Press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, notably on the Iranian issue and on international action in response to the economic crisis and climate change, in L'Aquila on July 8, 2009.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

8 July 2009 · G8 summit press conference · L'Aquila, Italy

Context
Sarkozy addressed a press conference at the G8 Summit in L'Aquila, Italy on July 8, 2009, reviewing decisions on Iran, the economy, and climate.
Main themes
Iranian political crisis, G8 summit outcomes, economic crisis and stimulus plans, financial regulation, climate change and temperature limits, bank bonuses, energy price speculation, Clotilde Reiss detention, Holocaust denial condemnation, international coordination
Duration
~40 min
90th percentile
Words
4,818
90th percentile
Sentences
251
93rd percentile
Readability
58
83rd percentile
Grade
9.9
19th percentile
Syntax
2.93
38th percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
18th percentile

G7 / G20 Summit Communiqués Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

251 sentences in 57 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT - Good morning everyone, I apologize for the late hour of this meeting, but it is still better to explain the decisions that have been made once the meetings have taken place rather than before.

I had the opportunity to hear some of your colleagues indicate that the G8 would not take any resolutions on Iran. Obviously, since we only discussed it at dinner, it was difficult to take any before. I know that an Italian minister has indicated a position, but to my knowledge, he is not around the G8 table. Therefore, the subject of Iran was mentioned at dinner, and there is a statement that shows the unity of the G8 in the face of the situation in Iran. Franck LOUVRIER can distribute the statement to you right away.

There is a strong consensus, including from Russia, to give negotiations a chance, but with a meeting in Pittsburgh where we will assess the progress or lack of progress. And at that moment, of course, if there are no advances, we will be compelled to make decisions together. That is what was discussed among us.

As far as I am concerned, I want to say as clearly as possible that the violence used by the Iranian authorities against the legitimate desire for truth of the Iranian people is deeply shocking. Saying this is not interfering in Iran's affairs because the first to demand the truth are the Iranians themselves. And the first victims of this blind and absurd violence are also the Iranians.

I also want to say that Tehran's behavior towards certain foreign nationals is simply unacceptable. We stood in solidarity with our British friends when their nationals were affected. Today, it is France that is targeted. These methods are nothing but blackmail, and we do not accept them. Clotilde REISS must be released immediately because this young woman is innocent, and everyone knows it.

The G8 has therefore condemned Tehran's inexcusable attitude. For the first time, the G8, at France's request, has unequivocally condemned the unacceptable statements regularly made by the Iranian President regarding the denial of the Holocaust.

Now regarding the work that occupied us at lunch and during the afternoon:

On the economic crisis, we agreed on four observations.

The first observation is that although there are signs of stabilization, the economic crisis is not over. This was a unanimous analysis from the G8 members.

The second observation is that we must implement the stimulus plans we have decided upon. It is certainly not the time to relax our efforts. Today, the priority is to get back on the path of economic growth and to engage all together in the stimulus plans to regain growth. Of course, the question of exiting the crisis and deficits will arise, but only when we have regained growth. We must not relax our efforts.

The third observation is that we have made this unanimous analysis: when we coordinated our efforts in the service of a genuine economic ambition, we succeeded. This is particularly what we did in London regarding regulation, and we all agree that Pittsburgh, the meeting in September, should mark progress in terms of regulation and concrete results. We will not go back to how it was before.

The fourth observation is vigilance. We are sending a very clear message to banks that might start implementing extravagant bonus systems again and think that they can continue after the crisis as they did before. There are a number of leaders who will not accept that. We are going to Pittsburgh with great ambitions.

I was also very pleased with the near unanimity on the need to stabilize energy prices. It is quite incredible that while there is less oil consumption, the price of oil has increased by 75% since the low price a few months ago. I hope I am being understood. That the price of a raw material increases when demand increases makes sense, but here, demand has decreased and the price has increased, which shows that we are in a speculative market that needs transparency, and we must work, as we proposed with Gordon BROWN, on a price range system, which is included in the statement.

Finally, because I think you prefer to ask questions, of course, I do not want to be too long, on climate, I ask you to have a fair assessment of the G8 results, because I remember the G8 in Heiligendamm where, with Angela MERKEL, we did not manage to include a single figure in the statement because the President of the United States at the time opposed it, because Canada opposed it, and others. We did not succeed. Two years ago, there was nothing.

So for the first time, the G8 commits to limiting global warming to 2 degrees above pre-industrial levels, which is exactly what the IPCC experts recommended. This is very important because everything will stem from this. We did not succeed in Heiligendamm, we did not succeed in Japan, but now the G8 has agreed on a goal: we limit the increase in temperature to 2 degrees, as stated by the IPCC experts. There are indeed many disagreements that remain, but this goal is now set, and I am hopeful that tomorrow we will manage to convince the major emerging countries to adopt the same goal. In any case, that will be tomorrow's work. But for the G8, it is done, and it is a significant step that countries like the United States, Canada, and Japan accept.

Secondly, the G8 commits to an 80% reduction in greenhouse gas emissions by 2050. We would have liked the G8 to set an intermediate target like Europe; I will not lie to you, I fought when I was President of the Council for Europe to set a target for 2020, and I do not see why I would not fight for the G8 to set the same target. We are not there yet. So why are we not there yet? We discussed this, particularly with the President of the United States, who has done considerable work compared to the traditional position of the United States, which must pass its project in the Senate, and who is fully aware, at least in the discussion we had together, that the ambition of the American plan is less than the European plan, but fundamentally, we need to get this American plan through. This requires that each of us understands the difficulties of one another.

That is where we stand. There are disagreements; we want an intermediate target. There are still 150 days until Copenhagen, so we will fight on that. We have Pittsburgh, we have the United Nations General Assembly, we will talk about it, we will not abandon this request; we know it is there. Let's start from the top. I also know that there is a lot of expectation regarding taxation, but what is very important is to have this goal; after that, the rest is just modalities. We also have time to achieve it. If we put the issue of taxation on the table, we risk not achieving the long-term goal.

On the issue of taxation, progress is being made; there was the extremely interesting WTO report that states that a carbon tax at the borders is now compatible with WTO rules, which is a first step. I spoke with the President of the United States about the opportunity of a carbon tax; the United States is working on a carbon tax, and I asked that we also work on it as a negotiating element with the major emerging countries that must choose: either they make an effort like us, or we will rebalance the conditions of competition. There is all the work on green taxation within pollution taxation. I indicated that France will very quickly establish a tax in this area. Europe will have to work on it.

So this is a G8 that marks spectacular progress compared to the last two G8s I had the opportunity to participate in.

Finally, we talked about the development of Africa. We reaffirmed that all commitments made in recent years will be honored. France, despite the crisis, will keep its commitments in terms of development. I remind you that we were at 0.38% of GDP in 2007, we moved to 0.39 in 2008, and we will be at 0.44% of GDP in 2009. We are the second largest contributor in the G8 in terms of GDP share.

On the two subjects we addressed today. Health, I announced in 2007 that France would dedicate one billion dollars per year to health in Africa; we are there, including 300 million euros for the Global Fund to fight AIDS.

And on food security, France has decided to dedicate one and a half billion euros over three years, 2009, 2010, 2011. I add that at our request, the G8 has agreed to be accountable for its commitments. Each year, we will publish the figures of aid provided sector by sector so that you can compare.

There you go, I apologize for being certainly too long, I will be very happy to answer your questions if you naturally have any.

QUESTION - Mr. President, regarding the coordination of economic policies in terms of stimulus, have we made progress, do you have any new elements? Because the spectacle that has been given to us by the major industrialized countries in recent weeks and months has not necessarily gone in the direction of strong coordination.

THE PRESIDENT - Frankly, I find you harsh. Let's take some examples. You are right; when the Americans decided to let Lehman Brothers fall and the first Paulson plan on banks, they did it on their own, we discussed this afternoon, but after that, it was not the case. We coordinated the support plans for banking activity first in Europe and then between Europe and the United States. The coordination worked, and that is indeed what stopped the financial crisis.

Secondly, on economic stimulus, I also find you harsh because, in essence, during the China-Europe Summit, when the Chinese announced that they were putting 800 billion dollars into the stimulus, we Europeans were quite pleased. And when Barack OBAMA announced the American economic stimulus plan, we can say that there was coordination from all regions of the world. We might think that Europe did not do enough. I also observe that those of you who think that Europe did not do enough are not the last to indicate that our deficits are concerning; we need to know. Is the stimulus plan insufficient, or is the stimulus plan too large?

It is true that at the beginning of the crisis, let’s say between September and October 2008, there was no coordination, but since then, there has been coordination, and we decided to talk about it again in Pittsburgh.

A third example, London. We cannot say that we did not reach an agreement in London. On tax havens, it was not easy, but it progressed. On financial regulation in Europe, I think the British have now accepted European financial regulation. Would you have imagined that it was possible? We can always do better, I agree, but I think it is inaccurate to say that there is no coordination today. The Chinese have gotten involved, the Americans have been involved, Europe with 27 has made a support plan for its banks, and fundamentally, if we have not fallen into the abyss, it is because there has been coordination. We must continue; not all countries are in the same situation, there are many things still to be done, but compared to what we experienced before, these are considerable advances.

QUESTION - Are you planning to set a date to conclude the WTO negotiations tomorrow? And regarding sanctions against Iran, I do not quite understand; is it postponed indefinitely at least until Pittsburgh? And how do you articulate the debate between the nuclear file and the Iranian democratic repression file?

THE PRESIDENT - It is a bit curious to say that it is postponed indefinitely and to immediately set a date, Pittsburgh, which takes place in mid-September. You, who have a very chosen vocabulary, either you remove Pittsburgh, or you remove indefinitely. It was necessary to reach an agreement with everyone, including the Russian President, Mr. MEDVEDEV. It happens that I was the one who reported the Iranian file this evening at dinner, and we discussed it very frankly. We had to find a compromise situation. The Russian President was very clear on condemning the violence and on the risk that the evolution of the situation could represent - well, it is for him to speak; I do not have to be his spokesperson - including on the nuclear file. And if you really read the statement in detail when you have it, you will see that the condemnation is unequivocal.

At the same time, President OBAMA reached out. There is a meeting in August since the Iranian President will be sworn in in August, if I remember correctly, and will appoint a government. Between August and September, it is up to them to choose the direction of things. We have made an effort to agree not to strengthen sanctions right away to bring everyone along, and those who were more reserved about sanctions committed to saying okay, Pittsburgh is the meeting. It's not so bad.

So do we link the democratic issue and the nuclear issue? The nuclear issue is extraordinarily concerning. Here is an Iranian regime that claims it is not seeking to obtain nuclear weapons and has refused for 6 years all outstretched hands, particularly the IAEA inspections. It would be so simple, if they do not want the atomic bomb, to open up to inspections! There is a phenomenal contradiction.

Not content with this contradiction, the Iranian President multiplies unacceptable statements about the Holocaust being a "joke," about Israel needing to be "wiped off the map." We have a meeting, it's Pittsburgh. And the G8 is unanimous on this statement. These are the conditions for compromise and consensus. But you know very well that for there to be sanctions, there must be unanimity. I think we have made a huge step towards that unanimity. I can say that President MEDVEDEV has been constructive. We all made an effort because we all think it would be a catastrophe not to resolve these issues through diplomacy and dialogue. But we cannot do diplomacy and dialogue alone. I believe that regarding what I have heard in the media about what the G8's decision on Iran would be, it is a considerable progress, honestly. This is an extremely serious matter. I add that behind this, there is Korea. This is also linked, of course. There cannot be one standard for one and not for the other.

QUESTION - Mr. President, I would like to have a clarification regarding Iran. Does this mean that President OBAMA has agreed to shorten the dialogue time he wanted to implement until now, which if I remember correctly was December? And to what extent does Pittsburgh, this summit, have a binding framework for sanctions?

THE PRESIDENT - I am not the spokesperson for President OBAMA, you will have to ask him. I can tell you that we all agreed on this statement which is extremely precise. We do not mention sanctions in the statement but the spirit and what we agreed upon is that. In Pittsburgh, it will be the G20, which is already a lot of people. The legal framework is the United Nations Security Council. The G8 is not meant to replace the G20, and the G20 is not meant to replace the United Nations. But if the G20 agrees, it makes the task easier since there are, notably, the permanent members who can veto. So the legal framework is indeed the United Nations, no one contests that. You can see that in this case, we are taking a political resolution in Pittsburgh that will translate into a number of resolutions.

QUESTION - Still on this issue. When you say if there are not enough advances, this will translate into a number of resolutions. Can this go as far as the use of force, first point, and second point regarding the goal of an 80% reduction in greenhouse gas emissions, apparently the Russian leaders consider this goal unrealistic and unattainable?

THE PRESIDENT - The Russian leaders accepted the G8 statement and it is the G8 statement accepted by the 10 participants that is authoritative. The statement of one person or another, I do not know, I was around a table, I saw what the Russian President said who accepted a statement and the G8 President, Mr. BERLUSCONI said, "everyone agrees on this deliberation," it is the deliberation that is authoritative. On Iran, I have said what I had to say. On the unacceptable attitude of the leaders, on our desire not to interfere in internal affairs, on the excellent news represented by the emergence of an extremely courageous Iranian civil society, and it has surprised many to see the strength of this civil society that has manifested, young people, women, who have given a beautiful example of Iranian society. And a unanimous decision when at the beginning it was not so easy.

QUESTION - Hello, if I understand correctly, you proposed a strengthening of sanctions against Iran. That was your initial proposal. What type of strengthening, what types of sanctions did you propose this evening?

THE PRESIDENT - Listen, we know that we have a meeting, we know that we need to start talking about it and we have decided that we would talk about it in private. You understand that these are sensitive matters that need to be given every chance for diplomacy and dialogue, and if it succeeds, all the better; if it does not succeed, it cannot remain without consequences. It is now up to the Iranian leaders to choose the solution they want: diplomacy, dialogue, openness? They need to respond now. We cannot keep the whole world waiting like this, it is not possible.

QUESTION - Mr. President, a more theoretical question about the G8. You refer to Pittsburgh for Iran for a global decision, you do pretty much the same for the economic crisis, for climate. Would you say today that the G8 is obsolete or that it can no longer make decisions alone and that the only instance that matters is to have several, to have the emerging countries with us, and that is the G20?

THE PRESIDENT - Listen, I am not saying that today. I said it as early as Heiligendamm where I advocated for the G14. We moved from the G14 to the G20 when President BUSH, convinced by the request that President BARROSO and I made for a global summit. I had proposed the G14 at the time, he preferred the G20. That was the compromise conditions for the first meeting in Washington. I have always thought that wanting to solve the world's problems without China, without India, without Brazil, without Africa - notably South Africa - without Mexico, without any Arab country, was unreasonable. You have heard me say this in Hokkaido, you have heard me say this in Heiligendamm, and I am very happy that for the first time, we have a full day in G14.

I wrote an article with President LULA, with whom I share the same analysis: global governance must change, we are in the 21st century and we have 20th-century institutions. So will we have to move from the G8 to the G20 without going through the G14 step? I do not know. Does this mean that the G8 will disappear? No. We can perfectly imagine if we are in G14 to meet for two and a half days in G14, with within those two and a half days, one day in G8 and one day in G6. What I contest is the idea that the 8 are convened for two and a half days and the 6 are convened for a morning. I do not contest, however, the idea that with eight, we have things to say to each other. So the G8 format can perfectly continue to exist within a broader format.

You look at me with eyes where astonishment competes with perplexity, and yet in my mind, it is quite clear. For those who are passionate about these issues, it is simple: we would meet in 14 or 20 and we would plan, in the two and a half days of the meeting, sessions in 8, sessions in 6, and sessions in 14. But everyone would be invited for the duration of the summit. In any case, today, China was not there. China will be represented tomorrow, its seat will be represented, you know the functioning of power in China: collective. China will be represented, it is the time tomorrow for G14, we will be there tomorrow morning.

QUESTION - Mr. President, it is clear that during this first day you could not have made important decisions. You have probably had a discussion among the different Presidents and representatives of the G8. The fact that we moved from Maddalena to L'Aquila had a clear basis. Did you talk about the earthquake, the Abruzzo region, and L'Aquila today? That is my first question. Second question, Mr. BERLUSCONI, in his first press conference stated that the economic crisis is over, it is behind us, what do you think about that?

THE PRESIDENT - First of all, thank you for telling me that we did not make any important decisions! I see that you have listened to me perfectly or at least did not hear if you listened to me. What we agreed on regarding climate, the document today talks about quantified objectives. When we did not obtain these objectives at the last G8, you said: "you did not obtain." Now that we have obtained it, consider it progress. You can perfectly say that we could have gone further, that is what I think, but no one can contest that it is progress and that it is an important decision.

Of course, we talked about the earthquake to express how everyone was shaken by the number of victims that Italy has experienced, it is a tragedy. And regarding France, Carla will arrive tomorrow afternoon, and will visit the earthquake site on Friday morning and announce a number of decisions on behalf of France that we have made in agreement with the Italian authorities.

On the economic crisis, the document we will give you expresses the idea that we are still in the crisis. We agreed on this analysis. Given the unemployment, the suffering, the French journalists know very well that I have never said anything else. However, it is true that several of us expressed satisfaction with a number of positive elements: the stabilization of the financial sector, in China economic progress, President OBAMA also told us that there was some slight improvement in the United States, President BARROSO indicated that we were rather at the bottom of the crisis but that it seemed there was no further deterioration in Europe. This is the analysis we made together including the President of the Italian Council.

QUESTION - Mr. President, I would like to know if during this summit you received a report from the Global Fund against AIDS because it was created here in Italy. Until now you have mentioned what you have done but you have not talked about it? If you discussed during dinner, of course, the appeal from Madam Ambassador of the Global Fund against AIDS whom you know very well, who called on you and your colleagues to accelerate and strengthen funding for the Global Fund to prevent the next crisis which this time will be humanitarian? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT - Yes, we talked about it. We did not just talk about it since France is the country that does the most in health matters and we have given 300 million euros for the Global Fund for AIDS, one billion euros per year for health in southern countries. This is a commitment I made and the fact that Carla is an Ambassador and is very concerned about this fight only strengthens our will to advance this cause. The crisis creates a lot of suffering in rich and developed countries, but it is not possible - and I believe there is unanimity around the table - to let the poorest countries fall behind - we all have budget deficits, we all have increasing debt and yet we will be at the meeting of the promises we made. It is in everyone's interest. We cannot cut funding for development and health protection. From this point of view, I completely share the just fight of Gordon BROWN who has always been at the forefront, in his convictions, in favor of development.

QUESTION - Mr. President, you mentioned earlier Clotilde REISS, do we have any new information about her fate?

THE PRESIDENT - Yes, we do. Our Ambassador is to see her tomorrow morning. He was able to speak with her and will meet her tomorrow morning. As you can see, this is a matter that France takes extremely seriously because it is truly the height of injustice, it is unacceptable. Of course, the messages have been conveyed with the utmost firmness. Madam REISS is not to blame in this matter, it is appalling. To present her as a spy, she was a reader there, she had a mobile phone which is the right of every citizen, frankly, all of this is just pretexts.

QUESTION - Regarding the decision you announced concerning the climate. You emphasized that this was happening within the framework of the G8. Does this mean that there are difficulties with emerging countries regarding Copenhagen? Can you talk to us about that?

THE PRESIDENT - We have many difficulties, but I believe what is important is that the United States and Europe have come to an agreement. Because emerging countries will not be able to say, we are waiting for the United States to do something. I am convinced that we will need to imagine a financing system to help the poorest countries. But I hope that tomorrow we will agree on the two-degree target and that we will continue to negotiate for Copenhagen. But what I have always said, because I deeply believe it, is that we will not win a Copenhagen agreement by simply negotiating in Copenhagen. Negotiation must take place throughout. And Pittsburgh, the United Nations General Assembly will be very important meetings again. But finally, there is a lot of progress.

QUESTION - Mr. President, a question about the new international financial rules. Do you share the intention of the Italian government during the Italian G8 Presidency to make what is called the "Global Legal Standard," or the "LECCE Framework," a true international financial code that has legal character and therefore binding?

THE PRESIDENT - Frankly, if we can have an international financial code, it is an excellent idea. But being less ambitious, I would like to start with a European code. I was very reassured by all of President OBAMA's interventions; there is really a willingness in the United States not to go back to the way things were before. Prime Minister Gordon BROWN is committed to regulation. We have not seen the British so proactive in this area for a long time, and Pittsburgh will be a decisive meeting since we will take stock of everything that was decided in London, what has progressed or not progressed, and then the second part to go much further.

I tell you in conclusion, after the crisis we will not accept that things go back to the way they were before and that the same causes produce the same effects. I am more reassured today than I was a year ago. Things have changed, and they have changed for the better, both on climate and on regulation. I am the first to acknowledge that there is still much to be done. And it is true that we have talked a lot about finance, regulation, climate, less about economic strategy, but even there, it is more difficult because everyone is convinced that the reservoirs of growth are in sustainable growth, but different regions of the world will be in competition. Therefore, we cannot ask for a global economic strategy since, of course, Europe must catch up on its competitiveness compared to other regions of the world. I judge by the content of the statements, the content of the conversations compared to what there was just a few months ago; we have, and it is fortunate, really changed the world.

Good evening, good night, and thank you.