held hostage to a quarrel between industrialized countries and emerging countries. And so, we are reflecting on this situation to protect the poorest countries.

There is the whole question of infrastructure development for Africa, which will be the subject of a particular and important chapter in Cannes. There is the question of innovative financing that we will push with Meles Zenawi. I was very pleased with President BARROSO's commitment indicating that he was in favor of innovative financing and that the Commission would make a proposal for innovative financing. As for France, we will take our responsibilities and we are ready to implement innovative financing with a group of leading countries, even if not everyone agrees.

And finally, it was very moving to invite three African countries that have had democratic elections, Côte d'Ivoire, Niger, Guinea. Clearly, our African friends have understood that the absolute priority would be given to those who fight against corruption, who fight for democracy, and that is the new partnership between the G8 and Africa, from North Africa to South Africa.

QUESTION -- A question about Europe and Greece: would a restructuring of Greek debt really be very harmful to Europe? It must happen very quickly and at all costs, and is this a topic you discussed with Mrs. MERKEL? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT -- It is a topic that we did not discuss at the G8 because it is not at the G8 that we should address these questions, even if we discussed with our partners the situation in the eurozone. We emphasized that the eurozone was a stable area where growth had resumed quite strongly, +0.8 on average in the first quarter of this year, where average deficits were actually lower than in other parts of the world, since if I remember correctly, we should be around 4.5 in average deficit, and there was indeed a paradox in discussing the problems of the euro at a time when we have rarely been as high.

I would still like to draw the attention of all observers to the fact that the euro has fluctuated in recent weeks between 1.40 against the dollar and 1.50, which is well above its introductory rate. I do not remember a currency that would be fragile having a market value that increases. And even, what sometimes poses a problem for us is the high level of the euro for financing our exports.

So it was not a question of discussing in detail the situation of Greece or any other country in its absence and in the absence of our euro partners. With Mrs. MERKEL, yes in bilateral talks, of course we discussed to express our total, complete, and unambiguous support for the euro, its stability, and its credibility. Germans and French have long said that the euro is non-negotiable because the euro is Europe, and anything that could undermine the future of the euro would undermine the future of Europe and thus undermine the future of France and the future of Germany. So everything that needs to be done will be done at the right time, in partnership with our German friends, and I will not fail to explain the decisions we will have made at that time.

QUESTION -- To extend my colleague's question about Syria, would you go so far as to send a message today to President Bashar AL-ASSAD, the same recent message that President OBAMA addressed to him during his speech to the Arab world, that is to say to tell him: "either you ensure a real democratic transition now or you leave power"?

THE PRESIDENT -- Could I have said that? Yes. He has already said it, and he was right to say it. Well, it seems to me that Alain JUPPÉ and I had already said it, but if you want me to say that we are following the good example of President OBAMA, listen, that does not pose any problem for me.

And France has some credibility to say it, as we have done everything to bring Syria back into the concert of international nations, we have done everything, we have discussed with them, we have talked with them, we have tried to help them, we have tried to understand them, and we have indeed been able to make progress in Lebanon thanks to this understanding, and unfortunately, I regret to say that the Syrian leaders are making a formidable backward march. France, under these conditions, withdraws its trust and denounces what must be denounced. President Bashar AL-ASSAD knew perfectly well that France would do this from the moment there was this unacceptable democratic regression.

QUESTION -- I wanted to ask you about the idea that there would be a proposal from Russia to mediate on the issue of Libya. Is it true that there is indeed this proposal, and what do you think about it? And if I may ask you, we in Italy are of course very interested in your wife; I know you do not talk about your private life, but allow us to congratulate you, and do you already know if it is a little boy or a little girl? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT -- Fortunately, you do not want to talk about my private life, because what would it be if you wanted to talk about it? I suppose you would do it in Italian. I congratulate you in turn for being Italian, which is a country we love so much in France.

Regarding President MEDVEDEV, words have meaning; what does mediation mean? There is no possible mediation with Mr. KADHAFI. Mr. KADHAFI's soldiers must return to the barracks, and Mr. KADHAFI must go. We can discuss the modalities of his departure in honor, in which country... all of that is indeed negotiable.

And as for Mr. MEDVEDEV, why would we do without his persuasive power when, on behalf of Russia, he agrees to condemn what is happening in Libya and to condemn the actions of Mr. KADHAFI? So yes, we need President MEDVEDEV's help, and indeed, we have needed it so much that at the Security Council, he allowed us to pass Resolution 1973. So yes, this help is welcome on this issue as on others. As it has indeed been useful in all the matters that continue with Iran. Russia is a great partner.

QUESTION -- This is not a question about your wife, but rather we will return to Greece, which is a fascinating issue since the situation is indeed deteriorating in Greece. The IMF has just announced that it may not grant the next tranche of aid to Greece, so I would like to know if you had a somewhat in-depth discussion about this issue with Mrs. MERKEL, particularly because the new deterioration is partly due to Germany calling for a "soft" restructuring of Greek debt, a restructuring that France and the European Central Bank firmly oppose? Second question, did Mr. OBAMA express his concerns to you about the ongoing instability within the eurozone more than a year and a half after the onset of this crisis? Clearly, we are not managing to provide the systemic response that the markets expect.

THE PRESIDENT -- Mr. OBAMA did not express his concerns to me because he is fully aware of the situation in the United States of America. And Mr. OBAMA, one of his characteristics is being reasonable, and how could he be worried about a zone where the average deficit is at 4.5? That is not possible.

Secondly, Germany is a major country and a strategic partner for France; I will not say anything that could hinder a confident collaboration with Mrs. MERKEL and the German government, which is essential.

Thirdly, I find that the word "restructuring" is being misused. If restructuring means that a European country should not repay its debts, then that is a word that will not be part of France's vocabulary, it is clear, simple, and straightforward. If the question is: can we think about how private agents or private partners can share the burden? We are not at all in restructuring; there are formulas, there is no problem. There you go. And it is in this direction that everyone will have to converge.

The important thing is that we will defend and support the euro and solidarity within the eurozone. The credibility of European countries is crucial, and we cannot yield on this term of credibility. We will not yield on this term of credibility. As for the participation of the private sector, there are many ways to do it without undermining this credibility. So I confirm to you, France does not use the word restructuring and believes that it is a word that should not be used and a reality that should not be considered.

QUESTION -- Earlier, the Tunisian president in his press conference mentioned the issue of refugees, Tunisians crossing into Europe, saying: "I do not believe that 20 or 28,000 arrivals on European soil call into question the demographic balance in Europe." Do you consider that there is today a problem, a danger of massive immigration?

THE PRESIDENT -- Associating the word danger with immigration, coming from you, is curious. Do you see a danger? Sorry, you are associating two words that we do not associate, that I have never associated, danger and immigration. I would not have used those terms like that, but well, you have used them; it is your right.

I have never been in my life for zero immigration; I will not start now, and it has been a long time since I thought that the south of the Mediterranean and the north of the Mediterranean should manage migratory flows and development imperatives together. Immigration must be considered by people who have responsibilities and a sense of responsibility.

For example, our Tunisian friends want us to train their elites; they are right, and we will be very happy to train them, if only because it helps to develop and maintain the love of French in Tunisia. But at the same time, everyone can see that when it takes 10 years to train a medical student, in 10 years, one makes encounters whether one is a young man or a young woman. The goal is not for all Tunisian medical students to become doctors in France. So all of this deserves to be discussed and concerted; things are progressing steadily. Alain JUPPE went to Tunisia, Claude GUEANT as well, and I believe we are finding a good balance. So there is no tension on the subject, and I can also tell you that the Tunisian Prime Minister wishes for me to visit Tunisia fairly soon at his invitation.

Moreover, it seems to me that Tunisian youth has been quite sensitive to the French Presidency's initiative to invite Egypt and Tunisia to the G8; it is a signal.

QUESTION -- Could you talk about your conversations regarding the possibility of Russia joining the WTO?

THE PRESIDENT -- There are still a few issues to resolve, but we have said that on the objective, we are in favor of Russia being able to join the WTO. Generally speaking, the partnership between Russia and France, Russia and Europe will get much closer and stronger in the months and years to come.

From the moment Russia takes its share in resolving major international issues as it is doing, there is no reason to delay the resolution of Russia's requests, such as that of a market economy or joining the WTO.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, without going back to what you indicated yesterday, can you tell us what President OBAMA said to you this morning in your discussions about the situation at the IMF, what has happened in the last two weeks, and the candidacy of Ms. Christine LAGARDE?

THE PRESIDENT -- Listen, we naturally talked about it; how could it be otherwise? But in the current state of affairs, I am not the spokesperson for President OBAMA, and it is not for me to announce his decision. I believe his decision has been made, and he is reserving the right moment to announce it. It would have been particularly clumsy, it seems to me, to give the impression that the G8 countries were agreeing on a candidacy, ignoring the requests from other regions of the world, which could indeed be multiple. But in the meantime, I saw the excellent statement from Ms. CLINTON last night. I would have a hard time imagining that there is a disagreement between the two.

QUESTION -- I would like to return to a question about the Middle East. Do you think it is good, useful to talk about the 1967 borders when trying to address the issue of resolution in the Middle East? About a return to the 1967 borders? Second question on Iran: Do you not think that the Arab Spring and all the measures being taken are sidelining the Iranian issue, even if it was discussed at the G8, and do you not regret that?

THE PRESIDENT -- I believe it is appropriate to talk about the 1967 borders because we cannot talk only about borders without specifying which ones. Otherwise, it will become really virtual, and I think that precisely what gives courage to President OBAMA's speech is that he mentioned the 1967 borders.

On Iran, it is very clear; Iran has evidently tried to take advantage of a happy Arab news cycle to make its inexorable march towards military nuclear capability forgotten, a march that is perfectly unacceptable. We have discussed this in detail, and we will take new measures to further strengthen sanctions.

QUESTION -- In your introduction to the e-G8, you spoke of a dialogue of responsibilities between an industrial sector and heads of state and government, and you described this sector as both fragile and powerful. I know that there is something else that is fragile and powerful in this world, which is youth. You have given your high patronage to the G8 and G20 of youth next week, and I wanted to know how you see the future of this initiative and how you hope to continue to integrate a generation as we have seen in Spain or in the Arab world that is still seeking its place in globalization?

THE PRESIDENT -- We cannot compare what Arab youth is doing in Tunisia, in Egypt, and what they are doing in Spain because Spain is a great democracy. Frankly, far be it from me to take away from the merit of Spanish youth or part of Spanish youth that is demonstrating, but it is not quite the same commitment as demonstrating in Tunisia or Egypt, which were not democracies and aspire to become one.

For the youth G8 as for the e-G8, the presidency can have ideas, make proposals, but then it is up to the actors to seize them; it is not for us to artificially carry the projects.

The e-G8 will now take place every year because the actors of the Internet have decided to take it up. That is the right approach; it is not for states to carry the ideas. We can possibly put an idea on the table, initiate a process, but then, if it is us who have to keep it alive permanently, it proves that it was artificial. The same goes for the youth G8. We could also develop other G8s. We could have a G8 of artists. There are many ideas, athletes. There are many ideas that we could develop, but they depend on the relay we find on the other side. If the e-G8 has worked so well, it is because the world of the Internet has taken hold of this event, made it live, and millions of internet users have followed it, and this idea no longer belongs to me at all. You understand, the French presidency put the idea forward; this idea no longer belongs to us, and that is a good thing. It works, and every year there will be an e-G8; that is the right solution. I do not wish, in any case, to pump it up artificially like a tire that needs a patch. It is the energy of the actors that can take the ideas and give them life and future.

QUESTION -- I would like to follow up on my colleague's question regarding the IMF's management that you discussed this morning with Mr. OBAMA. I wanted to know if you believe that Ms. LAGARDE's candidacy can repair the wounds that may have been inflicted on France's image by Mr. STRAUSS-KAHN's arrest, and if you are personally shocked by the particularly luxurious conditions of Mr. STRAUSS-KAHN's detention in New York?

THE PRESIDENT -- Really, I have refrained from taking sides on this issue because you know perfectly well all the lawsuits that would be brought against me, whatever I say, and you know that very well. I do not blame you for asking the question. I think that all of this is sad enough for all political leaders to try to maintain a sense of perspective and dignity because in the face of all these events, there are mixed feelings that can be contradictory and belong to the intimate sphere of each person, and therefore I do not believe that as head of state, I should take sides.

There is the American justice system, there is the IMF. You tell me: "this seriously damages France's image," but I did not know that Mr. STRAUSS-KAHN represented France. He represented the IMF. Are you telling me: "this seriously damages the IMF's image"? The deputy director of the IMF was there; we spoke with him; we need the IMF.

I want to maintain this position of distance and, I hope, perspective on the subject. Frankly, some comments I have heard reinforce my decision to keep a bit of distance because there are things we have heard that we would have preferred not to hear, things we have seen that we would have preferred not to see, things heard that we would have preferred not to hear. And this has nothing to do with questions of politics, left or right, majority or opposition. Frankly, there have been extremely shocking statements made. I will leave it at that, and I apologize.

QUESTION -- During this summit, you announced with President MEDVEDEV the sale of the Mistrals with a very important transfer of technology. This sale has raised some concerns in several countries neighboring Russia; do you think this concern is justified? What can you say to these countries that express this concern, and what can you say to those who think that this transaction was a sort of bargaining chip for Russian support on the Libya issue?

THE PRESIDENT -- We do not exchange a BPC for a political position of a great country like Russia. Russia is large, as if I remember correctly, 46 times the size of France. Russia is an area twice the size of the United States of America. Russia has between 130 and 140 million inhabitants, and it loses 600 to 700,000 inhabitants each year. Russia does not occupy its entire area. Presenting Russia as a country wanting to invade its neighbors and being a threat to the European Union, I think that is an extremely outdated and extremely false analysis. That is what I think, and I tell you. If the European Union has only Russia as its sole adversary, frankly, it means that the situation is quite stable.

Secondly, Russia is a great country with raw materials. Europe has a lot of technologies; we have everything to build together.

Finally, when we saw Mr. Juppé in Lisbon with the President of the United States and the President of Russia at the NATO summit, we said to ourselves: "Ah, finally, the Berlin Wall has fallen, the Cold War is over." So if the Russians are allies, on what grounds should we not sell them a ship? And do you think it is with the four Mistrals that we are going to invade? Who, by the way?

And as for my many friends in Georgia, I believe that today, since I was invited there on a trip, they have evolved significantly on the issue of the 2008 agreement. They know very well that it is because France was president of the European Union that today's Georgia is completely free from Russia. It was necessary to stop tanks 40 kilometers from Tbilisi. And I will not forget that Mr. Medvedev kept his word.

So, either we are friends, or we are not. But if we are friends, if we are partners, and if we are allies, I really do not see why we should not have projects together. You tell me: a very important transfer of technology, a transfer of technology, because all the countries of the world, when we sell them something, ask for technology, regardless of the field and regardless of the country.

You know, there is one thing I am sure of, if we had not built them, others, including in Europe, would have been happy to build them. I am thinking particularly of our Spanish friends.

Honestly, I stand by the decision. You have always heard me say the same thing. There is no hidden agreement; we do not need one. Moreover, at the time we concluded, I do not think the Libyan affair had started, since I was at the Saint-Nazaire shipyard at the time and we were not engaged in Libya. So, there is no link between the two files. When Mr. Medvedev abstained simply on Resolution 1973, we had not finished negotiating the contracts.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, a few weeks ago you accepted an invitation from the CNT to go to Benghazi. Have you made progress on the project and when do you plan to go there?

THE PRESIDENT -- Yes, I have spoken about it several times, including with Alain Juppé and President Jibril, who is a man of great quality, at the head of the CNT. He renewed this invitation to me. Alain Juppé and I will go to Benghazi when the time comes. But we wish that at that moment, when the time comes, we can make a working visit and meet all those who want to build the democratic Libya of tomorrow. And this is entirely in agreement with the members of the CNT. And I would like to specify that, in our idea, we have discussed it with David Cameron, this should be a Franco-British initiative. We are linked; we have the same analysis. It would seem to me quite clumsy to do it separately. So yes, it is still on the agenda. For a number of reasons, we have not yet set a date.

QUESTION -- Why did the G8 not opt for the cancellation of Tunisia's debt? And could we name the e-G8, the e-G9, since Mark Zuckerberg heads a population that far exceeds several Western countries?

THE PRESIDENT -- It was a message for Mark Zuckerberg; he will be sensitive to it. Regarding the question of debt cancellation, as you know, we are not closing the door at all, Mr. Juppé and I, but it does not happen within the framework of the G8; I believe it is the Paris Club. This may seem heavy to our Tunisian friends, but there are rules, because there are many poor countries, unfortunately, countries poorer than Tunisia, that if we decide for one unilaterally, the question of all the others naturally arises. So, this is not at all a door that is closing; we will have the opportunity to talk about all this because Mr. Juppé will gather all the foreign ministers of the G8 with the foreign ministers of Egypt and Tunisia. We will do the same for the finance ministers, because once we have defined our frameworks and the overall envelope of 40 billion dollars, now we need all the implementation. It does not happen just like that. There is immense technical work to continue.

QUESTION -- One more question about Libya. There are currently substantial Libyan funds frozen around the world, funds that are frozen under the UN decision. Did you discuss during this G8 a possible unfreezing of these funds in favor of the national council, finally the council in Benghazi, with all that this would obviously imply in terms of increased recognition of this same council? And by the way, what is your personal opinion on this not-so-simple question?

THE PRESIDENT -- My opinion is that I would like it to go faster because the CNT needs resources. The funds you are talking about are assets illegally held abroad by a number of Libyan personalities associated with the current power. But this raises legal problems because we are states governed by the rule of law, and in states governed by the rule of law, the end does not necessarily justify the means. That is why it is a bit heavy. It is one of the files that Mr. Juppé is working on most actively because, of course, the CNT needs money. There is this money that is blocked, and it is not moving fast enough.

Ladies and gentlemen, I would like to take this opportunity, before thanking you for covering this G8, to thank our Norman friends, to thank the people of Deauville, whom I imagine we have greatly inconvenienced. Things have not been simple for them. But surely they will console themselves by imagining that their city and their region are here, present before the television cameras of the whole world.

And I find that Normandy has reserved its most beautiful adornments for us with a typical Norman weather without excess, that is to say a magnificent trailing sky, some sun, and really very, very little rain. I know that the rain is awaited by farmers, including here, but it was really a way to show that in Normandy, there is movement and that every minute we live on the soil of this region is different. There you go, and we understand why all these painters and all these writers fell in love with Normandy. Last night we all dined together; it lasted until quite late, but we were facing the beach, and there was this extraordinary sky that changed completely during the meal, and I can tell you that Mrs. Merkel was particularly sensitive to it. And if Angela is sensitive and happy at the G8, then it means that the G8 was indeed a great success.

Thank you all.