Brussels. Statement by the President after the NATO summit.

Poland Andrzej Duda · President of Poland

24 March 2022 · Extraordinary NATO summit · Brussels

Context
Duda addressed press following an extraordinary NATO summit in Brussels on 24 March 2022, convened by President Biden to coordinate alliance response to Russia's invasion of Ukraine.
Main themes
NATO summit unity, Russian aggression against Ukraine, ceasefire conditions, Russian military losses, support for Ukraine, withdrawal of Russian forces, war crimes accountability, civilian suffering, eastern flank security, international law, diplomacy and hard measures
Duration
~33 min
85th percentile
Words
3,954
85th percentile
Sentences
180
86th percentile
Readability
49
60th percentile
Grade
11.7
42nd percentile
Syntax
3.03
52nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
25th percentile

NATO Summit Statements Translated from Polish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 72%72%
  • Institutional 16%16%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

180 sentences in 52 paragraphs

Good afternoon, Ladies and Gentlemen!

As you have seen, this afternoon the extraordinary summit of the North Atlantic Alliance has concluded. All representatives of the allied countries gathered to meet here in Brussels in an extraordinary manner – because this summit was not planned in advance, it was convened by the President of the United States, Joe Biden – to discuss what steps need to be taken to, first of all, ensure the security of the North Atlantic Alliance, and more specifically, the member countries that are currently near the borders of Russia; I say "near" because not all of them border Russia, but those that are potentially threatened by the evident specter of Russian aggression, which is a consequence of the aggression against Ukraine that we are witnessing today. This is what we discussed today.

But – of course – the most important topic was what further measures the North Atlantic Alliance can and should take in this direction to interrupt and end the Russian aggression against Ukraine.

In summarizing everything we discussed today – which is partly included, and partly somewhat adjacent to what is contained in the official statement, in the official position of the Alliance, and thus of all member states – resulting from today’s meeting, I will say this: I am very pleased that the Alliance maintains unity, that the position is unequivocal.

This means that we must do everything, using peaceful tools, but employing tools appropriate to the needs, to interrupt the Russian aggression against Ukraine, to ensure not only that a ceasefire occurs – which I emphasized strongly in my speech – a ceasefire is not enough.

I will say more: a ceasefire may be precisely something that the Russians need very much today. Considering the enormous losses they are suffering, probably incomparable to anything they have experienced so far – because during the entire Afghan war, they suffered losses that they have incurred in less than a month of their attack on Ukraine.

It is they who need a ceasefire today to regroup, replenish supplies, and improve their logistics. Therefore, so that immediately after this ceasefire, they can attack Ukraine with even greater force and even greater brutality.

If a ceasefire were to occur, it must be linked to the withdrawal of Russian forces from internationally recognized territories of Ukraine. Therefore, from the territory of the Ukrainian state recognized internationally – I emphasize this very strongly. And I hope that this was echoed today not only in my speech but also – which was a great satisfaction for me – in several other speeches by leaders of states and governments. So this issue is fundamental, and I hope that the North Atlantic Alliance community understands it perfectly.

Secondly – without a doubt, everyone spoke unequivocally: "We must support Ukraine with all our might. We cannot allow a situation in which Vladimir Putin, in which Russia wins this war." This war cannot be won by Russia, because a Russian victory in this war poses a danger to the eastern flank of the Alliance, which ultimately means a danger to all of NATO.

We must – of course – conduct diplomacy, but in addition, we must also employ hard measures that will call Russia to order and that will firmly require Russia to adhere to international law. A return to adherence to international law!

Of course, the issue of accountability for war crimes is a completely separate matter. Appropriate bodies are dealing with this today – tribunals are addressing this issue, investigators and prosecutors are gathering evidence, conducting proceedings. This matter is obvious, and I have repeatedly said that the world must rise to the occasion, and those guilty of war crimes that are happening daily in Ukraine must answer before the appropriate criminal authorities. But this is a completely different issue.

Today, the fundamental task is to stop the murder of civilians, to stop the bombing of residential areas, to unblock Ukrainian cities where defenders are still holding out, but where there are still thousands, tens of thousands, even hundreds of thousands of civilians who are deprived of means of survival, very often deprived of food, who do not have the basic conditions for normal existence, who are in shelters, basements, and are dying every day. We all see on the television footage that we watch daily in the media, corpses lying in the streets of Ukrainian cities.

These are scenes that we last saw on this scale during World War II. I say "on this scale" because, of course, during the war in the former Yugoslavia – in Sarajevo and other cities that were attacked at that time, in the aforementioned Vukovar – such events also took place, but not on the scale we see today. These are huge cities: Mariupol – several hundred thousand inhabitants. What can we say about Kyiv – a multi-million agglomeration, a multi-million metropolis that is defending itself today, which is partially surrounded by Russians today, which is prepared to repel Russian assaults, and which is being bombed?

In recent days, we have seen bombings of districts, shopping centers in the capital of Ukraine – terrifying sights. These are images we have seen in archival footage from World War II. I emphasized in recent days that Mariupol and some parts of Kyiv resemble Warsaw in 1944 – completely ruined, completely destroyed, it breaks the heart.

We discussed this today, but of course, this very important aspect for me, as the President of the Republic of Poland – a country that borders Ukraine, a country that is, of course, in potential danger from Russian imperialism – is and will be the increase of the North Atlantic Alliance's presence on the eastern flank of the Alliance. I am very pleased that this topic was raised by essentially everyone and that not a single voice was raised against increasing this presence.

I and several other Presidents proposed that this presence be transformed from Enhanced Forward Presence and Tailored Forward Presence into a forward defense presence – that is, changing its character by introducing additional brigade combat groups, by strengthening the quantitative and qualitative presence of the North Atlantic Alliance, by additional equipping of the armed forces of the countries located on the eastern flank, and also by strengthening with additional equipment at least for the time being, until these countries procure their own equipment, such as missile defense or air defense systems. These were our proposals to our allies.

These are issues that will be discussed in the coming months, because – of course – final decisions have not yet been made on this matter. This is a topic that is currently on the table of all forums where the North Atlantic Alliance is deliberating. We will be discussing this in the coming months.

I believe that appropriate decisions – already specifically formulated – will be made at the NATO summit in Madrid, which – as you know – will take place in two and a half months. So we have two and a half months to conduct negotiations in this regard; to present the Polish proposals that have been put on the table, to encourage their acceptance, to discuss them with our allies. This is a significant task.

Just a moment ago, I also discussed this with the Presidents of the Baltic states. We met after the North Atlantic Alliance meeting and specifically talked about the work that awaits us in the coming months to strengthen the eastern flank of the Alliance.

This is a significant task, but I repeat: for me, a very important signal is that there is fundamentally no opposition. Of course, there will certainly be discussions about the final shape of the strengthening of the eastern flank of the Alliance – what specific quantities should it entail? How should the eastern flank be strengthened in terms of infrastructure?

However, no one doubts that this strengthening is necessary – starting from the Secretary General, through everyone, of course, President of the United States, Mr. Joe Biden, to individual members of the Alliance. Everyone is absolutely unanimous here, there was no opposition, which – I believe – is good news for us. This will certainly strengthen our security.

President Joe Biden once again strongly emphasized that Article 5 is in effect and that there are no conditions under which it would not protect NATO member states. There is no option that if any member state were attacked, Article 5 would not be activated.

Once again, we heard an absolutely firm and decisive declaration from the President of the United States, which – of course – is very important for us, especially in today’s situation, and which I received with great satisfaction. I want to convey this to my compatriots through your mediation, as it has very significant meaning for everyone in our part of Europe and the world today.

I strongly emphasized – and several Presidents also emphasized this – that there is really no point in mentioning the NATO-Russia Act from 1997 anymore. Russia has completely trampled this act, violated all the most important commitments contained in it. And to say today that this act is in force, that it binds anyone, would simply be ridiculous.

In light of the above, we have carte blanche when it comes to making decisions – there are no obligations towards Russia. Russia has violated and broken all the rules of international law. Moreover – it has even broken the rules of the laws of war. In Ukraine, the rules of the laws of war are being violated daily! So what are we even talking about here?

So support for Ukraine once again – support for Ukraine. There was a very dramatic speech by President Volodymyr Zelensky. I must say that my heart ached when he asked for help, for support. There is a feeling that without a doubt we could – as a Euro-Atlantic community, as NATO – do more; that we should be more active in this regard, that we should act more in this matter. This will certainly be a concern for the leaders of the Alliance in the near future.

There were clear declarations that assistance to Ukraine will be increased. I received this with satisfaction. It is particularly important for us that Ukraine is supported, that it does not lose this war, but that it is a defeat for Russia, that Russia breaks its teeth on Ukraine. And in this regard, it thinks twice before attacking either Ukraine again or anyone else in the future.

These are the most important pieces of information, so largely a repetition of what I have said to you in recent days; what we discussed with President Klaus Iohannis during our press conference in Bucharest.

We have planned meetings – even before the NATO summit in Madrid, there will be a meeting of the Bucharest Nine, where the Central European countries belonging to the North Atlantic Alliance, that is us, will finally establish our position for the NATO summit in Madrid. There will also be a meeting – a Three Seas summit – also before the NATO summit, so an additional opportunity to meet in a broader group than just the Bucharest Nine. So we will have many moments for discussions and negotiations.

As you can see, international politics, and especially security policy, is currently unfolding extremely intensively, very quickly – such are the demands of the moment. But I assure you that we are working to ensure security to the greatest extent possible so that everyone in our countries can sleep peacefully, confident in their tomorrow and that none of our countries will be attacked, because we are together, we stand united.

There is no more powerful defense alliance today than NATO – it is known that NATO is capable of defeating anyone. There is no power in the world that the countries of the North Atlantic Alliance cannot defeat when acting together. Article 5 is key here, and collective defense is absolutely protective against any serious threat of attack.

And we too, on our part – as Poland – should do everything to build our own defense system based on our capabilities, on the development of our armed forces, on their modernization and equipping, so that it is not profitable to attack Poland – so that the Polish Army is able to first repel any aggressor, and treat the assistance of the North Atlantic Alliance as support only in situations where it would be necessary.

This is what we strive for, this is the purpose of the homeland defense law, this is why there are new formulas for financing defense expenditures, this is why there are plans for the development of the Polish army – precisely so that everyone can feel safe; confident that the Polish Army is sufficiently numerous, efficient, and well-equipped to defend our state.

Dominika Ćosić, TVP: Mr. President, you have partially answered my question, as I wanted to ask you for a comment on the recent statements from Russia, which are becoming increasingly frequent, regarding the possibility of opening a corridor to Kaliningrad, that is, such clear threats, directly articulated, concerning Poland. And was this topic commented on? Was there any discussion about the fact that Russia is increasingly making it clear that it does not intend to stop in Ukraine? Thank you very much.

Madam Editor, it may not be very political, but in Poland there is a rather ugly saying: don’t scare, don’t scare. We are a nation that wants to live in peace, which has not attacked anyone—especially over the last century. We have always wanted to live in peace. If someone attacked, it was we who were attacked. We still want to live in peace; we broke free from behind the Iron Curtain, regained full sovereignty, independence, and economic freedom, to live comfortably, to develop, to become prosperous, to be able to explore the world, to be citizens of the world. We want this to continue. This is our aspiration as a society, as a nation. We are not aggressive; we do not want to attack anyone.

But—of course—we must prepare for the possibility that someone might attack us. If someone wants to attack us—especially if they want to attack us from the north, or from the east, or from any other direction—they must reckon with the fact that we will stand firmly to defend our homeland. I emphasize: to defend our homeland! And I assure you that it is sufficiently vast for us to have a place to bury the attackers.

Wojciech Cegielski, Polish Radio: Good morning, Mr. President. I just want to briefly ask about the assistance for Ukraine that President Zelensky requested—you mentioned sending 1 percent of aircraft. You also said that this assistance must ultimately end when the war ends. Beyond the declarations and decisions that have been made, what, in your opinion, can the West and Poland do in the coming days, not even weeks, to help Ukraine? What else can be added? Because the Ukrainian side says that what has been provided so far is insufficient.

We are discussing this topic all the time, but I want to emphasize very strongly: this— in my personal conviction as the President of the Republic, but also as one who represents Poland here in the North Atlantic Alliance and at its summits—must be an allied decision. I emphasize once again: an allied decision, meaning one that will be approved within NATO. This support must be such that it is foreseen by NATO. Why? To maintain all the conditions for functioning within the Alliance. And this is important to me. As for what forms this will take—we are still working on that. We are constantly thinking, and experts are considering what other forms of assistance can be realized.

We talked today—about which I did not mention now, in my first statement, in the declaration—about sanctions. In a moment, the European Council will discuss sanctions. The G7 is also discussing sanctions today. Therefore, there are potentially many elements being discussed here—tools that are meant to force Russia to cease its aggression. The only thing is that they must be composed and formulated in such a way that their effectiveness is as high and as quick as possible. Because none of us has any doubt today that the sanctions that have already been established will probably be maintained for months or years. By the way, I believe that their maintenance should depend on the decision of Ukraine; it should be Ukraine that agrees to lift the sanctions if a discussion about lifting the sanctions begins—yes, if Ukraine agrees to that. The point is that all these measures taken together should bring results as quickly as possible because people are dying there every day, and this is no joke.

Maciej Sokołowski, TVN: Good morning, Mr. President. I would like to ask about the visit of the President of the United States to Poland. Joe Biden is coming to our country tomorrow. What main goals do you set for yourself for this visit? What do you want to achieve in talks with the President of the United States? And will you return to the idea of a NATO peace mission? Because today we also hear the response from the Secretary General—there is still no agreement to send NATO soldiers to Ukraine. Thank you.

We are discussing the formula of a certain support plan for Ukraine, very broadly defined. A Polish proposal is currently formulated. It is on the table of the North Atlantic Council. Ambassador Tomasz Szatkowski will present it in detail to the allies in the near future. Of course, please remember that all of these are proposals for discussion, for debate. It is not the case that someone is imposing something on the Alliance—absolutely nothing of the sort is happening. So these are various proposals that are currently being discussed. There are indeed a number of them.

I cannot speak about the details because today’s meeting—as you know—was held in a closed session. Therefore, I can assure you that the ideas for various solutions and forms of assistance are broad; there are at least several of them. The debate on these issues is ongoing. We are looking for the most effective solutions, while also being the most convenient for the Alliance itself—while primarily, in an evident way, supporting Ukraine, helping, responding to needs.

As for the visit of President Joe Biden, it is extremely important and significant for me. What position Poland occupies today, let everyone answer that question for themselves. If in recent weeks we had the Secretary of Defense, Austin; if we had Secretary Blinken; if we had the visit of the Vice President of the United States, Kamala Harris; and today we are practically on the eve, on the threshold of the visit of the President of the United States, Joe Biden—then it is clear what the level of Polish-American relations is today; how significant a place Poland occupies on the map for the United States; how strategic a place it is; how strong the ties that connect us with the United States are today.

Moreover—as I have always emphasized—these ties are independent of all political relations; we are democratic countries. Authorities change, but strategic interests remain. I am immensely pleased that today, in this very difficult situation for Poland, but also for the United States—because these are the strategic interests of the United States; the United States is a global power; we are, indeed, a large country in Central Europe, but the United States is the greatest power, the greatest strength of the North Atlantic Alliance—it is in our absolute interest to build the strongest Euro-Atlantic ties and the strongest Polish-American ties.

This is exactly what we are doing, and in this context, the visit of President Joe Biden tomorrow and the day after to us, because there will be two days of meetings, talks, visits to various places, is of enormous significance from my perspective, and I believe it will bring—already brings, and additionally will bring as a result—very serious strengthening of the security of our country.

You know how it is—of course, the President hears various voices, looks at various plans, sees various maps and illustrations. But when he comes in person and sees certain aspects with his own eyes, when he looks at what the terrain looks like, what the situation is, how everything actually works, what the infrastructure is—then he truly sees what the needs are. Especially if he has such vast experience as President Joe Biden.

Dorota Bawołek, Polsat News: Thank you. Actually, my colleague has already asked the question. But indeed, there is no agreement for a peace mission, as the Secretary General clearly stated today. As for increasing NATO's military presence in Poland and changing its nature from rotational to permanent, no decisions have been made either. Perhaps something has at least moved regarding the MiGs? How would you assess the outcomes of this summit for our country?

Madam Editor, I have just under seven years of experience in serving as the President of the Republic. I have already attended a whole series of NATO summits. The decision to establish the presence of the North Atlantic Alliance on the eastern flank took us over six months of work. We visited all member countries during that time. I spoke personally with all the Presidents before that decision was made. So please forgive me that today, four or five days after the summit was announced and took place, no specific decisions have been formulated. However, considering how NATO operates, this time was too short.

One decision was made today by acclamation, but the truth is that it is a decision we have been discussing for several months, and absolutely since the moment Ukraine was actually attacked by Russia—it is the decision to extend the mandate of the Secretary General, Jens Stoltenberg. It was made today by acclamation, amid thanks and applause from all members of the Alliance. This is very important.

We are grateful to the Secretary General for—having the opportunity for a much calmer service to his country, which his country provided him—he nevertheless decided to remain here in this very difficult situation as a coordinator, as the leader of the North Atlantic Alliance here in Brussels. Because it is a very responsible decision in a very difficult situation—not easy for the Alliance, not easy for Europe, not easy for the world. And this stability was very much needed by the Alliance.

Moreover, it is not hard to imagine a situation in which a new Secretary General is elected. Before this new person gets into all the topics, into the specifics of how the Alliance functions, into the specifics of how the Secretary General functions as the linchpin of the entire Community—time passes. And today there is no time for someone to prepare for the role. Today, we need someone decisive who makes decisions. And we know, because we have seen it in recent years, that Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg can make decisions—and they are good decisions. Throughout the time I have been here in Brussels, and observing his work closely, and having met with him many times, I do not recall a single situation in which he made a wrong decision. Therefore, for me, it was an obvious matter, and everyone expressed gratitude that he took on this mission for this next period, now, in a difficult moment.

Madam Editor, as I said, all decisions are implemented when they are made as allied decisions. And if allied decisions are made in this regard, they will be implemented in an allied manner. Simply put.