Transcription of the press conference of the President of the Republic at the G20 Summit

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

29 June 2019 · G20 Summit

Context
Macron addressed press at the G20 Osaka Summit on June 29, 2019, summarizing France's positions and outcomes on trade, climate, and multilateralism.
Main themes
Multilateralism, international trade reform, WTO reform, climate change, G20 Osaka outcomes, China-US trade tensions, digital services taxation, platform regulation, steel overcapacity, gender equality, ocean plastic pollution, Iran and North Korea crises
Duration
~26 min
77th percentile
Words
3,148
77th percentile
Sentences
153
81st percentile
Readability
49
61st percentile
Grade
11.5
38th percentile
Syntax
3.00
47th percentile
Vocabulary
2.18
45th percentile

G7 / G20 Summit Communiqués Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Environmental 26%26%
  • Geopolitical 25%25%
  • Economic 24%24%
  • Institutional 18%18%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Not in focus 1%

153 sentences in 24 paragraphs

Gentlemen ministers. Ladies and gentlemen. I wanted, at the end of this G20 and before this bilateral visit to Japan, to report to you on our work and the progress made, the discussions. First and foremost, I want to thank the Japanese presidency for organizing this G20 and for the progress made in various areas.

Indeed, there are subjects on which tangible progress has been observed. Gender equality, ocean pollution by plastics, and several other topics. I will not list them all here. The communiqué has been made public, and Prime Minister Abe himself has gone over each of these points. Prime Minister Abe has worked to maintain the spirit of consensus and international cooperation despite the adverse winds.

And indeed, we have just held this G20 in Osaka in a difficult context for multilateralism. I think we all need to be clear-eyed. And that is why we must also look at the context in which we operate. Because multilateralism is under attack from several of us. Because it has sometimes shown itself to be deficient in recent years, particularly in addressing commercial dumping, for example. And also because we are in a context of extremely structuring regional crises. I am thinking of North Korea, Iran, and I will return to each of these points.

The option that France has retained from the beginning is that, in this context of failure, we can retain on the commercial or economic or tension front, hegemony or unilateralism leads nowhere; or more precisely, to further fracture the international order that is ours. And so, what we have sought to defend here, as from the beginning, is a strong multilateralism, effective in reforming the rules in depth and trying to respond to the fundamental issues that are posed to us. In this regard, there were two main subjects that touched on our conclusions that were the subject of negotiations right up to the last minutes. Trade on one hand and climate on the other.

On these two subjects, there are disagreements around the table. On these two subjects, we have managed to achieve either progress or to fight against regressions. Is that satisfactory? No. But I believe that the red line or the red lines that we had defined were not crossed during this G20. On trade, discussions were held bilaterally between China and the United States. I was able to discuss this briefly with President Xi Jinping. Discussions will evidently resume, but the heart of the response on the trade front is to restore an effective multilateral framework. I have had the opportunity to say this several times. Our future cannot depend on a good bilateral agreement between two powers—be they the two largest. Because the world in which we live does not depend on two production sites but on the interdependence between all the countries that are precisely around the table.

And in this regard, we are too slow to reform multilateral trade. We have nevertheless arrived at a concluding text that clearly reaffirms our willingness to reform the World Trade Organization in all its functions. The establishment of rules, the application of those rules, and the enforcement of those rules. Very concretely, our ministers will have to continue the work in connection with the OECD to precisely build the rules for open and fairer trade, in these competitive conditions. And what we care about is very simple. To fight against uncontrolled subsidy policies. To fight against all forms of distortions of international trade. To have a more effective dispute resolution body.

We then had a long discussion on the issue of steel overcapacity. I remind you that under the Chinese presidency, progress had been made in establishing a forum to monitor precisely this overcapacity. The temptation was strong to end it or to let it die at the end of the year. We therefore asked the competent ministers, before November, to build the conditions for the continuation of this work. We absolutely need to monitor the issue of overcapacity internationally in steel as in all areas where it appears. I say this very simply, because from a European perspective, when you have a Sino-American trade tension and steel overcapacity, the victim is called Europe. And that is what we see in our steel markets. And our companies as well as our workers in these sectors are suffering the consequences of these distortions even though we cannot blame them in terms of mobilization, investments, or competitiveness. So it is very directly jobs, commercial and social justice that are at stake behind this essential reform.

The text has allowed for concrete progress this time on two important subjects: the taxation of digital services and the regulation of platforms. On the regulation of platforms, the commitments we made in Paris last May during the Christchurch Call for stronger regulation of digital platforms and a fight against hate speech or the use of digital space to either promote terrorism or lead to terrorism, have been reiterated in this format. On digital taxation, a clear commitment has been made to establish a minimum tax on digital companies. And thus, giving the Minister of Finance, in connection with the OECD, a work program that will also be taken up in the context of the G7 Finance and then the G7 that France is presiding over. That is the situation regarding trade and economic issues. We see the tensions that continue. Nevertheless, I believe that for certain subjects, the worst has been avoided. For others, we have managed to make progress. Now, very concretely, what we need to succeed in doing is this deep reform of the WTO without which we will not be able to make concrete progress on multilateral issues in this regard.

On climate. I had said it before this summit. I think we are increasingly disconnected from the rest of the world. Scientists remind us every day of our duties regarding climate change as well as biodiversity. Our youth, every week, in many countries, remind us of our duty.

And we continue to have debates about whether we have the right to still mention the Paris Agreement. I think that if we want to collectively gain credibility, we need to take a step forward. Thanks to the work of the Japanese presidency, a commitment from several negotiators, we have managed to obtain elements in the G20 communiqué that maintain the level of ambition as it was affirmed in Hamburg and Buenos Aires, even improving some formulations on a technical level. I want to thank the negotiators who spent many hours of their night and who only finished this morning in the last minutes. Very concretely, we reiterated a declaration to 19, precisely acknowledging the commitment of all G20 members except the United States of America to implement the Paris Agreement. The irreversibility of this agreement and its implementation and thus to continue to make progress on this. We have also integrated commitments regarding the fight against HFCs, you know, these gases particularly used in air conditioners that are extremely polluting. Other techniques exist, which are indeed under development and which allow us to address this issue. On this subject, it is our responsibility; we cannot go back.

We had an exchange with President Trump on this point. Again this morning, after yesterday's discussion which convinced the United States of America to let us operate at 19 and not to ask for a less ambitious text to be more consensual. And this is also the subject of the discussion I had yesterday bilaterally with President Bolsonaro who confirmed his commitment contrary to the concerns that we might have had regarding the Paris Agreement and the fight for biodiversity. We will now be engaged both in monitoring these concrete commitments and ourselves in carrying out clear operations in this regard. But thanks to France's commitment, the mobilization of Europe and engaged partners like Canada, we have been able to confirm this commitment; and here too, to prevent things from being unraveled. But we must go further. And that is the whole challenge of the coming months on this subject.

The French presidency of the G7 will focus on implementing coalitions of concrete actions in the fight against climate change as well as in favor of biodiversity. We particularly wish, on HFCs, to have a concrete commitment from both industry and governments within the framework of the G7 but with willing powers that we wish to rally. This has been the subject of discussions among others with Prime Minister Modi.

And we wish to very concretely advance on coalitions of government actions and industrial actors to move forward on this agenda. Going further is also what we will concretize at the European level in the coming weeks to defend carbon neutrality by 2050. We obtained it at 24 during the last European Council. I hope that by the end of the summer, we can achieve unanimity on this point. I think it is totally achievable. In any case, we have this morning a coalition of several international actors; European countries, South American, North American around this ambition. And we will reiterate this during our G7.

We will then have, in September, a United Nations summit that is precisely dedicated to climate where we must also be clear about raising our commitments, since this is the condition to meet the Paris Agreement and on, among other things, financial issues where France, I remind you, with Jamaica has been mandated by the Secretary-General of the United Nations. We will then have the replenishment of the Climate Fund in the fall. Then COP 25 in Chile in December where I will go. This climate agenda is the one on which France will engage very strongly, whether it is in the fight against warming or in the fight for biodiversity. And indeed, our desire is also to broaden the agenda in this regard. This is what I started to do following the submission of the IPBES report last May on the sidelines of the G7 Environment Ministers' meeting. This is what I reminded President Bolsonaro of yesterday.

And we will have very concrete actions on this subject in the Amazon rainforest. And this is what we also agreed upon with our Chinese partners, I will return to this in a moment, on the occasion of this G20. I had the opportunity to convey these messages during the many bilateral meetings I had with Prime Minister Abe, Presidents Putin, Erdogan, Bolsonaro, Xi, and Prime Minister Modi. And fundamentally, during all these meetings, it is this strong multilateralism that I have also tried to articulate. While we are experiencing the moment of tension that I mentioned, the worst could have been feared during this G20, either on Iran or on trade. We have avoided the worst, but avoiding the worst is not enough. We need to build fruitful agreements and succeed in establishing stability. On issues of general interest and on major common goods like climate, we need to be much more ambitious and accept that a few willing powers move faster than others. And I think that the search for unanimity, including in a forum like the G20, should not be a hindrance to ambition.

And then, on the collective security front, on each of the subjects we have been able to address. Whether it is North Korea, Syria, or Iran, I believe that the sought objective and the final objective of all the interlocutors I have been able to have is to build collective security and stability. The problem is that often, the concrete conditions lead to creating tensions, which in the short term, can threaten this final result. And so, France's role in this context, and this is what I have done through these various bilateral meetings, is precisely to build the conditions for de-escalation of tension. What I hope we can initiate on the Iranian issue as well as what we discussed on the North Korean issue. In this regard, several appointments have been made. With President Xi Jinping, we discussed at length North Korea and Iran. I hope we can work together on these two subjects. I will be going to Shanghai and Beijing on November 5 and 6. And we will have, in this regard, the continuation of the bilateral roadmap set together to continue. But we also wish to have a strong moment of joint commitment in follow-up on biodiversity and climate, and to be able to take an additional step on our commitments.

With President PUTIN, we also discussed the various crises that I have just mentioned. And beyond these, the situation in Ukraine. I indeed wish that we can make concrete progress in the coming weeks so that at the level of heads of state and government, we can restart a meeting in the Normandy format. I do not wish to hold meetings just for the sake of holding meetings. I made this very clear to President PUTIN. And so, this assumes that there are developments on the positions currently taken. Our teams, as well as our ministers, will meet to continue our nocturnal exchange in the coming weeks. And we will have a new bilateral meeting with President PUTIN on these subjects in the coming weeks. I believe that within the framework of the French presidency of the G7, it is essential that we take this initiative towards Russia, which consists, on the one hand, of exploring all forms of cooperation that we can have on major destabilization or conflict issues, without naivety but without closing the door. This is not about changing the G7 format, but about taking the initiative to build useful solutions.

Prime Minister MODI will be invited to the expanded G7 session, and we will develop a common agenda with him on digital issues and climate, in particular, and he reaffirmed to me his willingness to make progress on this point. I also had the opportunity, with my Korean counterpart, to discuss security on the Korean Peninsula, with President SISSI to talk about regional stability and the situation in Libya, and with President ERDOGAN to follow up on our meeting in Istanbul on Syria, and our wish is that we can hold a follow-up meeting under the same format at the end of summer and the beginning of autumn, but on the condition, again, that progress is made, particularly on the political front in the context of constitutional reform and the commitments that each of us has made before the United Nations.

Finally, I want to say a word about two agreements that were signed on the sidelines of this G20. The first is the agreement that our foreign ministers signed between China and France. Indeed, this is an important text for us, which was prepared following President XI Jinping's visit to Paris, which reiterates, on the one hand, the strong commitment of our two countries within the framework of the Paris Agreement, in which we commit together to combat HFC emissions, with concrete solutions, in which we commit together to act for the financing of the Green Fund but also the change of its governance. We reiterate our commitments for 2020, our commitment also in view of the United Nations summit, and we make new commitments in terms of biodiversity protection. This agreement was made public just a few moments ago. I refer you to the detailed reading of it, but it is an important text, an important agreement that not only gives international momentum to our own commitments and actions but also engages China with us, which is absolutely essential if we want to have effectiveness in terms of global emissions.

The other agreement that was signed on the sidelines of our work is the agreement on Mercosur, approved yesterday between the European Commission and Mercosur.

I have always said that a good trade agreement is good for our businesses and our jobs, and this agreement will open agricultural and industrial markets and protect our geographical indications. I consider that this agreement, at this stage, is good, given that the requests we made have been fully taken into account by the negotiators, but it is over time that we will be able to assess the prerequisites for its ratification and implementation, first because this agreement is the one that recognizes our geographical indications, which is extremely important for our agriculture, as no other has done previously.

Furthermore, because the three criteria we set are reflected in the text that was approved yesterday. First, the explicit respect for the Paris Agreement, for the first time at this level, in a trade text. This is at the heart of the logic that we have put on the table for several months. I explained this a few weeks ago when I refused, for my part, to reopen trade negotiations with the United States of America as long as they were outside the Paris Agreement. The mention of the agreement and the commitments related to it are included in the text, and the real change in this negotiation in its final phase was the change, in any case the clear affirmation that Brazil was committing to the Paris Agreement and to the fight for biodiversity.

The second criterion is the respect for our environmental and health standards. No trade agreement should be signed to degrade the environmental and health standards that we impose on our businesses, which is also reflected in the agreement. Finally, the protection of our sensitive sectors within the framework of the quotas that are being discussed, and on which we had set limits. I am thinking particularly of beef and sugar. The first elements we have indicate that all these concerns have been taken into account.

In addition, there is a point that we had requested from the Commission, which is extremely important, which is, for the first time as well, a safeguard clause that applies to agricultural products. What does this safeguard clause mean? It means that in the event of major destabilization of a particular sector, it is possible to activate a mechanism that interrupts the implementation of such an opening. This is very important so that we can manage the actual implementation of this trade agreement. Nevertheless, as I said, we now need to verify all this in the upcoming phases, it is going in the right direction, but we will be very vigilant about all the final drafts, about the ratification process, and especially about the follow-up process. I also wish that full transparency is ensured. As we did for CETA, I want to launch, in the coming days, an independent, comprehensive, and transparent evaluation of this agreement, particularly regarding the environment and biodiversity, so that the follow-up is effective and shared with all our citizens. These are the few words I wanted to say at the conclusion of this G20.