Press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the G20 Summit and the crisis in the Eurozone, in Cannes on November 3, 2011.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

3 November 2011 · G20 Summit press conference · Cannes, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed a press conference at the G20 Summit in Cannes on November 3, 2011, reporting on summit progress amid the eurozone debt crisis.
Main themes
Eurozone crisis, G20 summit, Greece political situation, EFSF implementation, economic policy coordination, financial transactions tax, global growth, development financing, trade and protectionism, EU sanctions and governance, surplus countries, innovative financing for poorest countries
Duration
~19 min
63rd percentile
Words
2,255
63rd percentile
Sentences
93
59th percentile
Readability
54
75th percentile
Grade
11.3
36th percentile
Syntax
3.01
49th percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
15th percentile

G7 / G20 Summit Communiqués Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

93 sentences in 27 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT -- Ladies and gentlemen, just a few minutes to naturally report on the progress of the work and facilitate your work.

The G20 has worked extensively on the economic situation; if I had to qualify the atmosphere, I would say it was serious, with a strong desire for unity and mutual assistance, and a fear of a slowdown in growth that would not only affect the developed world.

In the face of this fear, all G20 members have shown a willingness to better coordinate economic policies, which does not mean that G20 members must have the same economic policy everywhere. Some countries need to pursue their budgetary consolidation, others may allow automatic stabilizers to play a role, or even take additional measures. Finally, countries with a balance of payments surplus must consume more. I must say, speaking under the oversight of Alain Juppé and François Baroin, that there is a good atmosphere; we will work a lot tonight, of course, on drafting the final communiqué, but the countries with a surplus show a willingness to assist in the revival of global growth.

It is true, and I will not hide it from you, that most of the discussions were devoted to the eurozone. Together with Chancellor Merkel, we reported on the meeting of October 27; we indicated the European willingness to move very quickly in implementing the EFSF, and in this regard, there was a meeting this afternoon with François Baroin, Wolfgang Schäuble, Mr. Tremonti, Commissioner Olli Rehn, in order to prepare the work for a very prompt establishment of the fund. The Secretary of State for the Treasury was also present at the meeting.

Regarding Greece, I would simply say that things are progressing, and we are, of course, following the situation with great attention. I believe I can say that the message addressed to the entire Greek political class yesterday, by Germany and France, facilitated an awareness that, if confirmed, would be welcomed unanimously by everyone.

We also heard the report from Bill Gates on development and the report from Tijani Thiam. Mr. Gates and Mr. Thiam have done absolutely remarkable work. The French presidency has stated as clearly as possible that the poorest countries cannot be victims of the crisis twice. Once because they suffer from the crisis like others, and another time because the deficits of developed countries would prevent meeting public financing obligations. Therefore, we must move towards innovative financing.

France has once again advocated for the establishment of a tax on financial transactions, which I am convinced is technically possible -- the commission has done excellent work on the subject -- that it is financially essential given the crisis, and that it is morally absolutely unavoidable.

Needless to say, there is no consensus; some countries are very opposed to it. However, we noted with great satisfaction the statements from the Brazilian President and the Argentine President indicating that they had no opposition to the principle of the tax and that they were very open on the subject. We will therefore continue contacts to form a group of leading countries in this area.

Finally, regarding global trade, all countries indicated -- and this will not surprise you -- that protectionism is in no way the solution, that we must promote the freedom of trade, but that we need to change methods, that we are not obliged to remain in the same strategy that has led to the same failure for years. Therefore, we will lay the foundations for a new method to strengthen multilateral institutions to propose new discussion topics and to protect the poorest countries that need the freedom of trade for the export of their products.

There you have it, ladies and gentlemen; if you have any questions, I will try to answer them.

QUESTION -- Sir, what happened today in Greece, after your intervention and that of Mrs. Merkel, does it not justify "a posteriori" that Europe now adopts prior sanctions against all countries that do not respect deficits? The Germans are asking for this. Does not all this spectacle we have witnessed in recent months, which shows the difficulty you have in bringing extremely indebted countries into line, justify that Europe moves to another stage?

THE PRESIDENT -- Listen, I believe I remember that regarding sanctions, France has spoken about it just like Germany. I even believe I was one of the first to mention the issue of suspending voting rights; that caused controversy at the time. I do not say that it is the solution, by the way; I do not say that, but it is to illustrate. Naturally, there is no rule without the possibility of sanctioning in case of non-compliance with the rules.

What happened? Everyone knows well what happened. Countries entered the eurozone and were not ready for it. We decided on a single currency before establishing an economic government and convergence. And finally, as if all this were not enough, we loosened the pact when there were already all the problems, I would say related to the birth of the euro. But that is the past. In any case, we can discuss endlessly on the subject; we have a problem to solve.

The problem is very simple today: the euro is the heart of Europe. And Europe is the heart of French politics. We cannot accept the explosion of the euro, which would mean the explosion of Europe. The problem must be posed this way and not otherwise. If the euro is the heart of Europe, the explosion of the euro would explode Europe. Now, Europe is the guarantee of peace on the continent where we have behaved in the most brutal and violent way of all the continents in the world, not in the 15th century, but in the 20th century. And it is perfectly normal that two founding countries of Europe and the two largest European economies step forward to defend a European achievement that has been bequeathed to us by our predecessors. The question of the euro crisis is undoubtedly one of the most important crises that Europe has faced - and not just the euro, Europe - since its creation.

We had to find a solution; this solution is a clear discourse, an open discourse, but a firm discourse. The euro implies obligations, rights of course, and obligations for all those who participate. There is solidarity among all eurozone members towards all others, but only if a minimum of common rules is respected. This is what we wanted to remind yesterday with the Chancellor, and I am very happy that there are enough political leaders in Greece who have understood this message and risen above partisan interests to speak of the national interest, because we have always said -- and it was very clear between us -- that we wanted Greece to remain in the euro, but that we could not wish for it if they themselves did not wish for it.

So we have other problems to address; we will take care of them again after dinner because it is absolutely essential that the eurozone sends a message of credibility to the whole world. When we make a decision, it must be applied. When we set a rule, it must be respected. There you go. In a timely manner and firmly. That is the message we wanted to convey, and it is the position that truly underpins the axis between Germany and France, which has a perfect identity of views on all these subjects, and this axis, the solidity of this alliance between Germany and France, in a way, is the backbone of the eurozone. And on the leverage effects of the fund, on the expansion of the fund's capacities, on economic policy, on the reform of eurozone institutions, our identity of views is total, and I would like to say that it is not simply an agreement, of course, between Chancellor Merkel and myself, but it is also a total identity of view between Mr. Schäuble and Mr. Baroin, Alain Juppé, Mrs. Merkel, and myself.

There you go, really, we have managed absolutely all the questions that have been raised. And one last detail, when it came to the tax on financial transactions, the Chancellor wished to speak to express how much she supported this project. So I am not saying at all that we are out of the woods, that things are easy. I am saying that there is a line, and that this line will be maintained. There you go. The question is credibility.

Perhaps one or two last questions...

QUESTION -- Mr. President, do you consider that the political messages coming from Greece today give you assurances that this country will really implement the plan of October 27, and on the other hand, how did things go this morning with Mr. Berlusconi, given that Italy also seems to be struggling to implement the measures that are being asked of it?

THE PRESIDENT -- I do not have to insert myself into the Greek political debate, which is complicated enough as it is. I would simply say that we saw with great interest the statement from the leader of the opposition in Greece indicating his support for the plan of October 27 -- this is an extremely important element that I want to commend because it is courageous and responsible -- and furthermore, the statement from Prime Minister Papandreou indicating that the referendum was not an end in itself, that it was a means, but that if the opposition rallied to the plan of September 27, it was not necessarily useful; this is a state declaration, it is an interesting declaration.

For the rest, I repeat, Greece is an independent country, it is a free country. The Greeks freed themselves from dictatorship by themselves; I have admiration for the Greeks and Greece, I have very old family ties, and I do not want in any way to give the impression that we are inserting ourselves into political life.

On the other hand, regarding the defense of the euro and the defense of Europe, it was our duty. The red line for us is very simple. Countries govern themselves freely, but the euro and Europe are our heritage, and they must be defended. There you go, that is as far as we can go, as far as we will go. We will not go further, but regarding the defense of Europe and the euro, yes, we will do our job.

Regarding Italy, we heard, there was Mr. Tremonti, Mr. Juppé, Mr. Baroin, Mrs. Lagarde, the President of the Commission, the President of the European Council. First of all, I want to express my confidence in the Italian economy, which is one of the strongest economies in the world; it is the 3rd economy in Europe, it may be the 7th or 8th economy in the world. Italy has a remarkable tradition of entrepreneurs.

President Berlusconi indicated to us what the results of the government meeting were. We took note of it with interest, but he himself sees well, with his experience, that the question is not so much the content of the package, but whether this package will be implemented. And that is what we need to work on. And that is what we are currently working on with the Italian authorities. The message we must send is a message of credibility. The eurozone is determined to take charge, to do its duty, and to implement a policy to the end. This concerns everyone; it certainly concerns France and Germany. We will have the opportunity in the coming days and weeks to make other decisions. Prime Minister François Fillon has spoken about it. There are not countries on one side that have absolutely no problems and other countries that have all the problems. We are together; we must react now, and if yesterday's meetings had this interest, it is perhaps a form of positive shock to ensure that everything goes in the right direction.

QUESTION -- A question about the EFSF since, as we understood, there is the credibility of the states and the credibility of this fund; will this fund be powerful enough at a time when Italy is increasingly struggling to borrow -- we have seen interest rates above 6% -- will this fund function as a credit insurer, and will it be able to help Italy borrow when it is in difficulty?

THE PRESIDENT -- I cannot go into detail about the conversation, but that is the very purpose of the discussions we are currently having among Europeans, I mean the States, and among Europeans, I mean the Institutions in the broad sense, as well as with other institutions; I am thinking of the IMF and other countries, I am thinking of the United States and other partners available to support the eurozone and convey a message of confidence about the euro. It is all of these discussions that I hope will lead to decisions that will allow us to clarify the technical implementation of the fund. It is not that I do not want to explain to you; I am sure, in fact, that you know everything, but we need to reach an agreement among many people, and we are concerned with doing something credible, ambitious, and swift. This is exactly what we are working on, and I can tell you that the viewpoints are converging among Europeans and between Europeans and their allies.

Thank you very much.