PRELIMINARY PROPOSAL BY THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

16 November 2022 · G20 summit · Bali, Indonesia

Context
Macron addressed press at the G20 Bali summit on November 16, 2022, presenting France's preliminary conclusions on Ukraine, missile strikes, and global diplomacy.
Main themes
War in Ukraine, G20 Bali summit, de-escalation and peace, missile strikes on Poland and Ukraine, multilateralism, Russia condemnation, China mediation role, nuclear blackmail, international law, emerging country convergence, global challenges
Duration
~28 min
80th percentile
Words
3,358
80th percentile
Sentences
113
69th percentile
Readability
42
40th percentile
Grade
14.7
74th percentile
Syntax
3.39
89th percentile
Vocabulary
2.25
61st percentile

G7 / G20 Summit Communiqués Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 34%34%
  • Economic 34%34%
  • Environmental 12%12%
  • Institutional 9%9%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Social 4%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

113 sentences in 21 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen, good evening.

First, I would like to thank Indonesian President Joko WIDODO for organizing this G20 summit and for bringing us all together here in Bali. I would also like to take this opportunity to thank the entire population; I know the constraints that such meetings impose. In this regard, I commend the major role that Indonesia is playing this year for peace and multilateralism and for hosting this G20.

We all knew that this was going to be a difficult G20, and we knew that the discussions would obviously be impacted by the political context of the war in Ukraine. And the events of the last few hours have once again shown us the extreme sensitivity of the situation. In this regard, I was able to speak in recent hours and just a few minutes ago with the Polish authorities. I expressed our condolences for the victims of the missile strikes that hit Polish territory yesterday. I conveyed my solidarity, and we expressed our commitment alongside Poland to clarify these strikes fully. Analyses are underway; we are cooperating with Poland to determine exactly what happened, and we are doing this with all the allies with whom we met this morning.

I also called President ZELENSKY, who has spoken twice during this G20, and I conveyed France's solidarity in the face of the massive missile strikes suffered, particularly during yesterday, which was particularly difficult. Between 80 and 100 Russian missiles were indeed fired at civilians and civilian structures, which shows the violence of the war at this very moment and the very clear message deliberately sent by Russia as we were meeting.

But as I said, the choice we made, based on the convictions we have held for several months, was to avoid any division of the world in this context. This is not a G20 summit that decides peace or allows a war to stop. But at least we had, on the occasion of this summit, a responsibility to send a very clear message to avoid any escalation, to send a very clear message to defend peace and to avoid a division and partition of the world. And I believe that in this regard, despite the differences in sensitivities, it is the clear message that has been sent to the international community and particularly to Russia.

That is why the first important conclusion of this summit is that the G20 did not look away from the war in Ukraine; quite the opposite. Our discussions, based on proposals we had made, show that there is a space for convergence, including with major emerging countries like China and India, to push Russia towards de-escalation, in line with what France had defended at the United Nations General Assembly a few weeks ago in September. Indeed, even though President PUTIN did not attend, the message sent to him by the world's largest economic powers gathered in Bali is very clear. The vast majority of G20 members explicitly condemn the war in Ukraine. This is a fact; we saw it at the UN during the vote on the last resolution, and the G20 takes note of it. But beyond the UN resolution, the communiqué also acknowledges within the G20, including China and India, that in the face of the multiplication of crises and global challenges, the G20 does not want war, the G20 does not want nuclear blackmail, which it deems unacceptable. That if the G20 is primarily an economic cooperation forum, all its members affirm that it is also based on respect for international law. And as I have had the opportunity to remind on several occasions, it is indeed the respect and effectiveness of this international law that is at stake in the war in Ukraine.

Furthermore, on the sidelines of the summit and very clearly following the liberation of Kherson, we have also seen that the lines have shifted. The opportunity we had to exchange with the Chinese president, who very clearly expressed a willingness to speak out against any nuclear escalation, also allowed us to delve deeper into the situation. China can play a more important mediating role alongside us in the coming months to avoid, in particular, a resumption of even stronger ground offensives starting in early February. I was able to discuss this topic with President XI Jinping, as well as the principle of a visit to Beijing in early 2023, with the aim of intensifying our dialogue on this specific point.

I also had the opportunity to speak with Prime Minister MODI, following a very clear line: more cooperation in the face of all global challenges. There is also a desire to re-engage in mediation capacity with Russia. Finally, I believe we have an interest in intensifying dialogue with other G20 partners, and that is the goal of the meeting we held on Monday evening, just before the official start of this G20, where we brought together Senegal—President Macky SALL, also as President of the African Union—Rwanda, South Africa, Argentina, and Mexico to truly create convergences and have a clear message from all our countries towards Russia, with unequivocal calls for an end to this war and for respect for international law.

You understand that on this aspect, this G20 has been useful. It has allowed us to mark strong convergences and to expand this coalition for peace and a diplomatic effort that we will continue in the coming weeks and months.

The second objective of this G20 in my eyes was the issue of food security. As you know, and I had the opportunity to say as early as last March on the sidelines of a NATO summit, the main short- and medium-term risk of this war is obviously the destabilization of our food chains. Given what both Russia and Ukraine represent in terms of the grain and fertilizer market, this war destabilizes the entire world. Regarding grains, while markets anticipated a major crisis due to the blockade of the Black Sea, we have acted in recent months to provide answers, and this G20 has allowed us to sustain them. Indeed, I want to remind here that the European Union, first, enabled, with what we call "solidarity corridors," the export of nearly 15 million tons of grain from Ukraine since April. These corridors represent 60% of the volumes of grain that have been exported from the region. There was then the agreement negotiated this summer under the auspices of the United Nations, which has allowed nearly 10 million tons to be exported since August. The result is that since last April, food prices have been able to decrease, and we are finding ways and means to ensure regular flows of grain exports.

And while Russia threatened to jeopardize this mechanism, leading to a new rise in grain prices, the G20 sent a very clear message to President PUTIN. There has been significant technical discussion work under the auspices of the United Nations and the Secretary-General, whom I thank for that. The agreement on grain exports in the Black Sea must be renewed by the end of this week. Several technical modalities have been specified. It will be tacitly renewed; we have given a perspective to continue this work. This means that our arrangements, as established since last August, will be able to continue, and the various routes we have opened allow us to export grain as we are doing today from Ukraine.

On the issue of fertilizers, we have also made progress since the strategic meeting we convened in New York last September, by establishing during the Paris Peace Forum last week with the Global Food Partnership a new corridor to transport Russian fertilizers from Europe to Africa. The first shipments will be delivered as early as next week, and France will contribute financially. We have just mobilized 7.5 million euros, and this is part of the very concrete facilities and emergency plan we established last September.

And while Russia has announced in recent days its intention to impose new taxes on fertilizer exports, the G20 has also sent a very clear message. It would be irresponsible to impose obstacles to agricultural trade, and we have taken a very clear stance to increase market transparency, particularly through the G20 AMIS (Agricultural Market Information System) mechanism, which was launched under the French presidency of the G20 in 2011 and which is intended to facilitate the exchange of information on agricultural stocks and flows, including fertilizers.

I also want to commend the work of the World Trade Organization, which has delivered its conclusions in accordance with the mandates we set a few months ago and which also allows us to monitor all mechanisms and lift those that obstruct the free movement of either agricultural products or, in particular, fertilizers. We were also able to hold a technical meeting last night with the IMF, the World Bank, the Europeans, and the African Union to continue advancing on the mechanisms for transfer, circulation over time, but especially for developing African capacities for fertilizer production, particularly sustainable fertilizers. This is in line with the strategy and spirit of the FARM strategy we launched as early as last March. So that is the second main aspect of this G20, which concerns international food security, with clear messages, clear conclusions, and the sustainability, in particular, of certain mechanisms that could very concretely result from it.

The third major message of this G20 is a message of solidarity towards the Global South. Indeed, this G20 had to be a G20 of solidarity, and the Indonesian presidency and then the Indian presidency are obviously keen for the G20 to keep its promises. We have also stated very clearly: the poorest countries should not pay the high price for a war they did not want. Since the Rome summit last year, we have made considerable progress that also shows that the G20 can achieve concrete results.

You may remember, at least I hope so, that in May 2021, France launched an initiative in the wake of Covid to help finance, in particular, African economies. After we launched, with the IMF, in November of the year preceding the initiative, a special drawing rights issuance from the IMF, it was at that moment that we decided to launch an initiative to reallocate the special drawing rights of the wealthiest countries to those countries that needed them most. With the goal of an equivalent of 100 billion dollars towards the most vulnerable countries and those that needed it most, particularly the African continent, but more broadly. This goal, affirmed in May 2021 in Paris, was endorsed at the G20 in Rome in the fall, and we have been able to take stock of it. We are now at 81.6 billion dollars of special drawing rights that have been reallocated. This is already a tangible result that is the fruit of our initiatives, of our ability to mobilize the international community, which has allowed, in a very concrete way, countries like Rwanda, Barbados, or others to access IMF programs under very preferential conditions: in terms of both rates, duration (20 years), as well as a 10-year grace period before the start of repayments, but also to fund programs to assist the countries that are most financially fragile.

And so we simply reminded everyone of their duties. To move from 81.6 to 100, those who committed to making the 20% reallocations must do so, and the few laggards in the club must be able to join them. We also wish to continue to technically improve things with ongoing work with the International Monetary Fund, but I want to commend here the mobilization and financial inventiveness. I also wished, in light of the situation we are experiencing, which has deteriorated for these developing countries as well as for middle-income countries, that we go further. France has committed, along with a few others, to reallocate 30% of our special drawing rights or to make an equivalent financial effort.

In the same way, this G20 has allowed progress on the restructuring of the debts of the most fragile countries, which is a key element of solidarity. Again, based on the work we had set up on the G20 finance track, with a common framework, a common approach to debt, to achieve restructurings. We have just obtained at the G20 a first historic agreement between the Paris Club and emerging countries, particularly China, on the restructuring of Chad's debt, which has allowed in particular to restructure this debt and the private debt of this country, which is important, and to implement the framework we had decided.

We will continue on this path and we wish to go further. However, as I said in Sharm El Sheikh, the multiplication of crises, the pandemic, the war in Ukraine and its consequences, and the acceleration of climate change compel us to go further and to create the conditions for a genuine shock of financing towards the Global South. For a simple reason: we cannot ask these countries to support multilateralism if it is not capable of responding to their vital emergencies. In this regard, and building on the results I have just mentioned and the discussions we have had during this G20, I announced the holding in June next year in Paris of an international conference on the new financial pact with the South, which will aim to take stock of special drawing rights, the 30% target I mentioned, on all ways and means to increase financial solidarity towards the South, but also to advance on the reform program of international financial institutions. There will be an important meeting during the spring meetings. At the end of the spring meetings and the G7 that will take place in Japan, we will thus be able, during this conference for the new financial pact, to draw all the conclusions. We must move away from a status quo for the poorest countries and massively mobilize the private sector, in any case mobilize it much more for the energy, agricultural, and industrial revolution and ease some of the constraints in accessing financing. We must also, within the framework of this new financial pact, integrate the issue of climate vulnerability, which is how we want to address the issue of loss and damage that, as you know, is at the heart of COP 27 in Sharm El Sheikh. We are entering the era of climate emergency and we cannot ignore what is happening, what has happened in Pakistan in recent months, which we have all seen, what several middle-income countries may suffer, which are experiencing massive shocks related to climate disruption. Today, nothing in our international financial rules takes these criteria into account. Our aim is therefore to integrate climate vulnerability as an element that would allow us to activate specific financial mechanisms under conditions that will be defined in the coming months. In this regard, we have mandated a group of wise persons on the sidelines of Sharm El Sheikh with the Prime Minister of Barbados to technically advance and define conditions that will allow us to activate such mechanisms. On these three points at least, we will work with our partners: the African Union, but also Barbados which is addressing the issue of loss and damage, India which will hold the G20 presidency next year, the United States which will have a major role to play on all these issues to move the lines, and obviously in close coordination with Japan which will hold the G7 presidency.

Finally, despite the war, and this is the fourth point I wanted to make, because it is an important act of this G20, we have continued to make progress in the area of climate and biodiversity. This is indeed crucial. I reiterated it at COP 27, we cannot sacrifice our commitments under the energy threat from Russia and because there is war. This G20 was a G20, if I may say so, of confirmation and even clarification in climate matters; confirmation because we have not ceded any ground since Rome and Glasgow. The G20 remains committed to the Paris Agreement and particularly to the 1.5°C target which requires us to update our national strategies. We have also made progress in at least two respects. First, through a clear commitment to the gradual phase-out of coal, which must be our top priority. This is the first time that the G20 has taken such a clear position on the phase-out of coal, which corresponds exactly to the strategy I recalled a few days ago in Egypt and which is our international priority if we want to meet our objectives. The second element of clarification is that, after the partnership on energy transition for South Africa that we also finalized in Sharm El Sheikh, it is Indonesia that has signed such a partnership on the sidelines of the G20, of which France will be a part with the funding we are contributing. This is also in a spirit of coherence, on the sidelines of Glasgow, that we launched these partnerships to help major emerging countries phase out coal. We have made very rapid progress with South Africa and finalized it in Egypt. We are launching it with Indonesia and we have finalized the first round of discussions on the sidelines of this G20 and we will continue the work. I could go on longer, I could mention that health was also a central issue at this G20, and I think that here too, it is in a spirit of coherence as we emerge from the pandemic, we are not abandoning the effort and we have reiterated the mechanisms, particularly for crisis prevention and preparedness, with the establishment of this fund, the FIF, to which we will contribute 50 million dollars and also the confirmation of initiatives for technology transfer to the most vulnerable countries or emerging countries. France was at the initiative in the spring of 2021 for technology transfers for mRNA vaccines to Africa, particularly with the South African hub, and I was alongside President RAMAPHOSA to do so. The G20 has very clearly reaffirmed this strategy and international funding. The health strategy, solidarity strategy, prevention strategy, and One Health strategy have been reinforced and we have also, particularly in finance formats, reaffirmed our commitment to finalize international taxation and the recovery particularly on the first pillar which is a very important aspect as you know of initiatives that France has pursued for several years.

You have understood, this G20 in Bali shows us that despite tensions and risks of division, multilateralism and the defense of peace continue to prevail because it is in everyone's interest. Russia did not wish to isolate itself in the face of a de facto majority at the G20 on this point and beyond the negotiations during these two days of the summit and in the days leading up to it at the level of our sherpas. Russia must now hear the message that has been very clearly sent to it by the international community gathered here and return to the negotiating table. This G20 also shows us that we are in a world in reconfiguration. In many respects, this war questions the rules of governance, our own international institutions and that is also why we wanted to take the initiative for a reform of our financial institutions for next year. But we must go further. That is also why France supports the full and complete integration of the African Union into the G20, which is a key element of this reconfiguration. If we want to fully take into account solidarity towards the South, we must accept that the African Union, like the European Union, is at the table. These are the few words I wanted to say in conclusion of this G20, congratulating the Indonesian presidency and President Joko Widodo for all the work done, his hospitality, and for successfully conveying not just this message of unity, but very concrete advances that go in the direction of unity to make it more effective at the end of this summit. I will now answer your questions.