Press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the outcome of the G20 Summit and on the crisis in the Eurozone, in Cannes on November 4, 2011.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

4 November 2011 · G20 Summit · Cannes, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed a press conference in Cannes on November 4, 2011, summarizing outcomes of the G20 Summit regarding the Eurozone crisis and global economic governance.
Main themes
Eurozone crisis response, G20 Summit outcomes, Greece debt crisis, Italy fiscal measures, IMF resource strengthening, global growth strategy, financial regulation, tax havens, systemic banks oversight, social protection and growth, French G20 presidency priorities, international economic coordination
Duration
~44 min
92nd percentile
Words
5,328
92nd percentile
Sentences
262
94th percentile
Readability
54
73rd percentile
Grade
10.7
29th percentile
Syntax
2.92
36th percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
31st percentile

G7 / G20 Summit Communiqués Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

262 sentences in 62 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen, good morning,

After two days of very intense discussions and an atmosphere marked both by the gravity of the situation and the necessity for unity within the international community, we have worked on both short-term issues to reduce the impact of the crises and long-term issues to guide the global economy back to the path of growth.

I would like to share with you, in a few words, the three messages from the summit.

The first concerns Europe, which has done everything to provide a credible response to the crisis. It was essential for Europe to arrive united at the G20. We also have the unanimous support of our partners, and it seems to me that we have made progress on three essential points in the implementation of the agreement of October 27.

The first point is Europe’s firm stance towards Greece, which has sparked the necessary collective awareness of the stakes for the future of this great country. The conditions are being created in favor of a consensus in Greece on the agreement of October 26, and we are very pleased that the atmosphere today in Greece is nothing like what it was at the beginning of last week.

The second element regarding the European crisis, I would like to commend Italy for taking the necessary measures to restore confidence, achieve budgetary balance by 2013, and strengthen its growth. Italy is an essential country in the eurozone, one of the largest economies in the world, and I want to commend Italy's decision to call on the European Commission and the IMF to certify the results achieved, on a quarterly basis, with results that will be published. These evaluations will naturally be made public.

Finally, we have committed to strengthening the resources of the IMF if the need arises. And we have established the conditions to achieve this goal. The IMF must fulfill its role as a bulwark against systemic risk; the finance ministers, at their next meeting in February, have been instructed to deploy several options to strengthen these resources: allocation of SDRs, bilateral loans to the IMF, specific accounts at the IMF. We have not decided between these different formulas, but the direction is clear: strengthening the resources of the IMF.

The second message from the G20 is that we have decided to use all available levers to support growth. The situation is in fact much more complex than in 2009; there is no single response. Washington and London were about "stimulus all around." Toronto was about "austerity measures all around." Cannes is about differentiating situations according to countries, and it is indicated in the final communiqué that countries with solid budgetary situations, I think of China, I think of Germany, these countries will activate automatic stabilizers and are ready to take new measures in favor of growth. We have thus moved beyond the status quo of Seoul, which had led to, you will certainly remember, opposition among countries on this theme. Furthermore, countries with significant external surpluses commit to increasing domestic demand and accelerating the flexibility of their exchange rate regime in order to reduce the accumulation of foreign exchange reserves in the medium term. You can clearly see the major country that has made these commitments, and it is excellent news.

Finally, and this is a significant innovation, the action plan for growth fully takes into account the social dimension of globalization. It is the first time that G20 countries, particularly emerging countries, have expressed their willingness to establish social safety nets. Moreover, there is a commitment from the entire G20 to state that social protection, the social model, the level of protection is conducive to growth and is not contradictory to growth. I believe this is the first time an international summit has so clearly stated that a high level of social protection is favorable to growth.

Lastly, there are strong advances, it seems to me, on the priorities of the French presidency regarding financial regulation. We have decided to publish, finally the Financial Stability Board will publish today a list of 29 major international systemic banks, which we have decided will be subject to transparency and enhanced regulation obligations. The second element is the publication by the global forum of 11 countries that we consider to be tax havens: Antigua and Barbuda, Barbados, Botswana, Brunei, Panama, Seychelles, Trinidad and Tobago, Uruguay, Vanuatu have not established a legal framework suitable for the exchange of tax information. We no longer want tax havens. The message is very clear. We do not want them anymore. And countries that remain tax havens, with banking secrecy, will be ostracized by the international community. Things have progressed significantly, but they must progress further. I would like to clarify that Switzerland and Liechtenstein did not qualify in phase two as long as they do not remedy certain identified deficiencies. The credibility of all commitments against tax havens lies in the systematic publication, at each of our summits, of the list of countries that will not do what is necessary to cease unacceptable behavior. We are not prepared to tolerate this. I would like you to remember that in London, three years ago, I had to threaten to leave the room [if a list of non-cooperative jurisdictions was not published] because at that time the term "tax haven" was not even mentioned. You can see the progress that has been made.

And finally, we have decided to reform the FSB to transform it into a true global financial organization. Legal personality, budgetary autonomy, the ability to enter into agreements with other organizations, and the expansion of its steering committee to include the treasury of major financial centers to ensure the implementation of G20 decisions.

On the international monetary system, this is a long-term project; when France put it on the agenda, it provoked a lot of skeptical comments. Today, everyone considers it to be the project for the coming years. We have therefore set a framework for managing capital flows; the use of capital controls, which is very important, is now accepted as a stabilization measure. There was a mistake in seeing a parallel between the freedom of trade and the freedom of capital movement; capital controls can prove necessary and are recognized as a stabilization measure.

It is also the review of the SDR basket in 2015, which may include new currencies. The yuan is an obvious candidate, given the commitment I noted with satisfaction from China towards gradual convertibility.

Reform of IMF surveillance to expand it to new subjects: exchange rates, capital flows, contagion effects—this significantly evolves the missions of the IMF. Finally, new IMF instruments, a short-term liquidity line to address systemic shocks.

On agriculture, it is the first time that agricultural issues are on the G20 agenda. This was truly a topic that was not discussed. Increasing production is essential to feed the global population. Transparency in agricultural markets. We have achieved regulation of commodity derivative markets. There is an agreement to regulate these markets and the actors in these markets to combat market abuses and especially to empower supervisors to set position limits to prevent a single actor from manipulating prices through disproportionate purchases or sales. When we started with Bruno LEMAIRE and François BAROIN, we did not think we could achieve such a result at a summit of this nature. Finally, community emergency stocks and the prohibition of export restrictions for food program purchases.

On development: innovative financing and infrastructure. Innovative financing is in the final communiqué, with an explicit reference to the financial transaction tax. There is a willingness from a number of countries to bring innovative financing and the reference to the financial transaction tax into the communiqué; they are included.

Where do we stand on this issue? There are now a number of countries that have joined France's fight. I remind you that when France initiated this fight, it was absolutely alone. Today, apart from France, the European Commission, Germany, Spain, Argentina, the African Union, Ethiopia, South Africa, the Secretary-General of the United Nations, and Brazil, which has expressed its interest in the approach, are in favor of the principle of a financial transaction tax. And the text of the declaration states: the G20 recognizes the initiatives of some member countries to tax the financial sector for various purposes, including a financial transaction tax to support development. You cannot imagine the struggle that such a tax represents.

Let me be very clear: France believes that to meet the challenges of development, innovative financing is necessary, given the state of deficit in all countries. And we stated in the communiqué that in the Bill Gates report there are a number of innovative financing options and that each country commits to at least take one of these innovative financing options.

The second element is that we consider it morally essential that the peoples of the world know that the financial actors who have led the world into the pitfalls we are experiencing will be required to contribute financially to repairing the damage that has been created. That is the purpose of the financial transaction tax.

So, the European Commission's project, which is the only concrete project on the table and which demonstrates the technical feasibility of a financial transaction tax, will be submitted for discussion at the Council of Ministers and Heads of State and Government table at the beginning of this year. France will fight for this tax to become a reality, and France believes that waiting for the rest of the world to adopt such a tax is not a sufficient argument to refuse the implementation of this tax. Clearly, we will do everything we can to rely on public opinion in each country to achieve this result.

I would also like to add that I was pleased with Barack OBAMA's willingness regarding the principle of the financial sector's contribution to resolving the crisis. It does not go as far as a financial transaction tax, but his willingness to consider the financial actors' financial contribution to overcoming the crisis is encouraging.

I remind you that we started from a situation of absolute blockage, and now the financial transaction tax is an element of the debate, and I hope it will be a concrete element of implementation as early as 2012.

So, there are still many things to settle, particularly regarding the allocation of the proceeds from the future tax, but it is very interesting because when we debate the allocation of the proceeds from the future tax, it means that we consider the principle of the tax has progressed so much that it is appropriate to discuss the allocation of its proceeds.

France believes that a significant, defined, and majority portion of the proceeds should go to development.

Finally, we had a debate on global governance, with a very good report from David CAMERON.

There you have it, ladies and gentlemen, and I apologize for being too long; I now open the floor to your questions.

QUESTION - To date, how many G20 countries have committed to financially assist eurozone countries in overcoming the crisis? And is it true that you are considering pooling the SDRs of eurozone countries to contribute to the EFSF? And then, a second question of a different nature: have you made progress on the issue of a permanent Secretariat for the G20? And do you think that Mexico, which will take over the presidency, will move in this direction?

THE PRESIDENT - There is an agreement among all G20 members to work, at the meeting in February, on increasing the resources of the IMF. That is a general agreement. All, developed countries, emerging countries, a general agreement. And a second agreement, to reflect and work on the modalities of collaboration between the IMF and the European fund, to expand the capacities of the European fund. And among the avenues that finance ministers will work on, SDRs are clearly identified.

Does this mean that this will be the path chosen in February? I would not venture to say. But here is a timeline: February, a method, and a general agreement from everyone, from the United States to emerging countries. Regarding the G20, we have decided to institutionalize the troika, meaning the current presidency, the incoming presidency, and the outgoing presidency. This means that France will be part of the troika of the Mexican presidency next year.

The G20 is not enthusiastic about the creation of a General Secretariat. Because the G20 must remain a very free informal dialogue forum, and we wanted a very strong involvement from the presidencies and not a takeover of the presidencies by a General Secretariat.

There you go, I believe I have summarized the spirit of the debates quite well, and this is the only point in the otherwise excellent report by David CAMERON that did not reach a complete consensus.

QUESTION - In a speech in 2008 before the Hellenic Parliament, you said you felt like a Greek, so what would you say about the fate of this people if there were a change of government overnight?

Second question, you conveyed a message of credibility for the euro and Europe. Did you also try to send a message of confidence to potential investors, especially to emerging countries like China, to whom you asked to place part of their reserves in euros?

THE PRESIDENT - As for Greece, I have said everything that needs to be said. I am pleased with the complete change in the political atmosphere in Greece. Because fundamentally, what was shocking was not the principle of a referendum. An appeal to the people is never something shocking; it is even an essential subject for Europe. What was shocking was that none of Greece's partners had been warned, and secondly, that it cannot be about a referendum on a plan. Because if you hold a referendum on the plan of October 27, you must be prepared to hold a referendum on all subsequent plans, and why did you not do it on the previous plans? The only important question, if you want to hold a referendum, is Greece's membership in the euro, and I believe that this message has been very well received.

It is a message of friendship towards the Greek people, and it is a message that we wanted to address to both the opposition and the majority in Greece. After that, it is up to the Greek people to choose their leaders and the policies they wish to see implemented. It is not up to us, but we have set a red line, and I do not regret it. The message of confidence for investors - but when you invest in a currency, you want that currency to rise, not to fall. I do not want to be unpleasant to anyone, but if you compare the euro to other currencies in the world, does it rise or fall? It rises. So, those who have put their money in euros have made a rather good deal; it proves that they were right to trust.

In any case, there is a very simple resolution, and Chancellor MERKEL reminded us of it: we will fight to defend Europe and the euro. It is neither speculation nor anyone else who will have the last word in this matter. Europe is the most beautiful construction that mankind has ever imagined in the service of peace, and we have no intention of accepting that it unravels under external pressures. If it unravels, it is because the peoples would have decided so, and certainly not because it was imposed on them. The message is very clear, and Germany and France are perfectly united in this objective.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, at the end of this G20, do you confirm the holding of a Council of Ministers on Monday for the implementation of a savings plan, an austerity plan in France? Is one of the unwritten conclusions of this G20 that France also needs to make quick savings to contain these deficits, and if so, in the proposed measures, does it involve reducing defenses? Which ones? Or increasing state revenues, that is to say, raising taxes, VAT, or creating new taxes?

THE PRESIDENT -- Take my place, sir, it’s better. I am happy to answer all the questions that are asked of me, but this is such a plea that I cannot respond to it. Do you know why there is a Council of Ministers on Monday? Because there was none last Wednesday. It is an extreme originality, I apologize for saying it like this, but there was none last Wednesday because last Wednesday we were in all the preparatory contacts for the G20. I made a decision in full agreement with the Prime Minister, I assure you, really very original, to postpone the last Council of Ministers to Monday. There you go, that’s absolutely all. As for what you refer to as a rigor plan, austerity, it may be what you wish, but we will ensure that the budget of France is perfectly consistent with the announcement made by the Prime Minister regarding a revision of France's growth. That’s all, it’s simple. When you forecast a growth of 1.75, you have an expected revenue; if you forecast a growth of 1, you have another expected revenue, and therefore, if you want to be serious, and we want to be serious, you find the savings, the least expenditures, or the revenues to compensate for the decrease in revenues induced by the decrease in growth. That is what we will have to decide. In any case, what matters is the path of France as it has committed, and this path will be scrupulously respected: 3% deficit in 2013, 0% deficit in 2016. That is the objective, that is the basis, and so far, we have perfectly respected this line, these commitments, and we will continue. We will take all measures to ensure that it is so.

I was already being asked the question; there was the Summit in Brussels, now we are in the conclusions of the G20, I am being asked questions, each step, "step by step" as they say in Cannes.

QUESTION -- It is obvious to you and Mrs. MERKEL that the most powerful governments in Europe have tried to change governments in Italy and Greece. How can this be fair, and once started, where will it lead?

THE PRESIDENT -- What I like most about your question is "it is obvious." If it is obvious, why are you asking me the question? It is therefore obvious that you do not expect an answer, since you assert your conviction, which is entirely your right. But I say that you are gravely mistaken. We did not want to change the governments, neither in Greece nor in Italy. It is not our role, and it is not my conception of democracy, but it is obvious that in Europe, and perhaps your belonging to the island, in the insular sense, makes you not quite understand the subtleties of European construction - it is with a heart that I say this -- there are rules; I would say it is not a Spanish inn, I do not know why this expression is used regarding this beautiful country that is Spain -- there are rules, and if one exempts oneself from these rules, one removes oneself from Europe. It is that simple. Now, our Greek friends, whatever government they establish, we will work with it. It happens that since I have been President, I have worked with Mr. CARAMANLIS and with Mr. PAPANDREOU under excellent conditions. Just as for Great Britain, I have worked with Mr. BROWN and with Mr. CAMERON under excellent conditions. We do not have to choose governments. And Italy has a Prime Minister named Silvio BERLUSCONI who has presented a plan; it is a reality that imposes itself on us democratically, and Silvio BERLUSCONI, aware of the doubts in the markets about the reality of the implementation of the plan, has asked the Commission and the IMF to have what is called a "monitoring." Why would you want to create the conditions for an alternation in one country or another? That would be madness.

The whole problem is the reconciliation of Europe with the peoples, but this reconciliation cannot be achieved through the systematic violation of all the rules. For solidarity to be exercised, we must address our compatriots by saying: "Here, we are going to lend money to such a country." But this country cannot exempt itself from the rules that we impose on our own nationals. No, I truly believe, I assure you that this is a false debate. The real debate is to bring Europe closer to the peoples. That is the essential question, but enforcing rules does not distance Europe from the peoples. It is rather when they are exempted from these rules that Europe has been distanced from the peoples.

QUESTION -- Could you tell us the names of the French banks that are on the list of systemically risky banks? I believe you said there were 29 in total at the G20.

THE PRESIDENT -- Listen, to my knowledge, there are 2: BNP Paribas, Société Générale, there are 2 others because there are 4, Crédit Agricole and the 4th is a collective, well played, thank you, Banque Populaire. Thank you, I thank the front row for this contribution to my spontaneous competence on the subject.

QUESTION -- Follow-up question: were you shocked to hear BNP Paribas announce, in the name of compliance with new regulations, hundreds of job cuts?

THE PRESIDENT -- Frankly, what shocked me most about the behavior of financial actors, if I go in order: the remuneration, the bonuses, the systematic distribution of dividends to shareholders rather than strengthening equity. I find, I say it, that this practice was irresponsible, shocking, and we have equipped ourselves with a legislative arsenal to put an end to it.

Then, I would not want the prudential measures -- I am talking about increasing equity -- to result in a scarcity of credit to the economy, to businesses as well as to individuals.

Finally, regarding restructurings, I would not want to fall into the ease of passing judgment without looking in detail at what is happening. If it is one of the countries where they are closing subsidiaries, to make a plan for cuts, one cannot keep employees if one is closing a subsidiary. I need to look at that. There is so much demagoguery today; allow me not to fall into this ease myself. I will not make this remark regarding their bonuses, their dividends, and their remuneration. I am not talking about this bank in particular, but about all banks in general.

QUESTION -- I did not quite understand what would happen if there were an attack against Italy before February. That is to say, will the firepower of the EFSF be strengthened in one way or another if a crisis occurs, given the time frame, which is three months, which is actually an eternity given what we are experiencing these days?

THE PRESIDENT -- There are institutions in Europe, which I will name, without knowing what they will do, which are the ECB and the Fund, and which are ready to intervene if needed. The question that was asked of me is whether we will strengthen it further. The answer: yes, we are working on it. But the plan of October 27 is more relevant than ever. And Italy is not alone. That is the basis of European solidarity.

QUESTION -- Three years ago, in your speech in Toulon, you called for a reform of financial capitalism. Three years later, six G20s later, what assessment do you make of this great ambition?

THE PRESIDENT -- Frankly, we are no longer in the same world. We are no longer in the same world. There are eleven tax havens. There were several dozen when we started in London; the word was not even mentioned. National and regional supervisors have seen their powers grow considerably. The equity of banks has been strengthened in conditions that have never been seen before. A distinction has been made between normal banks and systemic banks, which are imposed stricter rules. I do not remember, you see, that in three years things have progressed so quickly, even if there is still much work to be done. A lot. But it has progressed in a quite astonishing way. One example: that we can calmly talk at the G20 and put the words in a communiqué: tax on financial transactions. But last year, I would not have been believed if I had said that it was possible. The NGOs, with whom I spoke, knew perfectly well that the Robin Hood tax, the Tobin tax, was something that was talked about among NGOs but was never discussed at the table of heads of state and government. Absolutely never.

The moderation of remuneration, the conditionality of bonuses, the existence of bonuses and penalties, the payment of bonuses over three years and not just one year - but it is a totally different world compared to the one you even knew. Does that mean the world is perfect? Certainly not. Does that mean there is no more work to be done? Certainly not. But let us all recognize together, and you who follow these matters, that it has progressed in a stunning way. It has become the normal subject of conversation among finance ministers; these were subjects that were never mentioned, even in Europe. Even in Europe, Andorra, Monaco, other countries - it was a taboo subject. Today, they have signed tax agreements that take them off the blacklist. Would you have imagined that this was possible in three years?

QUESTION -- On this subject, Mr. President, NGOs are a bit disappointed and feel that the time spent resolving the problems of the eurozone has somewhat prevented the G20 from advancing on your priorities. Do you share this point of view?

Second question on a topic that has nothing to do with the first, the hypothesis of a preventive strike on Iran is new on the agenda. Have you discussed this with President Obama, and is this a perspective that worries you?

THE PRESIDENT -- I understand that NGOs are disappointed; they are disappointed because we have talked so much in the media about the crisis that we have talked less about poverty in the world, about hunger in the world, about the need for development. That is true, it is undeniable. And I share this disappointment with them. However, on the substance of the matter, progress has been made, and they have told me so, much more than they imagined. Do you believe that there was a union in the world that imagined that the B20 and the L20, business and labor, would meet? That we would talk in the communiqué, with countries like China and India at the table, about a minimum social floor? No one imagined that this would advance to such an extent. Moreover, you yourself, in your question, say: "a little disappointed." That is already remarkable, because the role of an NGO is to be uncompromising, to demand that things move forward, to find that it is never enough. That is perfectly normal; it is the enthusiasm for the good causes they defend.

Finally, everyone can see that the objectives of the French presidency cannot be said to have not made spectacular progress compared to what was indicated. When we announced, I speak under the control of the Minister of State, Minister of Foreign Affairs, the objectives of the French presidency, "they won't make it," "it's far too ambitious," "it won't produce results." I would have preferred to tell the NGOs: "there you go, it's decided, the tax on financial transactions, the whole world is convinced." But who believed that? Who thought it was possible? No one, not a single NGO. You know, NGOs are serious, passionate, uncompromising people, but serious. They knew perfectly well that it was not possible, but the fact that it is still on the table and in the communiqué is a considerable progress. The fact that I can give you the name of a dozen countries that view the tax favorably. We were alone at the beginning of the year, and the commitment of Germany, determined, and of the Commission. These are progress. So, you may find me optimistic, but you know in my profession, it is better that I am, because there is little chance that you will be for me. Besides, that is not your role, I willingly acknowledge that.

Preventive strike, I don't even know what that means. Iran's behavior and this obsessive desire to acquire military nuclear capability is in violation of all international rules. And France condemns, but firmly condemns Iran's non-compliance with international rules. Preventive strike, you are jumping to conclusions! It doesn't happen like that! There is dialogue; when dialogue does not yield results, there are sanctions; when sanctions are not enough, we impose more sanctions. The international community cannot solve everything with weapons. You might say: "this year, whether in Côte d'Ivoire or Libya, we did it." But we did it under a United Nations mandate, not preventively for Benghazi; fortunately, we did not wait for disaster. But these are very serious ideas, and they are not things that we talk about like that between heads of state: "oh, what if we did a preventive strike!" No, the only thing we have said is that if Israel were threatened in its existence, France would not remain idle, because we consider that the existence of Israel, after what happened during World War II, is a major political fact of the 20th century, and we are not ready to compromise. But, after all, the preventive strike as you mentioned and the effectiveness of sanctions, there is still a path.

QUESTION -- (inaudible).

THE PRESIDENT -- I am not asking you to be optimistic; that would indeed be ridiculous, and it is not your role, of course. I am simply asking you to look at the difficulty of the problems, the depth of the crises, and the initiatives we are taking to demonstrate to you that, contrary to what is said a bit too quickly, governments can act and are not condemned to suffer.

And finally, that will be my conclusion, if there is something to take away from this crisis G20, yet another one, it is that it is possible to act, that we must never give up, that the peoples are watching us, that the peoples have suffered from the crisis and that we must provide them with answers, and that the answers are not in ease, in demagoguery, and in renunciation. And I make a connection between the tax on financial transactions, the reduction of our deficits, the referendum in Greece. It is that we do not want renunciation, we do not want demagoguery, we want action with results to get the world out of the crisis in which it finds itself. There you go. So then, in the secrecy of your conscience, you will ask yourself whether it is sufficient or not?

Thank you all, and I would like to thank the mayor of Cannes who has received us magnificently, and, in addition, with this azure weather, we felt like we were on the other side of the Channel, and it provided beautiful images, without being too much! Really, I find that in terms of communication, for the city of Cannes, it was truly remarkable. And then, I would also like to thank you, because I know that you have not slept much given the hours of meetings and the complexity of the topics. And it was ultimately quite pleasant to answer your questions. Good luck.