Press conference by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, particularly on international economic issues and the situation in Syria, in Lough Erne on June 18, 2013.

France François Hollande · President of France

18 June 2013 · G8 summit · Lough Erne

Context
Hollande addressed a press conference at the G8 summit in Lough Erne on June 18, 2013, summarizing outcomes on economic, tax, development, and international issues.
Main themes
G8 summit outcomes, economic growth and coordination, tax fraud and tax havens, automatic exchange of financial information, multinational companies and digital economy taxation, development transparency, extractive industries, Africa and Mali, climate conference 2015, Syria and international issues, budgetary consolidation, anti-money laundering
Duration
~27 min
79th percentile
Words
3,296
79th percentile
Sentences
144
79th percentile
Readability
48
58th percentile
Grade
12.1
46th percentile
Syntax
3.06
55th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
33rd percentile

G7 / G20 Summit Communiqués Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

144 sentences in 44 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT Ladies and gentlemen, this G8 summit has allowed for a useful convergence on several important issues. First, on economic matters, with this reaffirmed support for growth through coordinated policies among different regions, and the repeated concern that budgetary consolidations, which are necessary, must be managed over time and at a suitable pace, so as not to severely affect activity and, on the contrary, even support it in some countries. There was also, at the initiative of France, the desire to ensure that monetary policies do not create additional distortions and that we can have a different vision of competitiveness that goes beyond simply the cost of labor, but takes into account all factors of production, particularly energy.

Still on these economic issues, a significant step has been taken in the fight against tax fraud. This was an initiative that originated from Europe, which had also been affirmed on the American side and which was therefore supported by all the countries present at this summit. And it is this same will that will be reaffirmed at the G20 through several provisions. The first is the exchange of information. The second provision is the fight against tax havens - everyone must make an effort where they can intervene. Finally, the fight against money laundering, which is closely linked to the fight against trafficking and terrorism.

We would have liked to go even further, particularly regarding multinational companies and the registers that could be published. But I take the progress for what it is, important, useful, and which can also be generalized. It was a sign that was expected because if we want to have control over our public finances, the simplest method is to make those who today refuse to pay taxes do so. And we can only achieve this together. Automatic exchange of information is a powerful lever that, moreover, convinces a number of those who had tried to evade taxes to now ask to pay them. They must know, through what has been decided here at the G8, that this will be a policy that will not weaken.

I also insisted that later, the tax optimization strategies of certain large companies be examined. I am thinking particularly of the digital economy, where multinationals manage to thrive in a number of territories without paying taxes attached to those territories. Here too, there are several steps to be taken in the coming years.

The third advancement of this summit is what has been announced for development or more precisely for a certain conception of development. This was the subject of today's lunch with the presence of African heads of state, the president of the African Union Commission, and also leaders of major international organizations, IMF, OECD, World Bank.

What is the idea? The idea is one of transparency: transparency for extractive industries, so that we know exactly the conditions under which they obtain their profits, the transfers that are made. Transparency also, to better understand land ownership, land acquisitions particularly in Africa, because this is a key issue for development.

It has thus been decided - and it is a great idea - that particularly around the World Bank - we had made the proposal - there could be support provided to states, particularly African ones, to negotiate contracts, to support them against extractive companies or a number of companies that request concessions for activities in ports or elsewhere. So, there is also this desire to clarify this requirement for transparency and this affirmation of development.

We were also able to take this opportunity to recall France's candidacy to host the Climate Conference and reaffirm the necessity of having an agreement in 2015 in the interest of developed countries, surely, but also in the interest of emerging countries or those that are struggling to ensure their development. This is a global cause that we must carry and that through the Climate Conference we must, in part, resolve.

Finally, there were the international issues that concern us the most. First, on West Africa and Mali, the G8 members all recognized the importance of the initiative we took and its success, both political and military, in Mali.

I also informed the G8 members that at this very moment, the Malian government had signed an agreement with those who had long opposed its authority and who had even taken up arms without joining the terrorists. An agreement has therefore taken place and it will allow for the organization of the presidential election throughout the territory of Mali, including in Kidal, with the presence of the Malian civil administration and also military elements or gendarmes, who will ensure the security of the operations. It was very important to succeed not only in the military operation - but that was already secured for several weeks - but also, if I may say so, in the political operation, in the preparation of the vote and then in the dialogue and the future of Mali.

We also discussed Libya with the desire to support the legitimate authorities of this country, to provide them, there too, with all the conditions for their security. Because we know well that a number of groups have taken refuge there and can exert pressure on the government, even try to destabilize it, or carry out operations that would concern neighboring states, and I am thinking particularly of Niger.

We also discussed, of course, Syria. Many thought that we would not be able to agree, at least on the Geneva conference. My will - and it was shared by all participants - was to affirm that Geneva could take place within a short timeframe. I know that it is difficult and that there were all sorts of excuses to postpone the deadline. Geneva is the possibility of a political transition. Geneva is the obligation placed on everyone to put pressure on the Syrian regime and, as far as we are concerned, on the Syrian opposition so that all these stakeholders are around the table, not just to be around the table, but to find a political solution through this transition.

In the same way on the issue of chemical weapons, beyond the condemnation of their use, which is the very least, it was therefore agreed that an international investigation would be conducted in Syria to confirm the use of chemical weapons in Syria and a report will be made to the Security Council. The purpose of this summit was not to resolve the Syrian issue - who could have claimed that? - but at least to set the framework, Geneva, the deadline, as soon as possible, and the objective, the transition, and from there to be able to initiate the investigation into chemical weapons.

There you have it, ladies and gentlemen, this is the significance of this G8. We will have the opportunity to see the possible extensions at the G20 which will meet in early September in Saint Petersburg. Ultimately, it will be the same themes that will be discussed: what do we want for our economies, do we want to promote growth, fight against unemployment, ensure that we can have a balance and rules for trade, since here the trade negotiation between Europe and the United States was launched even as the one being conducted between Europe and Canada is not yet completed.

We will therefore have this theme again at the G20: how to promote growth, how to better regulate economies and particularly through taxation, how to ensure development, how to put emerging countries in a position where they can also have a say in the evolution of the world. And finally, to return to what wounds the conscience at the moment and has for too many months, namely the Syrian conflict.

QUESTION - Mr. President, hello, Jeff WITTENBERG from FRANCE 2. Among the discussions you had during this G8, there was one yesterday with Vladimir PUTIN. How would you qualify the atmosphere and the outcome of that meeting given that, as we know, the positions, particularly on Syria, are very divergent?

And furthermore, still regarding Russia, we learned this afternoon that the Duma, the Russian Parliament, has voted a law that will now prohibit the adoption of Russian children by single individuals or same-sex couples in countries like France, which have adopted a law in this regard. What is your comment on this position? Thank you, Mr. President.

THE PRESIDENT - With Russia and President PUTIN, we have bilateral relations in the economic sphere that only need to improve and we are making sure that this is the case. In the same way, on the issue of human exchanges, whether in the academic, scientific, or cultural fields, we ensure that the historical relationship between France and Russia can experience new developments. But we have divergences, particularly on the issue of Syria, I will return to what the Duma has just decided.

We have expressed our divergences. I must say that President PUTIN understood that he also had an interest in the sense that he wants stability, that this conflict that exists in Syria does not last, that this Geneva conference is now planned and that he has a responsibility, since he supplies arms to the regime, since he supports it. It is to put pressure on ASSAD, so that this Geneva conference takes place and a political transition occurs.

On the Duma's decision, it is Russia's sovereignty, but if Russia wants to take its place - and I believe that is its intention - in the global concert as a great country that wants to affirm democratic values and human rights, I think that Russia must understand the evolution of our societies.

QUESTION - Mr. President, hello, Adrien GINDRE, BFM TV. To follow up on my colleague's question about Vladimir PUTIN, what was the Russian president's attitude in the meetings you had with him, the discussions, and what are you asking him now, do you believe you have received all the necessary guarantees from Russia regarding its attitude and the actions it will take with the regime now?

THE PRESIDENT - President PUTIN accepted the discussion, and notably last night at dinner and again this morning. He accepted the discussion, not just to express his point of view - I had already heard it on several occasions and again in the bilateral meeting I had with him yesterday - but to find solutions that could be common. Particularly on chemical weapons, he accepted that there could be this investigation, since he denies that there has been the use of chemical weapons. He therefore accepted the investigation and the referral to the Security Council. On the Geneva conference, we found common ground, including on the expression "quick timeframe" for its convening. He therefore accepts this framework. Finally, on the political transition, he is more cautious, but it is up to us to continue to exert pressure and to make our arguments known. But I said it from the beginning of this G8 summit, it was not here that we would resolve the Syrian issue. Here, we could set the framework, the Geneva Conference, the deadline, as soon as possible, and the idea of an exit, the political transition, that is what has been done.

QUESTION - Mr. President, Valérie NATAF, TF1. The Canadian Prime Minister described this summit as a G7 plus one, do you share this opinion?

THE PRESIDENT - Having not sat in the G7, I cannot know what it was. But this framework exists, the G8, it has its merit, precisely because Russia is there, because to resolve the Syrian issue, we need an active Russia that can take its part in the political resolution of this conflict. If we had held a meeting simply with those who were already in agreement, it would not have advanced the process. There, in a certain way, a step has been announced - the Geneva conference - within a quick timeframe. To find solutions, it is better that not everyone is in agreement - and in this case, we were served! - not in agreement at the start because afterwards we need to find the compromise.

QUESTION - Hello, Antonin ANDRE, EUROPE 1. You seem to have made a point on the fight against tax havens. The United Kingdom, in particular, has managed to include in this agreement the tax havens that depend on the Crown, the Cayman Islands, Bermuda, the Virgin Islands, Jersey. How will France approach this, particularly regarding Monaco and Andorra?

THE PRESIDENT - From Andorra, as you know, because you are well informed, I am the co-Prince, so I also have a responsibility. I want to say to those who might be listening, I am the co-Prince by function, I did not become one by force. This is therefore a provision that has existed, fortunately for a long time, and which allows us to have a discussion with the Andorran government. And precisely on the tax issue, there have been commitments from Andorra and some initial progress that has been noted. I spoke about it again recently. There will therefore be deliberations on most taxes that will be taken by the Andorran government. With Monaco, there are also specific agreements, and we are striving to ensure that there are no tax havens, including in France.

QUESTION - What is the timeline?

THE PRESIDENT - As the communiqué would say, in the quickest possible time. But on this, with Monaco, we have responsibilities, we are present, we have discussions. We can move things forward. It is indeed an obligation because we cannot accept that there may be areas where there are exemptions that cannot maintain fair competition.

QUESTION - Yes, Mr. President. [Hervé Asquin, AFP] To return to Syria for a moment, the final communiqué talks about organizing this international conference on Syria as soon as possible. This is certainly a way to salvage the outcome of this G8, to avoid a glaring failure, but it is also a rather vague way to mention a timeline. Do you still hope for this conference in July, before the G20, or before the end of the year?

THE PRESIDENT - You are used to diplomatic vocabulary; there could have been "quick timelines," there could have been "short timelines," but there was "as soon as possible." So we had this discussion. The idea could have been to indicate a date, but that would have assumed that the commitment could be kept, and if the date had not been respected, what would we have said, that there would be no more Geneva?

I felt, since we were talking about President PUTIN, that he was rather inclined to the idea of moving quickly, and that gives prospects for Geneva. And I myself mentioned a meeting: it is Saint Petersburg at the beginning of September. So we will have the opportunity to revisit this question, to evaluate, and to see where we stand. And from there, if it has not been done, in what specific timelines to act. That is why this summit on this formula is not a way to save face but rather to find a way out.

QUESTION - Mr. President, Yves-Michel RIOLS from MONDE. If at the end of this deadline at the end of September that you just mentioned, there has been no substantial progress, do you think that France would be in a position at that time to publicly announce whether it would decide to openly arm the rebels or not? Second question on the scope of the conference, do you think it is conceivable for Iran to participate in these negotiations?

THE PRESIDENT - Military pressure through a possible delivery of arms must continue to be exerted. This is a way to ensure the convening of Geneva. Regarding Iran's presence, let us wait for the statements from the new president, let’s see if he can be useful. And I give you my position: if he can be useful, yes, he will be welcome.

QUESTION - Mr. President, Cyril ADRIAENS, LCI. President OBAMA expressed in a television interview his skepticism about American military action in Syria and the creation of a no-fly zone. So, did you discuss this together, and more broadly, how did your meeting go? I believe you invited him to "land" at any time when he wished?

THE PRESIDENT - I did indeed invite him to the ceremonies for the 70th anniversary of the landing on June 6, 2014. And he told me he was considering this possibility. But I told him he could come at any time.

On your question regarding Syria, it is President OBAMA who made this statement himself, considering that the idea of an intervention for the Americans is not currently on the agenda. I think all our efforts must be focused on pressure on the Syrian regime, so that there is the Geneva conference. That is the scenario.

And to achieve this, we must support the Syrian opposition by all means: humanitarian, material, political. And we must ensure that the Syrian opposition - and this is a condition - is very clear regarding certain groups whose terrorist nature is recognized. This is what must be done in the coming days.

QUESTION - Yes, I wanted to ask a question about the composition of the G8; do you find it suitable for the world of 2013? Do you particularly find it normal that a country like China is absent from this organization?

THE PRESIDENT - The ideal would be to have an Economic Security Council. And that is what, moreover, France promotes for the reform of the United Nations organization. The creation of an Economic Security Council, which would proceed from the General Assembly, and we could find the main components of the global scene.

There is the G20, which has been a progress and which has allowed major countries like Brazil, India, and China to be associated with discussions about the future of the world, particularly in economic terms. So the G7 has lived, the G8 still has a reason to exist, but this reason for existence can only be conceived because there is the G20 and this perspective of also having the framework of the United Nations. Let us not forget the framework of the United Nations; this is France's traditional position, and it is just because that is where the future of the world is discussed with all countries. That is why I will be at the United Nations General Assembly in September.

QUESTION - Just one last question about Syria; the declaration does not openly mention the departure of Bashar El-ASSAD. Everyone says that this is a concession made to the Russians; is that your reading?

THE PRESIDENT - There will be no future for Syria with Bashar El-ASSAD. The Russians are not yet ready to say or write this, but speaking of transition, what does that mean if not a transitional government where all components of Syrian society would be present, but necessarily without Bashar El-ASSAD? It is hard to see how he could be responsible.

I wanted to mention the question of the trade negotiation between Europe and the United States to say that it was not a topic in this G8, in the sense that the negotiation has been opened, it has been announced, but no question was asked of me.

Moreover, I do not see why it would have been asked of me as the French President because there has been a position from Europe, a mandate given to the European Commission by the governments. And it is this mandate that will be scrupulously respected. And France, at any time, if the question of audiovisual services and cultural exception were to arise, would always have the same position.